The American Pie Company is a beloved destination for pie enthusiasts and comfort food lovers alike, offering a diverse menu that satisfies cravings for both sweet and savory flavors. Known for its warm, flaky crusts and rich fillings, this establishment has carved a niche in the culinary world by blending traditional recipes with creative twists.
Whether you’re stopping by for a hearty meal or a delightful dessert, the menu promises an experience that honors classic American pie-making while embracing modern tastes.
From timeless favorites like chicken pot pie to innovative seasonal specials, the American Pie Company’s menu is thoughtfully curated to cater to a wide range of palates. Each pie is crafted with fresh ingredients and attention to detail, ensuring every bite tells a story of comfort and quality.
The atmosphere of the restaurant complements the menu perfectly, making it a go-to spot for family dinners, casual lunches, or celebratory gatherings.
Exploring the menu reveals a commitment to authentic flavors and customer satisfaction. Whether you prefer sweet or savory, light or indulgent, the American Pie Company’s offerings showcase the versatility and charm of pies as a culinary tradition.
The following sections delve into the various categories and highlights of their menu, providing insight into what makes this dining experience truly exceptional.
Savory Pies
The savory pie selection at the American Pie Company is a testament to hearty, satisfying meals wrapped in a golden crust. These pies serve as a filling lunch or dinner option, featuring a blend of meats, vegetables, and rich sauces.
Each pie is baked to perfection, balancing a crisp exterior with a moist, flavorful interior.
Classic options like the Chicken Pot Pie stand out for their comforting, homestyle appeal. Tender chicken chunks combine with fresh vegetables and creamy gravy, all encased in a buttery crust that melts in your mouth.
For those seeking a meatier experience, the Beef & Mushroom pie offers a robust filling with slow-cooked beef and earthy mushrooms seasoned with herbs.
Vegetarian diners are not left behind. The Vegetable Medley pie features a colorful assortment of seasonal vegetables, complemented by a savory herb sauce.
This option highlights the company’s dedication to inclusivity and quality ingredients.
Popular Savory Pie Varieties
- Chicken Pot Pie: Classic comfort food with chicken, peas, carrots, and creamy sauce.
- Beef & Mushroom: Slow-cooked beef with mushrooms and rich gravy.
- Vegetable Medley: Seasonal vegetables in a savory herb sauce.
- Turkey Cranberry: A festive option combining turkey with a tangy cranberry glaze.
“The savory pies at American Pie Company bring back the warmth of home-cooked meals with every bite.”
Sweet Pies
When it comes to sweet offerings, the American Pie Company excels in delivering decadent desserts that celebrate classic American flavors. The sweet pie menu showcases everything from fruit-filled favorites to rich, creamy concoctions.
Each pie is prepared with the freshest ingredients, often featuring seasonal fruits and carefully balanced sweetness.
Apple Pie, a staple on the menu, is crafted using tart and sweet apples, spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg, and baked until the crust is perfectly flaky. For chocolate lovers, the Chocolate Silk Pie offers a smooth, velvety filling that melts on the tongue, topped with whipped cream for added indulgence.
Other sweet options include the Pecan Pie, known for its crunchy texture and caramelized filling, and the Lemon Meringue Pie, which combines tangy lemon custard with fluffy meringue topping. These pies are ideal for sharing or as a satisfying solo treat.
Signature Sweet Pie Flavors
| Pie Type | Main Ingredients | Flavor Profile |
| Apple Pie | Apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar | Sweet and mildly spiced |
| Chocolate Silk | Chocolate ganache, cream, sugar | Rich and creamy |
| Pecan Pie | Pecans, caramel, brown sugar | Sweet and nutty |
| Lemon Meringue | Lemon custard, egg whites, sugar | Tart and sweet with fluffy texture |
“No pie is too sweet when crafted with passion and the finest ingredients.”
Seasonal Specials
The American Pie Company embraces seasonality by offering specials that highlight ingredients at their peak freshness. These pies often rotate based on the time of year, providing customers with a unique taste experience that reflects the changing seasons.
During the fall, expect to find Pumpkin Spice Pie, which combines the warm flavors of cinnamon, ginger, and cloves with a smooth pumpkin filling. Winter brings hearty meat pies infused with root vegetables and savory herbs, perfect for cold nights.
Spring and summer introduce lighter options featuring fresh berries and stone fruits, such as Strawberry Rhubarb Pie or Peach Cobbler Pie.
These specials not only diversify the menu but also demonstrate the company’s commitment to quality and creativity. Utilizing local produce whenever possible ensures that these pies deliver optimal flavor and freshness.
Examples of Seasonal Specials
- Fall: Pumpkin Spice Pie, Sweet Potato Pie
- Winter: Lamb and Rosemary Pie, Beef and Root Vegetable Pie
- Spring: Strawberry Rhubarb Pie, Asparagus and Cheese Pie
- Summer: Peach Cobbler Pie, Blueberry Pie
“Seasonal pies connect us to the rhythms of nature and the bounty of each harvest.”
Gluten-Free and Dietary Options
The American Pie Company acknowledges the importance of catering to diverse dietary needs by providing gluten-free and other special diet options. This thoughtful approach ensures that pie lovers with restrictions can still enjoy delicious, safe meals without compromise.
Gluten-free crusts are crafted with alternative flours and careful preparation to maintain the signature flaky texture. These pies are available in both savory and sweet varieties, accommodating those with gluten sensitivities or celiac disease.
Additionally, some pies are made with reduced sugar or dairy-free alternatives to support diabetic or lactose-intolerant customers.
Clear labeling and staff knowledge help diners make informed choices, enhancing the overall experience. This inclusivity reflects the company’s dedication to customer care and culinary innovation.
Key Dietary-Friendly Options
| Pie Name | Dietary Feature | Notes |
| Gluten-Free Chicken Pot Pie | Gluten-Free | Uses almond flour crust |
| Vegan Vegetable Pie | Vegan, Dairy-Free | Made without eggs or dairy |
| Low-Sugar Apple Pie | Reduced Sugar | Sweetened with natural sugar substitutes |
| Dairy-Free Chocolate Pie | Dairy-Free | Uses coconut cream instead of dairy |
“Everyone deserves a slice of pie, regardless of dietary restrictions.”
Accompaniments and Sides
To complement their pies, the American Pie Company offers a variety of sides and accompaniments designed to enhance the overall meal. These options range from light salads to hearty soups, providing balance and variety.
Fresh garden salads with seasonal vegetables and house-made dressings add a crisp, refreshing contrast to the richness of pies. Soups, such as tomato bisque or creamy potato leek, are popular choices that pair well with savory pies.
For those seeking extra comfort, mashed potatoes or steamed vegetables round out the plate perfectly.
These sides are thoughtfully prepared to maintain the same high standards as the pies themselves, ensuring that every element of the meal contributes to satisfaction and enjoyment.
Popular Side Dishes
- Garden Salad: Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, and vinaigrette.
- Tomato Bisque: Creamy soup with fresh tomatoes and basil.
- Mashed Potatoes: Buttery and smooth, made from scratch.
- Steamed Seasonal Vegetables: Lightly seasoned and perfectly cooked.
“A great pie deserves the perfect side to create a memorable meal.”
Beverage Pairings
The American Pie Company thoughtfully curates a beverage menu designed to complement their pies, enhancing the dining experience through carefully selected drinks. From classic soft drinks to specialty coffees and teas, the beverage options are crafted to suit every taste and occasion.
For savory pies, robust red wines and craft beers are recommended to balance rich flavors. Sweet pies pair beautifully with lighter beverages such as dessert wines, herbal teas, or freshly brewed coffee.
Seasonal drink specials often accompany the pie specials, offering unique flavor combinations that highlight the pie’s ingredients.
Non-alcoholic options include house-made lemonades, flavored sodas, and artisanal iced teas. The staff is knowledgeable and happy to suggest pairings based on your pie choice, ensuring a harmonious and enjoyable meal.
Recommended Pairings
| Pie Type | Beverage | Flavor Match |
| Chicken Pot Pie | Chardonnay | Rich and buttery complement |
| Beef & Mushroom | Dark Ale | Earthy, malty balance |
| Apple Pie | Cinnamon Spiced Cider | Warm, sweet spice harmony |
| Chocolate Silk | Espresso | Bitter contrast to sweet chocolate |
“The right drink can elevate a pie from delicious to unforgettable.”
Ordering and Customization
Flexibility and customer satisfaction are key principles at the American Pie Company, reflected in their ordering and customization options. Whether dining in, ordering takeout, or catering for special events, the company strives to meet individual preferences and dietary needs.
Customers can choose from whole pies or individual slices, perfect for sampling multiple flavors or enjoying a single serving. Custom pie orders are welcomed, allowing for ingredient substitutions, crust preferences, and special dietary accommodations.
The staff works closely with customers to ensure that every order is tailored to their specific requirements.
Online ordering and delivery services make enjoying American Pie Company pies convenient and accessible, whether at home or the office. Regular promotions and seasonal offers add value and variety for frequent customers.
Customization Options
- Crust Choices: Traditional, gluten-free, whole wheat
- Filling Modifications: Extra vegetables, reduced salt, vegan substitutions
- Portion Sizes: Whole pies, half pies, individual slices
- Special Occasion Orders: Customized messages, themed decorations
“Personalized pies make every occasion special and every meal memorable.”
With a menu that thoughtfully balances tradition and innovation, the American Pie Company invites everyone to enjoy the timeless delight of a well-made pie. Their dedication to quality ingredients, diverse options, and exceptional customer service creates an inviting atmosphere where every visit feels like a celebration of flavor and comfort.
Whether savoring a savory entrée, indulging in a sweet dessert, or exploring seasonal creations, guests can expect a culinary experience that honors the rich heritage of American pie-making while embracing contemporary tastes.
Embracing dietary needs, beverage pairings, and customizable options further elevates the dining experience, making the American Pie Company a standout choice for pie lovers across all preferences and occasions.
From casual lunches to festive gatherings, their menu offers a slice of tradition and innovation that keeps customers coming back for more. The commitment to freshness, flavor, and variety ensures that every bite is memorable, warm, and satisfying—true hallmarks of a great pie experience.
