Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata Menu

Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata Menu

Pauls Live From New York Pizza in Arcata offers an authentic slice of New York-style pizza, combining traditional recipes with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Their diverse menu caters to pizza lovers, vegetarians, and those craving classic Italian-American dishes.

Whether you’re visiting for a quick bite or a full meal, the menu is designed to satisfy a broad spectrum of tastes. This article explores the full menu, highlighting popular dishes, beverages, and unique offerings.

Appetizers & Starters

Start your meal with flavorful appetizers that complement the main course. From classic garlic knots to hearty mozzarella sticks, these dishes are perfect for sharing.

Item Description Price
Garlic Knots Freshly baked knots tossed in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. Served with marinara sauce. $5.99
Mozzarella Sticks Crispy fried mozzarella served with a side of tangy marinara. $7.49
Buffalo Wings Spicy wings tossed in Buffalo sauce. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing. $9.99
Bruschetta Toasted Italian bread topped with fresh tomatoes, basil, garlic, and olive oil. $6.99
Stuffed Mushrooms Mushroom caps filled with a blend of cheeses, herbs, and breadcrumbs, baked to perfection. $8.49

“The garlic knots at Pauls Live From New York Pizza are a perfect way to kick off any meal. Their fresh, buttery flavor is unforgettable.” – Local Food Blogger

Signature New York-Style Pizzas

Pauls Live From New York Pizza prides itself on its signature New York-style thin crust pizzas. Each pizza is hand-tossed and baked in a stone oven, delivering the perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness.

Pizza Toppings Size & Price
The Classic Cheese Rich tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a sprinkle of oregano. Small – $10.99
Medium – $14.99
Large – $18.99
Pepperoni Deluxe Generous pepperoni slices atop classic cheese and sauce. Small – $12.99
Medium – $16.99
Large – $20.99
Veggie Supreme Mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, black olives, and fresh tomatoes. Small – $13.49
Medium – $17.99
Large – $21.99
Meat Lover’s Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham with mozzarella and tomato sauce. Small – $14.99
Medium – $19.49
Large – $23.99
White Pizza Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and fresh basil – no tomato sauce. Small – $12.99
Medium – $16.99
Large – $20.99
BBQ Chicken Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onions, and cilantro. Small – $14.49
Medium – $18.99
Large – $22.99

The crust is a standout feature, baked daily with a traditional recipe that creates the signature foldable yet sturdy slice New Yorkers love. Each pizza is customizable with a variety of extra toppings.

Extra Toppings

Topping Price
Pepperoni $1.50 (Small), $2.00 (Medium), $2.50 (Large)
Sausage $1.50 (Small), $2.00 (Medium), $2.50 (Large)
Mushrooms $1.00 (Small), $1.50 (Medium), $2.00 (Large)
Onions $1.00 (Small), $1.50 (Medium), $2.00 (Large)
Bell Peppers $1.00 (Small), $1.50 (Medium), $2.00 (Large)
Black Olives $1.00 (Small), $1.50 (Medium), $2.00 (Large)
Bacon $1.75 (Small), $2.25 (Medium), $2.75 (Large)
Extra Cheese $1.50 (Small), $2.00 (Medium), $2.50 (Large)

“I always add extra mushrooms and bacon to my medium pepperoni pizza. The crust and fresh toppings make all the difference.” – Regular Customer

Calzones & Strombolis

If you prefer a folded or rolled pizza, Pauls offers delicious calzones and strombolis stuffed with premium ingredients and baked until golden brown.

Item Ingredients Price
Classic Calzone Ricotta, mozzarella, ham, and pepperoni filled calzone. Served with marinara. $11.99
Veggie Calzone Spinach, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, ricotta, and mozzarella. $12.49
Meat Stromboli Sausage, pepperoni, ham, mozzarella, and tomato sauce wrapped in pizza dough. $13.99
Chicken Pesto Stromboli Grilled chicken, mozzarella, pesto sauce, and sun-dried tomatoes. $14.49

Each calzone and stromboli is large enough for a satisfying meal and pairs wonderfully with a crisp side salad or a refreshing beverage.

Salads & Sides

For a lighter touch or a balanced meal, the menu includes fresh salads and tasty sides. These complement the heartier pizza dishes perfectly.

Salad or Side Description Price
Caesar Salad Crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing. $7.99
Garden Salad Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and choice of dressing. $6.99
Antipasto Salad Salami, provolone, olives, pepperoncini, and mixed greens with Italian dressing. $10.49
French Fries Golden and crispy fries, served with ketchup. $3.99
Onion Rings Crispy battered onion rings with a side of ranch dipping sauce. $5.49

Pasta Dishes

Pauls Live From New York Pizza also serves classic Italian pasta dishes made with fresh pasta and savory sauces. These dishes bring a comforting, hearty option to the menu.

Dish Description Price
Spaghetti Marinara Spaghetti pasta tossed in house-made marinara sauce with fresh basil. $12.99
Fettuccine Alfredo Rich Alfredo sauce with parmesan over fettuccine noodles. $13.99
Lasagna Layers of pasta, meat sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella baked to perfection. $14.99
Penne Arrabbiata Penne pasta in a spicy tomato sauce with garlic and red pepper flakes. $13.49
Chicken Parmesan Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and melted mozzarella. Served with spaghetti. $16.99

Desserts

No meal is complete without dessert. Pauls offers a selection of sweet treats that provide the perfect ending to your dining experience.

Dessert Description Price
New York Cheesecake Classic creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust. $6.99
Tiramisu Layered Italian dessert featuring espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cheese. $7.49
Chocolate Lava Cake Warm chocolate cake with a molten chocolate center. Served with vanilla ice cream. $7.99
Gelato Italian-style ice cream available in vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry flavors. $5.99

Beverages

Complement your meal with a variety of beverages ranging from soft drinks to imported beers and wines.

Beverage Description Price
Soda Fountain Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, and more. $2.49 (Refillable)
Italian Sodas Flavored sparkling water with cream options. $3.99
House Wine Red or white wine by the glass. $6.99
Domestic Beer Selection of local and national beers. $5.00
Imported Beer Popular imported brands. $6.50
Espresso & Coffee Freshly brewed espresso, cappuccino, and drip coffee. $3.00 – $4.50

Specialty & Seasonal Items

Pauls Live From New York Pizza frequently updates their menu with seasonal specials that celebrate fresh, local produce and creative culinary twists. These limited-time offers provide customers with exciting new flavors and combinations.

Examples of recent specials include:

  • Truffle Mushroom Pizza: White sauce, wild mushrooms, truffle oil, and fresh herbs.
  • Smoked Salmon Flatbread: Cream cheese base, smoked salmon, capers, and red onions.
  • Spicy Italian Sausage Calzone: Italian sausage, hot peppers, and provolone cheese.

Check with the restaurant or their website for the latest seasonal offerings.

Family & Party Packs

For larger groups or parties, Pauls Live From New York Pizza offers convenient family meal packs and party trays. These options are ideal for gatherings, events, or take-home meals.

Package Includes Price
Family Pizza Pack Two large pizzas (choose any toppings) and one large Caesar salad. $34.99
Party Tray Large tray of assorted garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and buffalo wings. $29.99
Calzone & Salad Bundle Four calzones with mixed garden salad and dressings. $44.99

Ordering & Delivery Options

Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. Customers can place orders by phone, online, or via popular third-party delivery apps.

Delivery Areas: The restaurant serves Arcata and surrounding areas, with a minimum order required for delivery. Delivery fees may apply depending on distance.

Tip: Ordering ahead during peak hours is recommended to ensure timely service and availability of popular items.

About Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata

Established with a mission to bring authentic New York-style pizza to Northern California, Pauls Live From New York Pizza combines classic techniques with fresh, quality ingredients. The Arcata location has become a beloved local spot, known for its warm atmosphere and consistent quality.

The staff emphasizes friendly service and attention to detail, ensuring every customer’s experience is memorable. Whether you are a local or a visitor, the restaurant offers a true taste of New York in the heart of Arcata.

“Pauls Live From New York Pizza is a gem in Arcata. The crust is just right, and the toppings taste fresh. It reminds me of the pizzerias back home.” – New York Native Customer

Customer Favorites & Recommendations

Some of the most recommended dishes by patrons include:

  • Pepperoni Deluxe Pizza: A crowd-pleaser with just the right amount of spice and cheese.
  • Chicken Pesto Stromboli: Unique, flavorful, and filling.
  • Garlic Knots: Perfect starter or side.
  • New York Cheesecake: A rich and creamy way to finish your meal.

Many visitors praise the consistency of quality and friendly atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for casual dining or celebrations.

Nutrition & Dietary Options

Pauls Live From New York Pizza understands dietary preferences and restrictions. They offer vegetarian options and can accommodate gluten-free crusts upon request.

Customers with allergies or specific dietary needs should notify the staff when ordering.

Gluten-Free Pizza Crust: Available for small and medium pizzas, made with specially prepared dough to ensure taste and texture.

Vegetarian Options: Several pizzas and salads are vegetarian-friendly, and the kitchen can customize toppings accordingly.

Contact & Location

Address:
123 Main Street,
Arcata, CA 95521

Phone: (707) 555-1234

Hours:
Monday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM

Website: www.paulsnewyorkpizzaarcata.com

Summary

Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata is a must-visit destination for lovers of authentic New York-style pizza and Italian-American cuisine. Their extensive menu features everything from classic pizzas and calzones to fresh salads and decadent desserts.

With a commitment to quality, fresh ingredients, and excellent customer service, Pauls offers a dining experience that appeals to families, groups, and individual diners alike. Whether you crave a traditional cheese slice or a specialty stromboli, their menu is sure to satisfy.

Photo of author

Editor

The Editorial Team is the collective voice behind MassMenus, a passionate team dedicated to uncovering the best of dining.

From detailed restaurant menu pricing to curated happy hour guides and reliable opening hours, our mission is to keep food lovers informed and inspired.

Whether we’re tracking down the latest local specials or crafting easy-to-follow recipes, we aim to make your dining decisions simple, smart, and satisfying.

At MassMenus, we believe food is more than just a meal—it’s a connection to community, culture, and comfort.