Welcome to the world of My NY Pizza, where tradition meets innovation in every slice. Our menu is a vibrant celebration of New York-style pizza, crafted with passion, precision, and the finest ingredients.
Whether you crave the classic thin, foldable crust or an adventurous pie loaded with gourmet toppings, My NY Pizza offers a diverse selection designed to delight every palate. Each pizza is a story — from the heritage of hand-stretched dough to the tangy, robust tomato sauce that ties the flavors together seamlessly.
Our commitment goes beyond just serving pizza; it’s about creating an experience that brings people together, whether it’s a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night craving. Every bite promises authenticity with a modern twist, reflecting the dynamic spirit of New York City itself.
Explore our menu to find beloved staples alongside unique creations that push the boundaries of traditional pizza making, ensuring that each visit is a new culinary adventure.
Discover how My NY Pizza blends time-honored techniques with fresh ideas to craft pies that are both comforting and exciting. From the simplicity of a Margherita to the bold flavors of signature specialty pizzas, our menu is an invitation to taste the essence of NYC’s pizza culture.
Classic New York-Style Pizzas
The heart of My NY Pizza’s offerings lies in our classic New York-style pizzas, which embody the city’s iconic thin crust and rich flavors. These pizzas are designed to be foldable, crispy on the outside, yet soft and chewy inside, making them perfect for eating on the go or savoring slowly.
Each classic pie starts with our hand-stretched dough, made fresh daily. We use a special blend of high-gluten flour that gives the crust its characteristic texture and strength.
Our sauce, a secret family recipe, balances sweetness with acidity, highlighting ripe plum tomatoes and a blend of Italian herbs.
Toppings are simple yet high quality, allowing the base flavors to shine. Our cheeses are imported directly from Italy or sourced from trusted local dairies, ensuring a perfect melt and rich mouthfeel.
Whether you prefer a plain cheese pizza or a pepperoni-topped slice, every option reflects the essence of NYC’s pizza tradition.
- Hand-stretched dough for optimal texture
- Signature tomato sauce with a balanced flavor profile
- Premium mozzarella cheese for perfect melt
- Classic toppings including pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions
Essential Classics
Our menu features beloved classics such as the Cheese, Pepperoni, and White Pizza. The Cheese pizza is a celebration of simplicity, highlighting the creamy mozzarella atop our perfectly baked crust.
Pepperoni adds a spicy, aromatic kick with slices that crisp just right, while the White Pizza offers a rich blend of ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic for those seeking something different.
“The true magic of a New York pizza lies in its simplicity — quality ingredients, a well-made crust, and the perfect balance of sauce and cheese.”
Specialty Gourmet Pizzas
For those looking to explore beyond tradition, our specialty gourmet pizzas offer inventive combinations that marry bold flavors with classic techniques. These pies are crafted to surprise and satisfy, using fresh, seasonal ingredients and unique blends of cheeses and sauces.
Each gourmet pizza is thoughtfully composed, combining textures and tastes that complement one another. From the earthy richness of wild mushrooms to the peppery bite of arugula, these pizzas are designed to provide a layered experience in every slice.
We also incorporate house-made sauces like pesto, spicy arrabbiata, and garlic-infused olive oil to elevate the flavor profiles.
These specialty selections reflect the creativity of our kitchen while respecting the integrity of New York-style pizza. They are perfect for diners eager to try something new and memorable.
- Wild Mushroom Medley with truffle oil drizzle
- Fig and Prosciutto with balsamic glaze
- Spicy Italian Sausage with roasted peppers
- BBQ Chicken Deluxe with red onions and cilantro
Flavor Profiles Compared
| Pizza | Main Toppings | Sauce Base | Unique Element |
| Wild Mushroom Medley | Assorted Wild Mushrooms, Fontina Cheese | Garlic Olive Oil | Truffle Oil Drizzle |
| Fig and Prosciutto | Fresh Figs, Prosciutto, Goat Cheese | None (Olive Oil Base) | Balsamic Glaze |
| Spicy Italian Sausage | Italian Sausage, Roasted Peppers, Parmesan | Classic Tomato Sauce | Crushed Red Pepper |
| BBQ Chicken Deluxe | Grilled Chicken, Red Onions, Cilantro | BBQ Sauce | Smoky Flavor |
Build Your Own Pizza
Customization is at the heart of the My NY Pizza experience. Our Build Your Own Pizza option allows guests to select from a wide range of bases, sauces, cheeses, and toppings to craft the perfect pie tailored to their preferences.
This section caters to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters, offering flexibility and creativity. Whether you desire a gluten-free crust or a vegan cheese alternative, we provide options that accommodate dietary needs while maintaining exceptional taste.
Our staff is always ready to offer suggestions and combinations that work well together, ensuring every pizza is balanced and flavorful. This interactive menu choice emphasizes personal expression through pizza.
- Choice of crust: Classic thin, whole wheat, gluten-free
- Sauces: Tomato, BBQ, Pesto, Garlic Olive Oil
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, Vegan Cheese, Ricotta, Parmesan
- Over 20 Toppings: From pepperoni to fresh basil
Popular Custom Combinations
Many guests enjoy pairing classic tomato sauce with mozzarella, pepperoni, and fresh basil for a timeless pie. Others prefer a white pizza base with ricotta, spinach, and mushrooms for a creamier, earthier taste.
For those seeking bold flavors, BBQ sauce with grilled chicken, red onions, and cilantro offers a smoky, tangy experience. Vegan customers often select our gluten-free crust topped with vegan cheese, roasted peppers, and artichokes for a satisfying plant-based option.
“Custom pizzas allow you to explore your personal taste while embracing the core elements of New York pizza craftsmanship.”
Signature Sides and Appetizers
Complementing our pizzas, My NY Pizza offers a curated selection of sides and appetizers designed to enhance your meal. These items showcase fresh ingredients and traditional recipes with a modern twist.
From crispy garlic knots to vibrant salads, our sides are crafted to balance flavors and textures. Many of these dishes are perfect for sharing, making them ideal companions for group dining or family gatherings.
We focus on quality and presentation, ensuring each appetizer is flavorful and visually appealing. These dishes not only satisfy hunger but also prepare the palate for the main attraction — our exceptional pizzas.
- Garlic Knots: Soft, buttery, with fresh herbs and parmesan
- Caesar Salad: Crisp romaine, house-made dressing, shaved parmesan
- Buffalo Wings: Spicy, tangy, served with blue cheese dip
- Bruschetta: Toasted baguette slices topped with fresh tomatoes and basil
Appetizer Pairings
Garlic knots pair beautifully with a classic Margherita pizza, adding a rich garlic flavor that complements the simplicity of cheese and tomato. The Caesar salad offers a refreshing contrast to heavier pies, cleansing the palate with its crispness and tangy dressing.
Buffalo wings are a favorite for those who enjoy a bit of heat, providing a savory and spicy start to the meal. Bruschetta’s fresh tomato and basil topping echoes the flavors found in many of our pizzas, creating a harmonious dining experience.
“A great pizza starts with great company and the perfect sides to set the tone.”
Desserts and Sweet Treats
No meal at My NY Pizza is complete without indulging in our dessert offerings. Our sweet treats are crafted to provide a delightful finish and celebrate classic New York flavors with a contemporary flair.
From rich, creamy cheesecakes to warm, gooey brownies, each dessert is made in-house to guarantee freshness. We also offer lighter options such as seasonal fruit cups and sorbets, catering to those seeking a balanced end to their meal.
Our desserts echo the same attention to detail found in our pizzas, ensuring every bite is memorable and satisfying.
- New York-Style Cheesecake: Smooth, creamy, with a graham cracker crust
- Chocolate Brownie Sundae: Warm brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and fudge
- Seasonal Fruit Sorbet: Refreshing and light, made with fresh fruit
- Cannoli: Traditional Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta cream
Sweet Highlights
Our New York-Style Cheesecake is a house specialty, rich yet light, perfect for those who love classic desserts. The Chocolate Brownie Sundae combines texture and temperature contrasts that excite the palate.
For a refreshing option, the Seasonal Fruit Sorbet uses only the freshest fruits available, providing a palate cleanser that is naturally sweet. Cannoli offers a taste of Italy, with crispy shells and creamy fillings that pair wonderfully with an espresso or dessert wine.
“Dessert is the final act of a meal — it should leave you smiling and eager for your next visit.”
Beverages and Pairings
My NY Pizza’s beverage selection complements our menu by offering a variety of options to suit every taste and occasion. From classic sodas and fresh juices to curated wines and craft beers, our drinks enhance the overall dining experience.
We carefully select beverages that pair well with the flavors found in our pizzas and appetizers. Whether you prefer a crisp lager to cut through a rich cheese pizza or a robust red wine to accompany a spicy sausage pie, our menu has thoughtful recommendations.
Non-alcoholic options include house-made lemonades and iced teas, all made fresh daily to provide refreshing alternatives.
- Craft Beers: Local and regional selections, rotating seasonally
- Wines: Red, white, and sparkling options chosen for pizza pairings
- House-made Lemonade: Sweet and tart, made with fresh lemons
- Classic Sodas and Iced Teas: Traditional favorites served chilled
Pairing Suggestions
| Pizza Type | Recommended Beverage | Flavor Notes |
| Classic Cheese | Light Lager or Sparkling Water | Refreshing, cleanses palate |
| Spicy Sausage | Robust Red Wine or IPA | Balances spice with boldness |
| BBQ Chicken | Sweet Riesling or Amber Ale | Complementary sweetness and smoke |
| Veggie Gourmet | Dry White Wine or Herbal Iced Tea | Enhances fresh, earthy flavors |
“The right beverage can elevate a pizza from delicious to unforgettable.”
Family and Group Meals
My NY Pizza understands that pizza is often a shared experience, so we offer family and group meal packages designed to satisfy large appetites and diverse tastes. These bundles provide value and convenience, making group dining easy and enjoyable.
Each group meal includes a selection of pizzas, sides, and drinks, thoughtfully combined to please everyone at the table. Options are customizable to accommodate dietary restrictions and preferences, ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests.
Whether it’s a casual gathering, celebration, or office lunch, these packages deliver quality and variety without compromise.
- Family Feast: Two large classic pizzas, garlic knots, salad, and drinks
- Group Gourmet: Four specialty pizzas, appetizers, and craft beer sampler
- Kids’ Combo: Personal pizza, side, and juice box
- Customizable Options: Gluten-free, vegan, and allergen-sensitive choices available
Benefits of Group Meals
Group meals offer a stress-free way to feed many people while enjoying a variety of flavors. They encourage sharing and conversation, making meals social and festive.
Our packages also help simplify ordering logistics, with everything coordinated through one easy transaction. This means less waiting, fewer complications, and more time spent enjoying great food and company.
“Pizza is best when shared — our group meals are designed to bring people together effortlessly.”
Conclusion
My NY Pizza’s menu is a genuine reflection of New York’s vibrant pizza culture, blending time-honored traditions with contemporary creativity. Every section, from our classic pies to gourmet specialties, build-your-own options, and thoughtfully curated sides and desserts, is crafted to provide an exceptional dining experience.
Our dedication to quality ingredients, authentic techniques, and customer satisfaction shines through each offering. The menu caters to diverse preferences and dietary needs, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.
Whether you’re seeking a quick slice, a fully customized pie, or a family feast, My NY Pizza delivers consistently delicious results.
Beyond the food itself, we aim to create moments of connection and celebration around every table. The careful beverage pairings, inviting sides, and sweet finales all work together to elevate your meal from ordinary to memorable.
At My NY Pizza, every meal is an opportunity to experience the rich flavors and communal spirit that make New York-style pizza beloved worldwide.
