Mill Creek Tavern is a renowned restaurant chain that offers a unique dining experience with its exceptional menu and inviting ambiance. Established in 1998, the restaurant has grown to become a local favorite, with two locations in Bayville, New York, and Comstock Park, Michigan.
The Bayville location, nestled in the heart of Long Island, boasts a warm and cozy atmosphere, perfect for intimate gatherings or family outings. The rustic decor, with its exposed brick walls and wooden accents, creates a charming and welcoming environment. This location is renowned for its exceptional American cuisine, featuring a diverse menu that caters to various tastes and dietary preferences.
On the other hand, the Comstock Park location in Michigan offers a more contemporary and vibrant setting. With its sleek design and open layout, it provides a lively atmosphere perfect for social gatherings and casual dining. This location is celebrated for its creative twist on classic American fare, incorporating locally sourced ingredients and innovative culinary techniques.
Both locations share a commitment to using high-quality, fresh ingredients and offering exceptional service. Mill Creek Tavern prides itself on its dedication to creating memorable dining experiences for its guests, whether they’re seeking a romantic evening out, a family celebration, or a casual night with friends.
Mill Creek Tavern Bayville, NY Menu
Nestled in the heart of Bayville, NY, Mill Creek Tavern offers a tantalizing menu that celebrates the diverse flavors of American cuisine. From the moment you step through the doors, you’re greeted with a warm and inviting ambiance, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.
Starters
Kick off your culinary journey with a selection of mouthwatering starters that are sure to whet your appetite. Indulge in the rich and velvety French Onion Soup, a classic favorite that’s been perfected with a blend of caramelized onions, savory broth, and a golden, melted cheese topping. For something lighter, the Lobster Bisque is a creamy delight, infused with the sweet essence of succulent lobster meat. Vegetarians will revel in the Kung Pao Cauliflower, a flavorful dish that combines crispy cauliflower florets with a tangy, spicy sauce and a sprinkle of roasted peanuts.
Popular Dishes
Mill Creek Tavern’s menu is a celebration of classic American fare with a modern twist. The Country Chicken Pot Pie is a comforting dish that will transport you back to your childhood, featuring tender chunks of chicken, fresh vegetables, and a buttery, flaky crust. For those seeking a heartier option, the Sauerbraten Short Ribs are a must-try, slow-braised to perfection and served with a rich, flavorful gravy. Vegetarians will delight in the Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak, a harmonious blend of perfectly cooked pasta, sautéed vegetables, and succulent, blackened skirt steak.
Entrees
The entree selection at Mill Creek Tavern is a true testament to the culinary team’s creativity and attention to detail. Indulge in a variety of salad options, each one featuring fresh, locally sourced ingredients and the option to add grilled chicken, shrimp, or steak for a heartier meal. Daily specials showcase the chef’s innovative flair, featuring seasonal ingredients and unique flavor combinations that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Specials
Mill Creek Tavern offers a range of tempting specials that are sure to delight both locals and visitors alike. The Mid Week Prix-Fixe Dinner is a popular choice, offering a three-course meal at an exceptional value. For seafood lovers, the Lobster Palooza is a must-try, featuring a variety of lobster-inspired dishes that celebrate the best of the ocean’s bounty.
Happy Hour
Unwind after a long day and indulge in Mill Creek Tavern’s Happy Hour specials. Enjoy half-price bar menu items, including an array of delectable appetizers and small plates, perfect for sharing with friends or colleagues. Pair your bites with one of the refreshing cocktails or local craft beers, all offered at discounted prices during Happy Hour.
Beverages
Mill Creek Tavern’s full bar offers a diverse selection of libations to complement your meal. From a well-curated wine list featuring both old-world and new-world varietals to a rotating selection of local micro-brews, there’s something to suit every palate. Craft cocktails are a specialty, with skilled bartenders creating innovative and classic concoctions using premium spirits and fresh ingredients.
Additional Services
Whether you’re planning a corporate event, a wedding, or a family gathering, Mill Creek Tavern’s catering services and private party facilities have you covered. Their experienced team will work closely with you to create a customized menu and ensure every detail is executed flawlessly, allowing you to sit back, relax, and enjoy the celebration.
Mill Creek Tavern Comstock Park, MI Menu
Appetizers
Kick off your dining experience with a tempting array of appetizers that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Indulge in the gooey goodness of our Queso Nachos, a heaping platter of crispy tortilla chips smothered in a rich, velvety cheese sauce, topped with fresh pico de gallo, jalapeños, and a dollop of sour cream. For those seeking a burst of flavor, the Chips & Salsa is a must-try, featuring house-made tortilla chips served with a zesty tomato salsa. Embrace the unexpected with our Pickle Fries, a delightfully crispy and tangy treat that will leave you craving for more.
Soup & Salad
Nourish your soul with our selection of soups and salads, perfect for a light meal or as a complement to your main course. Our soup of the day is always a comforting and flavorful option, crafted with the freshest ingredients and a touch of culinary magic. For a heartier option, try our Combo Deal, which pairs a bowl of soup with a crisp garden salad or a half sandwich, ensuring a satisfying and well-rounded meal.
Handhelds & Burgers
Satisfy your cravings with our mouthwatering selection of handhelds and burgers. From classic BLTs to innovative creations like the Blackened Chicken Wrap, each sandwich is a masterpiece of flavors and textures. For burger aficionados, our juicy patties are sure to delight, whether you opt for the classic Cheeseburger or venture into the realm of the Bacon & Bleu Burger, topped with crispy bacon and tangy bleu cheese crumbles.
Entrees
Prepare to embark on a culinary adventure with our entree selection, featuring a diverse range of flavors and cooking techniques. Indulge in the tender and flavorful Top Sirloin, grilled to perfection and served with your choice of sides. For seafood lovers, the Firecracker Salmon is a must-try, featuring a succulent filet glazed with a sweet and spicy sauce that will ignite your senses. Vegetarians can rejoice with our Vegetable Stir Fry, a medley of fresh veggies sautéed in a savory sauce and served over a bed of fluffy rice.
Kids Menu
We haven’t forgotten about our youngest diners! Our Kids Menu offers a variety of options to please even the pickiest eaters. From classic favorites like Chicken Tenders and Grilled Cheese to healthier choices like the Veggie Plate, we’ve got something for every little appetite. And don’t forget to save room for a scoop of creamy ice cream for dessert!
Beverages
Complement your meal with our impressive selection of beverages, including a rotating lineup of craft beers from local and regional breweries. Our full bar also offers a wide range of wines, cocktails, and non-alcoholic options to suit every taste. Whether you’re in the mood for a refreshing IPA, a bold cabernet, or a classic mojito, our knowledgeable bartenders are ready to craft the perfect libation.
Happy Hour
Unwind after a long day and take advantage of our Happy Hour specials. Join us for discounted appetizers, beer, wine, and cocktails, making it the perfect time to gather with friends or colleagues for a relaxing evening. Check our website or ask your server for the current Happy Hour menu and timings.
Dining Experience at Bayville Location
The Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville, NY, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements its delectable menu. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a cozy and rustic ambiance, with exposed brick walls, wood-beamed ceilings, and a crackling fireplace that sets the tone for a memorable dining experience.
The main dining room features a mix of comfortable booths and well-spaced tables, ensuring a sense of privacy and intimacy. The soft lighting and carefully curated decor create a relaxing and sophisticated vibe, making it an ideal spot for a romantic evening or a special occasion.
For those seeking an al fresco dining experience, the outdoor patio is a true gem. Surrounded by lush greenery and charming string lights, the patio offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of daily life. Whether you’re enjoying a leisurely brunch or a candlelit dinner under the stars, the outdoor seating area provides a delightful ambiance that perfectly complements the restaurant’s exceptional cuisine.
The service at Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville is nothing short of impeccable. The knowledgeable and attentive staff go above and beyond to ensure that every guest feels welcomed and well-cared for. From offering recommendations on wine pairings to accommodating dietary restrictions, the team is dedicated to providing a personalized and memorable dining experience.
Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor to the area, the Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville promises an unforgettable dining experience that combines exceptional cuisine with a warm and inviting atmosphere, making it a true gem on Long Island’s culinary scene.
Dining Experience at Comstock Park Location
The Mill Creek Tavern in Comstock Park, MI, offers a warm and inviting ambiance that perfectly complements its delectable menu offerings. With its rustic decor, featuring exposed brick walls, cozy booths, and a lively bar area, the restaurant exudes a welcoming atmosphere that encourages guests to linger and savor every moment.
One of the standout features of the Comstock Park location is the exceptional service provided by the friendly and knowledgeable staff. From the moment you step through the door, you’ll be greeted with a genuine smile and a commitment to ensuring your dining experience is nothing short of extraordinary. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular patron, the attentive staff will make you feel right at home.
For those seeking a more intimate setting, the Mill Creek Tavern in Comstock Park offers private dining options perfect for special occasions or corporate events. The Flamingo Room, a separate space within the restaurant, provides a private and elegant setting for gatherings of all sizes. With its own dedicated staff and customizable menu options, the Flamingo Room ensures that your event will be a truly memorable experience.
In addition to private dining, the Mill Creek Tavern in Comstock Park is an ideal venue for hosting a variety of events. From birthday celebrations and rehearsal dinners to corporate functions and holiday parties, the restaurant’s versatile spaces can accommodate groups of all sizes. The experienced event planning team will work closely with you to ensure every detail is meticulously planned and executed, creating an unforgettable experience for you and your guests.
Chef’s Signature Dishes
At Mill Creek Tavern, our chefs take great pride in crafting unique and flavorful dishes that showcase their culinary expertise. Each location boasts its own signature offerings that have become beloved by our loyal patrons.
Bayville, NY
One of the standout dishes at our Bayville location is the Country Chicken Pot Pie. This hearty and comforting dish features tender chunks of chicken, fresh vegetables, and a rich, creamy sauce, all encased in a buttery, flaky crust. It’s a true taste of home-cooked goodness that will warm your soul.
Another fan favorite is the Sauerbraten Short Ribs. These fall-off-the-bone short ribs are slowly braised in a tangy, sweet-and-sour marinade, resulting in a depth of flavor that’s simply irresistible. Served with a side of buttered egg noodles and seasonal vegetables, it’s a dish that perfectly balances comfort and sophistication.
Comstock Park, MI
At our Comstock Park location, the Firecracker Salmon is a must-try. This dish features a succulent salmon fillet glazed with a spicy-sweet firecracker sauce, delivering a delightful combination of heat and sweetness in every bite. It’s served with a side of jasmine rice and sautéed vegetables, making it a well-rounded and satisfying meal.
For those who appreciate a classic steak dish, the Top Sirloin is sure to impress. This premium cut of beef is expertly grilled to your desired doneness and served with a rich demi-glace sauce, garlic mashed potatoes, and seasonal vegetables. It’s a testament to our commitment to using only the finest ingredients and showcasing them in their purest form.
Seasonal and Special Menus
At Mill Creek Tavern, the culinary team takes great pride in showcasing the freshest seasonal ingredients in their ever-changing menu offerings. With each new season, diners can expect a delightful array of specials that celebrate the flavors of the moment.
Spring Delights
As the world awakens from its winter slumber, the spring menu at Mill Creek Tavern bursts with vibrant colors and flavors. Expect to find dishes featuring tender asparagus, crisp radishes, and sweet pea shoots, all sourced from local purveyors. The chefs also take advantage of the abundant seafood available during this season, crafting delectable preparations of fresh catch like halibut, salmon, and soft-shell crab.
Summer Sizzle
Summer is a time for outdoor dining and light, refreshing fare. Mill Creek Tavern’s summer menu is a true celebration of the season’s bounty, with tomatoes, zucchini, and corn taking center stage. Diners can indulge in refreshing salads, grilled specialties, and creative takes on classic summer favorites like lobster rolls and fish tacos.
Autumn Harvest
As the leaves turn and the air becomes crisp, Mill Creek Tavern’s menu reflects the rich, earthy flavors of autumn. Hearty squash, mushrooms, and root vegetables make their way into comforting dishes like risottos, stews, and pasta preparations. The chefs also showcase their skills with game meats, such as venison and wild boar, for a truly seasonal dining experience.
Winter Warmth
During the colder months, Mill Creek Tavern’s menu is designed to provide warmth and comfort. Expect to find rich, slow-cooked braises, hearty soups, and decadent desserts that showcase the best of winter’s offerings. The chefs also take advantage of the holiday season, creating special menus for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s Eve, featuring traditional favorites with a modern twist.
In addition to the seasonal menu changes, Mill Creek Tavern also offers a variety of special menus and events throughout the year. From prix-fixe dinners and wine pairings to themed brunches and holiday celebrations, there’s always something new and exciting to experience at this culinary destination.
Beverage Program
At Mill Creek Tavern, we take pride in our extensive beverage program, offering a carefully curated selection of wines, craft beers, and signature cocktails to complement our delectable cuisine.
Wine List
Our wine list is a true celebration of the finest vintages from around the world. Whether you prefer a crisp and refreshing white or a bold and full-bodied red, our knowledgeable staff is ready to guide you through our diverse collection. From the classic regions of France and Italy to the emerging wine-producing areas of the New World, our wine list is a journey of flavors waiting to be explored.
Craft Beer Selection
For beer enthusiasts, Mill Creek Tavern is a haven of craft brews. We have forged partnerships with local and regional breweries to bring you an ever-changing lineup of unique and flavorful beers. From hoppy IPAs and robust porters to refreshing lagers and tart sours, our taps are a testament to the artistry and creativity of the craft beer movement.
Signature Cocktails
Our skilled mixologists have crafted a menu of signature cocktails that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. Using premium spirits, fresh ingredients, and creative techniques, each cocktail is a work of art, designed to tantalize your taste buds and elevate your dining experience. Whether you prefer a classic Manhattan or a modern twist on a timeless favorite, our cocktail menu is sure to delight.
Family-Friendly Offerings
Mill Creek Tavern is a welcoming and family-friendly establishment, offering a delightful dining experience for guests of all ages. Both the Bayville, NY, and Comstock Park, MI locations feature a dedicated kids’ menu, ensuring that even the youngest diners can find something to satisfy their taste buds.
The kids’ menu at Mill Creek Tavern is a carefully curated selection of dishes that cater to the preferences of little ones. From classic favorites like chicken tenders and mac & cheese to healthier options like grilled chicken and steamed veggies, there’s something for every young palate. The portions are perfectly sized for smaller appetites, and the presentation is sure to delight the little ones.
To keep the kids entertained during their dining experience, Mill Creek Tavern provides a variety of activities and amenities. Coloring books and crayons are readily available, allowing children to unleash their creativity while waiting for their meals. Additionally, the restaurants offer high chairs and booster seats to ensure a comfortable and safe dining experience for the youngest guests.
Mill Creek Tavern understands the importance of creating a welcoming atmosphere for families, and their staff is trained to provide exceptional service to guests of all ages. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a casual family dinner, you can expect a warm and inviting environment that caters to the needs of both parents and children alike.
Reservations and Takeout Options
Making a reservation at Mill Creek Tavern is a breeze, ensuring you can enjoy a delightful dining experience without the hassle of waiting. Both the Bayville, NY, and Comstock Park, MI locations offer convenient online reservation systems through their respective websites. Simply select your desired date, time, and party size, and you’re all set.
For those preferring the traditional approach, friendly staff members are available to assist you with reservations over the phone. Call ahead, especially during peak hours, to secure your table and avoid any disappointment.
Mill Creek Tavern also caters to the needs of busy individuals and families by offering a comprehensive online ordering system for takeout and delivery. Browse through the digital menu, customize your order, and enjoy the restaurant’s delectable offerings from the comfort of your home or office.
Additionally, the tavern’s catering services are perfect for celebrating special occasions or hosting corporate events. Their experienced catering team will work closely with you to curate a personalized menu, ensuring a seamless and memorable experience for you and your guests.
Whether you’re seeking a cozy night out or a convenient meal on the go, Mill Creek Tavern’s reservation, online ordering, and catering services are designed to provide a hassle-free and enjoyable dining experience tailored to your preferences.