Celestino’s New York Pizza Menu stands as a vibrant tribute to the iconic flavors and rich heritage of New York-style pizza. Renowned for its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings, Celestino’s brings a slice of the Big Apple right to your table, blending traditional recipes with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
Whether you’re a longtime pizza aficionado or a newcomer eager to explore, this menu offers a diverse array of options designed to satisfy every craving. From classic cheese pies to innovative specialty pizzas, each item reflects the passion and craftsmanship that have become synonymous with Celestino’s name.
Crafted with a commitment to quality and authenticity, the menu pays homage to the classic New York pizza experience while incorporating modern twists that elevate each bite. The careful balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings creates a harmony of flavors that leaves a lasting impression.
Moreover, the inviting ambiance and attentive service complement the culinary offerings, making Celestino’s a destination for families, friends, and solo diners alike.
Exploring Celestino’s menu is a journey through the heart of New York’s pizza culture. Every choice is an opportunity to indulge in a time-honored tradition, perfected through years of dedication and culinary expertise.
Whether you prefer a simple slice or a fully loaded pie, Celestino’s ensures a memorable dining experience that celebrates the essence of New York pizza.
Classic Pizzas: A Timeless Foundation
The Classic Pizzas section of Celestino’s menu offers a selection of beloved staples that define New York-style pizza. These pies emphasize simplicity and quality, highlighting the essential components that make this style so enduring.
Each pizza features a thin, hand-tossed crust baked to perfection, topped with a balanced blend of sauce and cheese.
Among the standout options is the iconic Cheese Pizza, embodying the perfect marriage of tangy tomato sauce and melted mozzarella. This pie serves as a canvas for many of the other offerings, providing a familiar comfort to pizza lovers.
The Pepperoni Pizza adds a spicy, savory kick with generous slices of pepperoni that crisp beautifully in the oven.
For those seeking a bit more variety, the Mushroom and Onion Pizza combines earthy mushrooms and sweet onions, creating a savory, aromatic experience. These classics maintain a focus on traditional flavors, ensuring that Celestino’s remains true to the roots of New York pizza culture.
Signature Classic Options
- Cheese Pizza: Mozzarella, tomato sauce, hand-tossed crust
- Pepperoni Pizza: Classic pepperoni slices on cheese base
- Mushroom & Onion: Fresh mushrooms, caramelized onions
- Margherita: Fresh basil, mozzarella, light tomato sauce
“Our classic pizzas are a tribute to the original New York-style slice—simple, authentic, and endlessly satisfying.”
Specialty Pizzas: Bold Flavors with a Twist
Celestino’s Specialty Pizzas elevate the traditional New York slice by introducing bold flavor combinations and fresh ingredients. These pizzas are crafted to surprise and delight, appealing to adventurous eaters who crave something beyond the basics.
One of the most popular specialty pies is the BBQ Chicken Pizza, featuring tender chicken pieces smothered in tangy barbecue sauce, topped with red onions and cilantro. This pizza balances smoky, sweet, and savory notes in a way that complements the crisp crust.
The Mediterranean Pizza stands out with its fusion of feta cheese, black olives, sun-dried tomatoes, and artichoke hearts. It offers a refreshing and vibrant alternative, perfect for those seeking a lighter yet flavorful option.
Another highlight is the Spicy Italian Sausage Pizza, which combines spicy sausage with roasted peppers and a touch of crushed red pepper for those who enjoy heat with their meal.
Popular Specialty Choices
- BBQ Chicken: Grilled chicken, barbecue sauce, red onions, cilantro
- Mediterranean: Feta, olives, sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes
- Spicy Italian Sausage: Hot sausage, roasted peppers, chili flakes
- White Garlic: Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, spinach
| Pizza | Flavor Profile | Recommended Pairing |
| BBQ Chicken | Smoky, sweet, tangy | Craft beer or iced tea |
| Mediterranean | Fresh, savory, tangy | Light white wine |
| Spicy Italian Sausage | Spicy, robust, savory | Bold red wine |
| White Garlic | Creamy, garlicky, mild | Sparkling water or soft drinks |
Build-Your-Own Pizza: Customize Your Slice
Celestino’s Build-Your-Own Pizza option empowers customers to tailor their pie exactly to their preferences. This section is designed for those who enjoy crafting a personalized flavor profile, selecting from a wide variety of toppings to create a truly unique meal.
The foundation for every custom pizza is the classic hand-tossed crust, baked to a golden crisp. Customers choose their sauce, ranging from traditional tomato to white garlic or pesto, followed by a selection of cheeses and toppings.
This flexibility ensures that every pizza is a reflection of individual taste.
Popular toppings include pepperoni, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, various cheeses, and more exotic options such as anchovies or jalapeños. Vegans and vegetarians will appreciate the range of plant-based toppings and cheese alternatives available upon request.
Available Toppings
- Meats: Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, chicken, anchovies
- Vegetables: Mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, olives, spinach
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, ricotta, feta, vegan cheese
- Sauces: Tomato, white garlic, pesto, barbecue
“The build-your-own option is perfect for those who crave pizza that’s as unique as their own palate.”
Appetizers and Sides: Complement Your Meal
Beyond the pizzas, Celestino’s offers a thoughtfully curated selection of appetizers and sides that pair wonderfully with any pie. These dishes provide a balance of flavors and textures, enriching the overall dining experience.
Garlic knots are a perennial favorite, featuring soft, buttery dough baked with garlic and herbs, served with a side of marinara sauce. Another popular choice is the Caesar salad, crisp and refreshing, offering a lighter counterpoint to the rich pizza flavors.
The menu also includes buffalo wings, available in mild, hot, or barbecue sauces, catering to those who enjoy a bit of spice and protein alongside their meal. For something heartier, Celestino’s meatball sliders deliver robust flavor in a convenient bite-sized form.
Popular Appetizers
- Garlic Knots: Soft dough, garlic, herbs, marinara dip
- Caesar Salad: Romaine, parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing
- Buffalo Wings: Choice of sauce: mild, hot, barbecue
- Meatball Sliders: Mini sandwiches with meatball and marinara
| Appetizer | Description | Best Paired With |
| Garlic Knots | Buttery, garlicky bread knots | Classic cheese pizza |
| Caesar Salad | Crisp romaine with creamy dressing | Mediterranean pizza |
| Buffalo Wings | Spicy or sweet chicken wings | Spicy Italian sausage pizza |
| Meatball Sliders | Mini sandwiches with hearty meatballs | BBQ chicken pizza |
Beverages: Refreshments to Enhance Your Pizza
Celestino’s beverage selection is designed to complement the rich and varied flavors of its pizza offerings. From classic soft drinks to carefully selected wines and craft beers, the drinks menu caters to diverse tastes and dining preferences.
Soft drinks include all the familiar favorites, served chilled to refresh the palate between bites. For those seeking a more refined accompaniment, Celestino’s offers a curated list of red, white, and sparkling wines, chosen to pair perfectly with various pizza styles.
Craft beers from local breweries are also featured, providing bold and nuanced flavors that enhance the dining experience. Non-alcoholic options such as iced teas and flavored lemonades are available for guests of all ages.
Drink Options
- Soft Drinks: Cola, lemon-lime, root beer, diet options
- Wines: Merlot, Chardonnay, Pinot Grigio, Prosecco
- Craft Beers: IPAs, lagers, stouts from local breweries
- Non-Alcoholic: Iced tea, lemonade, sparkling water
“Pairing the right beverage with your pizza can elevate each flavor and create a memorable meal.”
Desserts: Sweet Endings to Your Meal
To conclude your Celestino’s experience, the dessert menu offers indulgent options that satisfy sweet cravings. These treats provide a perfect counterbalance to the savory flavors of pizza and sides, rounding out the meal with finesse.
The classic New York cheesecake is a standout, rich and creamy with a graham cracker crust that offers a delightful texture contrast. Chocolate lava cake provides a warm, gooey center that melts in your mouth, ideal for chocolate lovers.
For those seeking lighter fare, the fresh fruit tart showcases seasonal fruits atop a delicate pastry base with a hint of glaze. Each dessert is crafted with the same attention to quality and detail as the main dishes.
Dessert Selections
- New York Cheesecake: Creamy, dense, graham cracker crust
- Chocolate Lava Cake: Warm, molten chocolate center
- Fresh Fruit Tart: Seasonal fruits, pastry base, light glaze
- Gelato: Assorted flavors, creamy and refreshing
| Dessert | Description | Perfect Pairing |
| New York Cheesecake | Rich, creamy, traditional style | Espresso or dessert wine |
| Chocolate Lava Cake | Warm cake with molten chocolate | Milk or dark coffee |
| Fresh Fruit Tart | Light pastry with seasonal fruit | Herbal tea or sparkling water |
| Gelato | Creamy, various flavors | Fresh fruit or biscotti |
Gluten-Free and Vegan Options: Inclusive Dining
Celestino’s commitment to inclusivity is evident in its selection of gluten-free and vegan pizzas. These options ensure that dietary restrictions or lifestyle choices do not compromise the enjoyment of authentic New York-style pizza.
The gluten-free crust is crafted from high-quality alternative flours, providing a satisfying texture without the gluten. Paired with fresh toppings and vegan cheese substitutes, these pizzas maintain the delicious flavors Celestino’s is known for.
Vegan pizzas feature a variety of plant-based toppings and sauces, offering vibrant and creative flavor profiles. Whether you desire a simple vegan margherita or a fully loaded veggie pie, these options are thoughtfully prepared to delight every diner.
Gluten-Free and Vegan Highlights
- Gluten-Free Crust: Alternative flour blend, crispy texture
- Vegan Cheese: Plant-based mozzarella alternative
- Vegan Toppings: Spinach, mushrooms, olives, peppers
- Special Sauces: Vegan pesto, tomato sauce without dairy
“Everyone deserves a great pizza experience, regardless of dietary needs.”
Conclusion: Celebrating Tradition and Innovation
Celestino’s New York Pizza Menu masterfully balances the cherished traditions of classic New York-style pizza with innovative and inclusive options that cater to modern tastes. The menu’s diversity—from timeless cheese pizzas to bold specialty creations and customizable pies—ensures that every guest finds something to love.
Fresh ingredients, authentic preparation methods, and thoughtful pairings elevate each dish beyond mere sustenance into a memorable culinary experience.
Attention to detail extends beyond the pizzas themselves, with complementary appetizers, carefully selected beverages, and indulgent desserts rounding out the offerings. Moreover, Celestino’s dedication to accommodating gluten-free and vegan diets reflects a genuine commitment to hospitality and inclusivity.
Whether you visit for a quick slice or a full dinner with friends and family, Celestino’s delivers the rich flavors and warm atmosphere that define New York pizza culture. This menu is not just a list of options; it’s an invitation to savor a beloved tradition, reinvented with passion and care for every palate.
