Jaarsma Bakery stands as a testament to the enduring allure of Old World baking traditions, seamlessly blending history with modern tastes. Since opening its doors in Pella, Iowa, in 1898, the bakery has become a beloved culinary landmark, renowned for its unwavering commitment to quality and authenticity.
Visitors and locals alike are drawn in by the warm aroma of freshly baked pastries, the inviting displays of delicacies, and the welcoming atmosphere that only a family-owned establishment can provide.
The Jaarsma Bakery menu is a vibrant tapestry of Dutch heritage, offering an impressive range of sweet and savory options to satisfy every craving. Each item, from their iconic Dutch letters to hearty breads and delicate cookies, is crafted with time-honored recipes passed down through generations.
The menu is more than just a list of baked goods—it’s a culinary journey through the flavors and textures that define Dutch baking culture.
Whether you are seeking a nostalgic treat, a unique gift, or a hearty snack, Jaarsma Bakery’s offerings promise to delight and surprise. Their dedication to using premium ingredients and traditional methods ensures that every bite is imbued with authenticity and care.
For food lovers, explorers, and anyone with an appreciation for craftsmanship, the Jaarsma Bakery menu delivers a memorable experience that lingers long after the last crumb is gone.
Signature Dutch Letters
The Dutch Letter is the crown jewel of Jaarsma Bakery’s menu, a symbol of tradition and craftsmanship. Shaped like the letter “S,” this flaky, almond-filled pastry is both visually striking and irresistibly delicious.
The bakery’s Dutch Letters are a cherished treat and a must-try for any visitor.
Crafted with layers of buttery puff pastry and filled with a rich almond paste, every Dutch Letter is hand-rolled and baked to golden perfection. The process follows a secret family recipe, preserving the authenticity that sets Jaarsma apart.
Each bite offers a delightful contrast between the crisp exterior and the sweet, moist filling.
Enjoying a Dutch Letter is more than indulging in a pastry—it’s embracing a piece of Dutch-American heritage. These pastries are particularly popular during local festivals and holidays, but their appeal endures year-round.
Guests often purchase them by the dozen, eager to share the unique flavor with friends and family.
“The Dutch Letter is not just a pastry—it’s a celebration of tradition and community, baked fresh every day at Jaarsma Bakery.”
- Almond-filled with a sweet, nutty center
- Flaky, buttery puff pastry exterior
- Shaped into the iconic letter “S” for “Sinterklaas”
- Available in boxes for gifts or special occasions
The Dutch Letter’s reputation extends beyond Iowa, attracting food enthusiasts from across the country. For those seeking the authentic taste of Dutch baking, there is simply no substitute.
Traditional Dutch Pastries
Jaarsma Bakery’s menu shines with a vibrant selection of traditional Dutch pastries, each crafted with love and steeped in history. These pastries offer a window into the Netherlands’ rich culinary heritage, featuring unique flavors and textures that set them apart from typical American baked goods.
Among the highlights is the Banket, a close cousin to the Dutch Letter. Banket is made with the same luscious almond filling but rolled into logs or bars.
Another standout is the Stroopwafel, a caramel-filled waffle cookie that pairs perfectly with coffee or tea. Guests are also drawn to Boterkoek, a dense, buttery cake with a delicate almond essence.
Each pastry is meticulously prepared using traditional techniques and high-quality ingredients. The attention to detail is evident in the pastries’ beautiful presentation and consistent flavor.
Whether enjoyed with a morning coffee or as an afternoon snack, these treats offer a comforting taste of home for Dutch-Americans and a delightful discovery for newcomers.
| Pastry | Description | Best Pairing |
| Banket | Almond-filled pastry log | Hot coffee |
| Stroopwafel | Thin waffle cookies with caramel | Tea or hot chocolate |
| Boterkoek | Buttery almond cake | Milk |
- Each pastry is prepared in small batches for freshness
- Available individually or by the tray for events
- Combines sweet and rich flavors unique to Dutch baking
The variety of traditional pastries ensures that every visit to Jaarsma Bakery feels like a new adventure. Exploring these options is the perfect way to expand your palate and appreciate the depth of Dutch culinary artistry.
Freshly Baked Breads
Bread baking is an art form at Jaarsma Bakery, where time-honored techniques and quality ingredients result in loaves that are both hearty and flavorful. The bakery’s selection of breads caters to a wide range of preferences, from rustic classics to innovative specialties.
Among the most popular choices is the Raisin Bread, studded with plump raisins and a hint of cinnamon for warmth. The Honey Wheat loaf offers a subtly sweet, nutty taste, while the Pumpernickel brings a robust earthiness to any meal.
Each bread is kneaded, shaped, and baked with care, ensuring a perfect crust and tender crumb.
Bread lovers will also appreciate Jaarsma’s French Bread and Multigrain options, perfect for sandwiches or toasting. The bakery’s commitment to freshness means that every loaf is baked daily and frequently sells out by midday.
Customers are encouraged to arrive early or pre-order to secure their favorites.
“Fresh bread is the foundation of every great meal. At Jaarsma Bakery, we believe in baking with patience, passion, and the finest ingredients.”
- Selection includes white, wheat, multigrain, and specialty breads
- Perfect for breakfast, lunch, or as an accompaniment to dinner
- Available sliced or whole upon request
- Ideal for gift baskets or special occasions
From simple toast to elaborate sandwiches, Jaarsma’s breads elevate every bite. The bakery’s devotion to tradition ensures that each loaf reflects the best of Dutch and American baking.
Cookies and Sweet Treats
Jaarsma Bakery’s cookies and sweet treats provide a delightful variety for those with a sweet tooth. Every cookie reflects the bakery’s dedication to quality, offering a tempting mix of flavors, textures, and shapes.
One of the most beloved treats is the Speculaas cookie, a crisp, spiced delight that embodies the essence of Dutch baking. These cookies are perfect for dipping in coffee or enjoyed on their own as a snack.
Another fan favorite is the Gevulde Koek, a soft, almond-filled cookie that melts in your mouth.
For those who appreciate a classic, Jaarsma’s butter cookies are a perennial favorite. Their rich, simple flavor and delicate crunch make them ideal for sharing or gifting.
The bakery also offers seasonal cookies, such as holiday-shaped sugar cookies and gingerbread, adding a festive touch to the menu.
- Speculaas: spiced and aromatic, with a hint of cinnamon and nutmeg
- Gevulde Koek: soft cookie with almond paste filling
- Butter Cookies: classic, crisp, and buttery
- Seasonal varieties available throughout the year
Each cookie is baked with the same attention to detail as the bakery’s larger pastries. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack, a thoughtful gift, or a sweet finish to a meal, the cookie selection at Jaarsma Bakery is sure to satisfy.
Savory Pies and Meat Pastries
Beyond its sweet offerings, Jaarsma Bakery excels in crafting savory pies and meat pastries that draw inspiration from Dutch family recipes. These hearty, flavorful options are perfect for lunch, dinner, or a satisfying snack on the go.
The Beef Pot Pie stands out as a customer favorite, featuring tender beef and vegetables in a rich gravy, all encased in a flaky, golden crust. The bakery’s Chicken Pie offers a comforting twist, while the Saucijzenbroodje (Dutch sausage roll) provides a savory, satisfying bite.
Each option is prepared with premium ingredients and baked fresh daily.
Jaarsma’s savory selection also includes vegetarian options, such as cheese and vegetable pies, ensuring that there’s something for everyone. These items are ideal for takeout lunches, picnics, or as the centerpiece of a casual family meal.
| Pie/Pastry | Main Ingredients | Serving Suggestion |
| Beef Pot Pie | Beef, vegetables, savory gravy | Lunch or dinner |
| Chicken Pie | Chicken, vegetables, creamy sauce | Picnics or quick meal |
| Saucijzenbroodje | Spiced sausage, flaky pastry | Snack or appetizer |
- Hearty, satisfying, and made with premium ingredients
- Available hot and ready to eat
- Vegetarian options available
- Perfect for on-the-go meals or gatherings
For those seeking savory comfort, Jaarsma’s pies and pastries deliver both flavor and tradition in every bite. The savory menu showcases the versatility and depth of Dutch cuisine.
Specialty Cakes and Celebration Desserts
Celebrations are made sweeter with Jaarsma Bakery’s specialty cakes and desserts. Each cake is a masterpiece, designed to delight both the eyes and palate, making any occasion truly memorable.
The bakery offers a range of classic and custom cakes, from rich chocolate tortes to light, fruit-filled sponge cakes. One standout is the Mocha Torte, a multi-layered cake with coffee-infused buttercream and chocolate ganache.
For those who prefer fruity flavors, the Strawberry Cream Cake is a refreshing choice, featuring layers of sponge, real whipped cream, and fresh strawberries.
Jaarsma’s cakes are not just for birthdays—they are a popular choice for weddings, anniversaries, and community celebrations. The bakery also creates seasonal desserts, such as pumpkin rolls and holiday yule logs, offering something special throughout the year.
“Every cake we make is a celebration of flavor and artistry, crafted with care to mark life’s most important moments.”
- Custom designs and flavors available on request
- Fresh, locally-sourced ingredients
- Available in a variety of sizes
- Perfect for birthdays, weddings, and holidays
The attention to detail in every cake ensures that your celebration is as delicious as it is memorable. For those seeking a dessert that stands out, Jaarsma Bakery’s specialty cakes are the perfect choice.
Beverages and Pairings
No bakery experience is complete without the perfect beverage to complement your treat. Jaarsma Bakery offers a thoughtfully curated selection of beverages designed to enhance the flavors of their baked goods and provide a moment of relaxation.
Coffee lovers will appreciate the bakery’s robust brew, which pairs especially well with almond pastries and buttery cookies. For tea enthusiasts, a variety of black, green, and herbal teas are available, each chosen to bring out the subtleties in the bakery’s sweets.
For a refreshing option, enjoy a glass of fresh milk or locally-sourced apple cider.
Pairing the right beverage with your bakery selection can elevate your tasting experience. For example, the spiced notes of speculaas are heightened by a warm chai, while a glass of cold milk balances the richness of boterkoek.
The bakery’s staff are always happy to recommend pairings based on your preferences.
| Beverage | Recommended Pairing | Tasting Notes |
| Coffee | Dutch Letters, Banket | Bold, smooth, enhances nutty flavors |
| Black Tea | Stroopwafels, Butter Cookies | Malty, slightly sweet |
| Milk | Boterkoek, Speculaas | Cool, creamy, balances spice |
| Apple Cider | Raisin Bread, Fruit Pies | Sweet, tart, refreshing |
- Hot and cold beverages available year-round
- Specialty drinks offered during holidays
- Staff can recommend the perfect pairing for your treat
Choosing the right drink enhances not just the flavor but the overall bakery experience. These thoughtful pairings make every visit to Jaarsma Bakery a sensory delight.
Gift Boxes and Shipping Options
Jaarsma Bakery understands the joy of sharing exceptional baked goods with loved ones, near or far. Their gift boxes and shipping options make it easy to send a taste of Dutch tradition to friends, family, or clients across the country.
Gift boxes are thoughtfully curated, featuring a mix of the bakery’s most popular items. Choose from assortments of Dutch Letters, cookies, pastries, and breads, all beautifully packaged and ready for any occasion.
Custom gift boxes are also available, allowing you to tailor the selection to suit the recipient’s tastes.
The bakery’s shipping service ensures that treats arrive fresh and in perfect condition, no matter the distance. Each order is carefully packed to maintain quality, with expedited options available for special events and holidays.
- Nationwide shipping available for most menu items
- Customizable gift boxes for birthdays, holidays, and corporate gifts
- Secure, attractive packaging
- Easy online ordering and tracking
“Sharing a Jaarsma Bakery gift box is more than giving a treat—it’s sending a piece of tradition, care, and connection.”
Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, expressing gratitude, or simply spreading joy, Jaarsma’s gift options are a thoughtful and delicious choice. The ability to share authentic Dutch flavors with loved ones makes every shipment special.
Conclusion
Jaarsma Bakery’s menu is a living celebration of Dutch baking heritage, lovingly preserved and shared with every customer who walks through the door. From the distinctive S-shaped Dutch Letters to the comforting warmth of fresh breads, every item reflects a deep respect for tradition, quality, and community.
The bakery’s diverse offerings cater to every taste, whether you crave something sweet, savory, or somewhere in between.
What sets Jaarsma apart is not just its recipes, but its devotion to excellence and authenticity. The menu is a testament to the power of family, history, and culture, creating a bridge between generations and across continents.
For locals, the bakery is a cherished fixture; for visitors, it is an unforgettable destination. The ability to share Jaarsma’s treats—through gift boxes, special occasions, or a simple cup of coffee—spreads joy and connection far beyond Pella.
In a world that often rushes past tradition, Jaarsma Bakery reminds us of the value of slowing down, savoring each bite, and honoring the flavors that have stood the test of time. Whether you’re enjoying a Dutch Letter for the first time or revisiting an old favorite, the menu at Jaarsma Bakery promises a memorable, delicious experience—one that invites you to return, again and again.
