Shelter Island Slice is a beloved pizzeria located in the heart of Shelter Island, known for its fresh ingredients, inventive toppings, and a cozy atmosphere that welcomes locals and visitors alike. The menu offers a diverse range of pizza slices crafted with care and passion, capturing the essence of classic New York-style pizza while embracing creative culinary twists.
Whether you are craving a traditional cheese slice or an adventurous flavor combination, Shelter Island Slice has something to delight every palate. The menu is thoughtfully organized to highlight specialty slices, build-your-own options, and complementary appetizers and beverages.
Signature Slices
The signature slices at Shelter Island Slice showcase the pizzeria’s unique approach to pizza making. Each slice is carefully prepared with high-quality dough, house-made sauce, and premium cheeses.
| Slice Name | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| The Island Classic | Tomato sauce, mozzarella, fresh basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. | $4.50 |
| BBQ Chicken Delight | Grilled chicken, smoky BBQ sauce, red onions, and cilantro. | $5.25 |
| Veggie Medley | Sautéed mushrooms, bell peppers, black olives, onions, and mozzarella. | $4.75 |
| Spicy Pepperoni | Classic pepperoni with a kick of crushed red pepper and mozzarella. | $4.95 |
| White Garlic | Ricotta, mozzarella, roasted garlic, and fresh parsley on a white sauce base. | $5.00 |
“The Island Classic is our most requested slice, loved for its simplicity and fresh flavors. It’s a perfect example of how great ingredients can create an unforgettable pizza experience.”
Build-Your-Own Slice
For those who enjoy customizing their pizza, Shelter Island Slice offers a build-your-own slice option. Customers can select their preferred crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings.
This flexibility ensures everyone can enjoy a slice tailored specifically to their tastes.
| Category | Options |
|---|---|
| Crust | Classic Hand-Tossed, Thin Crust, Gluten-Free (additional $1.50) |
| Sauce | Tomato Basil, White Garlic, BBQ, Pesto |
| Cheese | Mozzarella, Cheddar, Ricotta, Vegan Cheese (additional $1.00) |
| Toppings | Pepperoni, Sausage, Grilled Chicken, Mushrooms, Onions, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Spinach, Jalapeños, Pineapple, Fresh Basil, Sun-Dried Tomatoes |
Pricing: Base slice price starts at $4.00. Each additional topping is $0.75.
Gluten-free crust and vegan cheese have extra charges as noted.
Appetizers and Sides
To complement the delicious pizza slices, Shelter Island Slice offers a variety of appetizers and sides. These options are perfect for sharing or enjoying alongside your slice for a fuller meal experience.
| Item | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Garlic Knots | Freshly baked knots tossed in garlic butter and parsley. | $3.50 |
| Buffalo Wings | Spicy buffalo wings served with blue cheese dressing (6 pieces). | $7.00 |
| Caesar Salad | Crisp romaine, parmesan, croutons, and creamy Caesar dressing. | $5.50 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | Golden fried mozzarella sticks with marinara dipping sauce. | $6.00 |
| French Fries | Hand-cut fries seasoned with sea salt. | $3.00 |
Beverages
Shelter Island Slice provides a curated selection of beverages to complete your dining experience. From classic sodas to local craft beers, there is a drink to pair perfectly with every slice.
| Beverage | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Soda | Classic Coca-Cola, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer | $2.00 |
| Fresh Lemonade | House-made lemonade, served chilled. | $2.50 |
| Iced Tea | Fresh-brewed iced tea, sweetened or unsweetened. | $2.25 |
| Local Craft Beer | Rotating selection of Shelter Island and Long Island craft brews. | $6.00 |
| Red and White Wine | Selection of house wines by the glass. | $7.00 |
About Shelter Island Slice
Founded in 2010, Shelter Island Slice has grown from a small neighborhood pizzeria into a favorite dining destination. The owners pride themselves on sourcing local ingredients whenever possible and creating a welcoming environment where families, couples, and friends can enjoy quality pizza.
The team behind Shelter Island Slice is committed to maintaining a high standard of freshness and flavor. Their dough is made fresh daily, and the sauce is crafted from vine-ripened tomatoes blended with secret herbs and spices.
“We believe pizza is more than just food — it’s an experience. Our goal is to bring a slice of happiness to every customer who walks through our doors.”
Customer Favorites
While every item on the menu is carefully crafted, some slices and dishes have become customer favorites over the years. These popular choices reflect a variety of tastes, from classic simplicity to bold flavors.
- The Island Classic – Celebrated for its fresh basil and perfectly melted mozzarella.
- BBQ Chicken Delight – Loved for its smoky, tangy flavor profile.
- Garlic Knots – A perfect appetizer that pairs well with any slice.
- Buffalo Wings – Spicy and satisfying, ideal for wing enthusiasts.
- Fresh Lemonade – A refreshing accompaniment, especially during summer months.
Special Dietary Options
Shelter Island Slice understands the importance of accommodating various dietary preferences and restrictions. The menu includes options for vegetarians, vegans, and those seeking gluten-free choices.
Vegetarian Options: Many signature slices like the Veggie Medley are completely vegetarian. Additionally, the build-your-own slice allows for a fully customized vegetarian experience.
Vegan Choices: Customers can opt for vegan cheese and a wide selection of vegetable toppings. The thin crust and tomato basil sauce are naturally vegan.
Gluten-Free Crust: Available for an additional charge, the gluten-free crust is made from a special blend of rice flour and other gluten-free ingredients, providing a safe and delicious alternative.
Ordering and Delivery
Shelter Island Slice offers convenient ordering options to suit busy lifestyles. Customers can order in-person, by phone, or online through the official website and mobile app.
Delivery services are available within Shelter Island and surrounding neighborhoods. Orders over $20 qualify for free delivery, making it easy to enjoy favorite slices at home or the office.
For large groups and events, the pizzeria offers catering packages that include a variety of slices, sides, and beverages customized to suit the occasion.
Community Engagement
As a local business, Shelter Island Slice is deeply invested in the community. The pizzeria regularly participates in charity events, local festivals, and school fundraisers.
In addition, they run a loyalty program that rewards frequent customers with discounts, free slices, and exclusive promotions. This program fosters a strong connection between the pizzeria and its patrons.
“Our customers are our family. Giving back to the community that supports us is at the heart of everything we do.”
Contact Information
Address: 123 Harbor View Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Phone: (631) 555-0147
Website: www.shelterislandslice.com
Hours:
| Day | Opening Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Friday – Saturday | 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM |
