Nestled in the heart of Maui’s vibrant Kihei district, Shearwater Tavern is more than just a neighborhood eatery—it’s an invitation to experience the flavors and hospitality that make the island unique.
With a menu that celebrates both local ingredients and global inspiration, Shearwater Tavern crafts an atmosphere where every meal feels like a festive gathering among friends. Whether you’re a resident or a visitor soaking up the beauty of South Maui, the tavern’s relaxed vibe and culinary creativity are sure to leave a lasting impression.
From its warm, wood-accented interiors to its breezy outdoor patio, Shearwater Tavern captures the spirit of aloha in every detail. The menu is a testament to the tavern’s philosophy: approachable yet adventurous, familiar yet delightfully surprising.
Diners can expect hearty comfort food, innovative cocktails, and a selection of local brews that reflect Maui’s thriving food scene. As the sun sets over Kihei, the tavern comes alive with laughter, clinking glasses, and the aroma of freshly prepared dishes—a true celebration of island life.
Discover why Shearwater Tavern has become a culinary landmark, drawing food lovers from near and far to savor its signature experience.
Ambiance and Setting
Stepping into Shearwater Tavern is like being welcomed into a friend’s home—a place where comfort and style merge seamlessly. The ambiance is both inviting and energetic, perfectly balancing the laid-back spirit of Maui with the sophistication of a modern tavern.
From the moment you enter, you’re greeted by a friendly staff and a warm, open layout that encourages conversation and relaxation.
The interior design features rich wood accents, industrial lighting, and tasteful art inspired by Hawaii’s natural beauty. Large windows flood the space with island sunshine during the day, while evenings are illuminated by soft, ambient lighting that sets a cozy mood.
The bar area buzzes with energy, making it a popular spot for locals and tourists to mingle over drinks and small bites.
Outdoor seating offers a different appeal, with a spacious patio framed by lush tropical landscaping. This area is perfect for those who want to enjoy Maui’s gentle breezes while savoring their meal.
The patio is also dog-friendly, making it a favorite among pet owners who wish to dine with their furry companions.
“Shearwater Tavern delivers the perfect blend of casual comfort and lively atmosphere—making every visit memorable, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just dropping in for a quick bite.”
- Cozy indoor seating with rustic decor
- Vibrant bar area for socializing and sampling local brews
- Dog-friendly outdoor patio surrounded by tropical plants
- Live music nights and special events for added entertainment
Signature Starters and Small Plates
The beginning of your Shearwater Tavern experience often starts with their carefully curated selection of starters. These dishes are designed to awaken your palate and set the tone for the meal, blending traditional favorites with creative twists that showcase local flavors.
From crispy calamari to fresh poke, the small plates menu is a celebration of both land and sea. Each dish is crafted with attention to detail, using high-quality ingredients sourced locally whenever possible.
This commitment to freshness is evident in every bite, whether you’re sharing with friends or savoring solo.
For those who crave bold flavors, the tavern’s spicy wings and house-made sauces are a must-try. These dishes pair perfectly with their rotating selection of craft beers, creating an ideal start to your dining adventure.
Popular Small Plates
- Calamari Fritti – Lightly battered, served with garlic aioli and house-made marinara
- Poke Nachos – A fusion of Hawaiian poke and crispy wonton chips, topped with avocado and sesame
- Korean BBQ Wings – Tossed in a sweet and spicy glaze, garnished with scallions and sesame seeds
- Garlic Truffle Fries – Hand-cut fries finished with truffle oil and parmesan
“Every small plate at Shearwater Tavern tells a story—one that captures Maui’s vibrant culinary heritage and the chef’s commitment to innovation.”
Pairing a small plate with a local beer or creative cocktail is more than just a meal starter—it’s an introduction to the tavern’s unique approach to hospitality. The menu is updated seasonally to reflect the freshest ingredients, ensuring each visit brings something new to discover.
Salads and Lighter Fare
Not every meal at Shearwater Tavern has to be indulgent. For those seeking balanced, nutritious options, the salad and lighter fare menu offers a refreshing alternative.
These dishes are thoughtfully composed, blending local greens, vibrant produce, and house-made dressings to create plates that are as beautiful as they are satisfying.
Each salad is a showcase of Maui’s agricultural abundance. Expect crisp baby greens, ripe tomatoes, and unique tropical ingredients like papaya or macadamia nuts.
The kitchen’s dedication to freshness shines through in every bite, making these dishes popular for lunch or as a lighter dinner option.
Featured Salads
- Maui Caesar – Romaine hearts, parmesan, house croutons, and a zesty Caesar dressing
- Island Cobb – Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, blue cheese, egg, and local greens
- Asian Sesame Salad – Mixed greens, mandarin oranges, crispy wontons, and a tangy sesame vinaigrette
Many salads can be customized with your choice of protein, such as grilled shrimp, seared ahi, or tofu. This flexibility makes it easy to tailor your meal to your personal preferences.
For diners with dietary restrictions, the staff is attentive and accommodating, ensuring everyone can enjoy a meal that fits their needs.
The lighter fare options also include soups and seasonal vegetable dishes. These selections are perfect for those who want something nourishing without feeling weighed down.
The kitchen uses locally-sourced, organic produce whenever possible, reflecting their commitment to both taste and sustainability.
| Salad | Main Ingredients | Add-ons |
| Maui Caesar | Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons | Grilled Chicken, Shrimp, Tofu |
| Island Cobb | Chicken, Avocado, Egg, Bacon, Greens | Seared Ahi, Tofu |
| Asian Sesame | Mixed Greens, Mandarin, Wonton | Grilled Shrimp, Chicken |
For those seeking a lighter meal, Shearwater Tavern’s salads are a delicious and healthful choice—without sacrificing flavor or satisfaction.
Signature Burgers and Sandwiches
Few things are as comforting as a well-crafted burger or sandwich, and Shearwater Tavern has elevated these classics to new heights. The tavern’s kitchen takes pride in using hand-ground beef, fresh artisan buns, and imaginative toppings to create mouthwatering combinations that keep patrons coming back for more.
Each burger is cooked to order, ensuring a juicy, flavorful bite every time. The menu offers a variety of options, from traditional cheeseburgers to more adventurous creations featuring local ingredients like Maui onions, pineapple, or even kalua pork.
Sandwich enthusiasts will appreciate the range of offerings, which include everything from crispy chicken to vegetarian-friendly fare.
Burger Highlights
- Tavern Classic Burger – Angus beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese, and house sauce
- Maui Pineapple Burger – Grilled pineapple, teriyaki glaze, Swiss cheese, and Maui onions
- Kalua Pork Sandwich – Slow-roasted pork, cabbage slaw, and spicy aioli on a toasted bun
- Portobello Mushroom Burger – Marinated portobello cap, roasted peppers, arugula, and goat cheese
Each burger and sandwich is served with your choice of side, such as house fries, sweet potato fries, or a fresh side salad. Gluten-free buns and lettuce wraps are available, making it easy for diners with dietary preferences to enjoy their favorite flavors.
The kitchen’s attention to detail is evident in the quality of the bread, the flavor of the sauces, and the freshness of the toppings. Every element is thoughtfully chosen to complement the main ingredients, resulting in a burger or sandwich experience that’s both familiar and unforgettable.
“Shearwater Tavern’s burgers are a symphony of flavors—the perfect fusion of classic comfort and island-inspired flair.”
For those seeking something extra, consider adding bacon, avocado, or a fried egg to customize your meal. The staff is happy to accommodate special requests, making each order as unique as the diner enjoying it.
Mains and Chef’s Specialties
Beyond burgers, Shearwater Tavern’s menu features a robust selection of main courses that highlight the chef’s creativity and commitment to local ingredients. These dishes range from hearty comfort foods to refined plates that showcase the flavors of Hawaii in unexpected ways.
The dinner menu is where the kitchen truly shines, offering a rotating selection of seasonal specialties alongside beloved staples. Diners can expect expertly prepared proteins, vibrant vegetables, and sauces that balance boldness with subtlety.
Chef’s Specialties
- Seared Ahi Steak – Fresh, line-caught ahi, served rare with wasabi mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables
- Short Rib Ragu – Slow-braised short ribs in a rich tomato sauce, served over pappardelle pasta
- Grilled Local Fish – Rotating daily catch, lightly seasoned and paired with coconut rice and mango salsa
- Roasted Vegetable Risotto – Creamy arborio rice with market vegetables and aged parmesan
The chef’s specials change regularly to reflect the freshest seasonal produce and seafood available. This ensures there’s always something new to try, whether you’re a first-time visitor or a returning regular.
The kitchen’s dedication to local sourcing means you can trust that each dish is both sustainable and bursting with flavor.
For those celebrating a special occasion, the staff is happy to recommend wine pairings or craft cocktails that complement your meal. The attentive servers are knowledgeable about the menu and can offer insights into the inspiration behind each dish.
| Main Course | Protein | Accompaniments |
| Seared Ahi Steak | Ahi Tuna | Wasabi Mashed Potatoes, Seasonal Veggies |
| Short Rib Ragu | Braised Beef Short Rib | Pappardelle Pasta, Tomato Ragu |
| Grilled Local Fish | Catch of the Day | Coconut Rice, Mango Salsa |
| Vegetable Risotto | Market Veggies | Creamy Risotto, Parmesan |
Shearwater Tavern’s main courses are more than just a meal—they’re a celebration of Maui’s bounty and the chef’s creative vision.
Drinks: Craft Beer, Cocktails, and Wine
A standout feature of Shearwater Tavern is its extensive beverage program, which offers something for every palate. From local craft beers to inventive cocktails and a curated wine list, the drink menu is as thoughtfully composed as the food.
Beer lovers will appreciate the rotating taps, which highlight both Maui-based breweries and standout selections from across the islands. The knowledgeable bartenders are always happy to provide recommendations based on your taste preferences, making it easy to discover new favorites.
Craft Beer Selection
- Maui Brewing Co. – Bikini Blonde Lager, Big Swell IPA, Coconut Hiwa Porter
- Kohana Distilling – Island-inspired seltzers and seasonals
- Guest Rotators – Rare finds from Oahu, Kauai, and the mainland
For cocktail enthusiasts, the bar serves up both classics and inventive new creations. Signature drinks often feature tropical ingredients like lilikoi, coconut, or fresh pineapple, reflecting the island’s rich flavor profile.
The mixologists take pride in using house-made syrups and fresh-squeezed juices, elevating each drink to a new level.
The wine list is carefully chosen to complement the menu, with offerings from California, Oregon, and international producers. Whether you’re pairing a crisp white with fresh seafood or enjoying a bold red alongside short rib ragu, the staff can help you find the perfect match.
“Shearwater Tavern’s bar is a destination in its own right—where locals and visitors gather to toast the day with the best of Maui’s craft beverages.”
Happy hour specials and seasonal drink menus keep the offerings fresh and exciting, ensuring there’s always something new to sip and savor.
Desserts and Sweet Endings
No meal at Shearwater Tavern is complete without a taste of something sweet. The dessert menu is a blend of comforting classics and island-inspired treats, crafted to provide a satisfying finish to your dining experience.
Each dessert is made in-house, using fresh, high-quality ingredients that capture the spirit of Maui.
Popular choices include the signature chocolate lava cake, served warm with vanilla bean ice cream, and the tropical fruit pavlova, a light and airy option that showcases the island’s abundant produce.
The menu also features rotating specials, such as coconut crème brûlée or macadamia nut pie, depending on the season.
Favorite Desserts
- Chocolate Lava Cake – Warm, molten center, vanilla ice cream, berry compote
- Tropical Fruit Pavlova – Crisp meringue, whipped cream, fresh island fruits
- Coconut Crème Brûlée – Silky custard, caramelized sugar crust, toasted coconut
- Macadamia Nut Pie – Buttery crust, toasted macadamias, caramel filling, whipped cream
Desserts can be paired with a selection of dessert wines, coffee drinks, or after-dinner liqueurs. For those celebrating a special occasion, the kitchen is happy to add a personalized touch, such as a birthday message or candle.
The dessert menu also accommodates guests with dietary preferences, offering gluten-free and dairy-free options when possible. Simply ask your server for the day’s selections, and they’ll be happy to guide you.
| Dessert | Main Flavors | Dietary Options |
| Chocolate Lava Cake | Chocolate, Vanilla, Berry | Gluten-Free Available |
| Tropical Fruit Pavlova | Meringue, Whipped Cream, Fruit | Gluten-Free |
| Coconut Crème Brûlée | Coconut, Caramel, Custard | Ask for Options |
| Macadamia Nut Pie | Macadamia, Caramel, Whipped Cream | Contains Nuts |
Whether you have a sweet tooth or just want a light finish to your meal, Shearwater Tavern’s desserts offer the perfect ending.
Service, Atmosphere, and Community
What truly sets Shearwater Tavern apart is its dedication to exceptional service and its deep connection to the Kihei community. Every guest is treated with genuine warmth and hospitality, creating a welcoming environment for families, couples, and solo diners alike.
The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, always ready to offer recommendations or accommodate special requests. Whether you’re seeking advice on wine pairings or need a dish adjusted for dietary needs, the team goes above and beyond to ensure your experience is outstanding.
Beyond food and drink, Shearwater Tavern plays an active role in the local community. The restaurant frequently hosts charity events, supports local farmers and producers, and participates in initiatives that give back to Maui.
This sense of community involvement is woven into the fabric of the tavern’s identity.
“Shearwater Tavern is more than a restaurant—it’s a gathering place, a hub of hospitality, and a proud supporter of the Kihei community.”
- Friendly, attentive staff who treat every guest like family
- Community events and partnerships with local organizations
- Support for local farms and producers
- Family-friendly atmosphere with options for all ages
Dining at Shearwater Tavern means being part of something bigger—a celebration of food, friendship, and local pride.
Conclusion: Why Shearwater Tavern Kihei Menu Stands Out
From the moment you arrive at Shearwater Tavern in Kihei, it’s clear that this is more than just a place to eat—it’s a destination that captures the essence of Maui’s culinary landscape. The menu is a vibrant tapestry of local flavors, global inspiration, and genuine hospitality.
Each dish, from inventive starters to signature main courses and decadent desserts, is crafted with care, creativity, and a deep respect for the island’s bounty.
The atmosphere is welcoming and lively, making it the perfect spot for any occasion, whether you’re gathering with friends, enjoying a family meal, or seeking a romantic evening out. The staff’s commitment to exceptional service and community engagement sets Shearwater Tavern apart as a true gem in Kihei’s dining scene.
With a beverage program that celebrates the best of local craft beer and inventive cocktails, every visit feels like a special event.
For anyone seeking an authentic taste of Maui—one that blends tradition with innovation, comfort with sophistication—Shearwater Tavern delivers. Its menu is a love letter to the island, inviting guests to return again and again for new flavors, friendly faces, and unforgettable memories.
Experience why Shearwater Tavern remains a beloved favorite for locals and visitors alike, and discover the magic that makes every meal here truly extraordinary.
