When it comes to satisfying cravings for delicious, handcrafted pizzas and hearty subs, Penny Pizza & Sub stands out as a beloved local favorite. Known for its fresh ingredients, generous portions, and a menu that caters to diverse tastes, Penny Pizza & Sub offers an experience that goes beyond ordinary fast food.
Whether you’re a fan of classic Italian flavors or prefer bold, innovative toppings, their menu is thoughtfully crafted to satisfy every palate. With a welcoming atmosphere and quick service, it’s the ideal spot for family dinners, casual hangouts, or a quick lunch that doesn’t compromise on quality.
The menu at Penny Pizza & Sub is a vibrant collection of options that celebrate the rich tradition of Italian-American cuisine while embracing contemporary twists. From crispy thin crusts to robust, meaty subs, each item is prepared with care and precision.
The attention to detail in every dish reflects a commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction. Whether you crave a simple cheese pizza or a loaded sub packed with fresh vegetables and premium meats, Penny Pizza & Sub’s offerings promise a delightful culinary journey.
More than just a place to eat, Penny Pizza & Sub has become a community staple, where friendships are fostered over shared meals and memorable flavors. The menu is designed to be approachable yet exciting, ensuring that first-timers and regular patrons alike find something to love.
Dive into the menu’s rich variety and discover why Penny Pizza & Sub continues to win hearts with every bite.
Signature Pizzas
The hallmark of Penny Pizza & Sub’s menu is undoubtedly its range of signature pizzas. Each pizza is crafted with a perfect balance of flavors, highlighting fresh toppings and a crust that strikes the ideal harmony between crispy and chewy.
These pizzas are designed to showcase both traditional favorites and inventive combinations that keep the menu fresh and exciting.
One of the most popular choices is the classic Margherita, featuring a thin, hand-tossed crust layered with fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and fragrant basil. It’s a timeless option that appeals to purists and newcomers alike.
Another standout is the Meat Lover’s pizza, generously topped with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon, delivering a hearty and satisfying experience.
Vegetarian options are equally celebrated, with pizzas like the Garden Delight, packed with mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, and onions. This variety not only caters to different dietary preferences but also emphasizes the use of fresh, locally sourced produce.
Each pizza is baked to perfection in a stone oven, ensuring a crispy crust and melty cheese every time.
Popular Signature Pizzas
- Margherita: Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, basil, olive oil
- Meat Lover’s: Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mozzarella
- Garden Delight: Mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, onions, tomato sauce
- BBQ Chicken: Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onions, cilantro
“Our signature pizzas are crafted to deliver bold flavors and authentic textures that keep our customers coming back for more.”
Build-Your-Own Pizza
For those who prefer customization, Penny Pizza & Sub offers a Build-Your-Own Pizza option that allows diners to create their perfect pie. This flexibility is one of the menu’s most appealing features, empowering guests to tailor every element from the crust to the toppings.
The process is simple yet liberating, making it a hit with families, groups, and anyone with a specific flavor profile in mind.
Start by choosing the size and crust type—options range from classic hand-tossed to gluten-free crusts. Then, select from a wide variety of sauces including traditional tomato, creamy Alfredo, or spicy buffalo.
The next step invites you to pile on toppings, with choices spanning premium meats, fresh vegetables, and an array of cheeses. This hands-on approach ensures every pizza is uniquely yours.
Beyond just personal taste, the Build-Your-Own Pizza is also ideal for accommodating dietary restrictions or experimenting with new flavor combinations. It’s a creative outlet that transforms pizza night into a fun, interactive dining experience.
Plus, the staff is always ready to offer suggestions or help with pairing ingredients to maximize flavor.
Customization Options
| Crust Types | Sauces | Toppings |
| Hand-tossed | Tomato Basil | Pepperoni |
| Thin Crust | Alfredo | Sausage |
| Gluten-Free | Buffalo | Grilled Chicken |
| Mushrooms, Olives, Peppers, Onions |
Classic Subs
Penny Pizza & Sub’s sub menu is a celebration of hearty, flavorful sandwiches made with fresh bread and quality ingredients. These subs are crafted to offer a perfect balance of textures and tastes, satisfying those looking for a substantial meal with bold flavors.
Whether you want a cold cut combo or a hot, melty sandwich, there’s a sub to suit every preference.
The Italian Classic sub is a standout, featuring a mouthwatering combination of salami, ham, pepperoni, and provolone cheese, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions, and a drizzle of Italian dressing. The bread is always freshly baked, offering a soft yet sturdy foundation that holds all the fillings together.
This sub is a crowd favorite for its authentic taste and generous portions.
For those who prefer warm sandwiches, the Chicken Parmesan sub is a must-try. Tender breaded chicken breast is smothered in marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, creating a comforting and rich flavor profile.
Vegetarian options such as the Veggie Delight, loaded with roasted peppers, fresh spinach, mushrooms, and cheddar cheese, ensure everyone can find something to enjoy.
Popular Classic Subs
- Italian Classic: Salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions
- Chicken Parmesan: Breaded chicken, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese
- Veggie Delight: Roasted peppers, spinach, mushrooms, cheddar cheese
- Turkey & Swiss: Sliced turkey breast, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo
“Our subs are built to satisfy — fresh, flavorful, and made with ingredients you can trust.”
Specialty Subs
Specialty subs at Penny Pizza & Sub elevate the sandwich experience with gourmet ingredients and unique flavor profiles. These creations go beyond the classic recipes to offer something truly memorable, perfect for those seeking a more adventurous or upscale sub option.
Each specialty sub is carefully constructed to balance bold tastes with fresh, quality ingredients.
The Steak & Cheese sub features thinly sliced, tender steak cooked to perfection and layered with melted provolone cheese and sautéed onions and peppers. It’s a hearty option that packs a punch and delivers satisfying warmth in every bite.
Another favorite is the Buffalo Chicken sub, which combines spicy buffalo sauce with crispy chicken tenders, lettuce, and ranch dressing for a zesty kick.
For the seafood lovers, the Tuna Melt sub is a standout choice. Made with a creamy tuna salad and topped with melted cheddar cheese, it’s served hot on toasted bread to create a comforting and flavorful meal.
Specialty subs also highlight Penny Pizza & Sub’s commitment to freshness and quality, ensuring each bite is a delight.
Featured Specialty Subs
| Sub | Main Ingredients | Flavor Profile |
| Steak & Cheese | Thinly sliced steak, provolone, onions, peppers | Savory, hearty, warm |
| Buffalo Chicken | Crispy chicken tenders, buffalo sauce, lettuce, ranch | Spicy, tangy, crunchy |
| Tuna Melt | Tuna salad, cheddar cheese, toasted bread | Creamy, cheesy, comforting |
Salads and Sides
Complementing the main dishes, Penny Pizza & Sub offers a variety of salads and sides designed to bring balance and freshness to your meal. These options are perfect for those who want to lighten their order or add a crisp, refreshing element to the rich flavors of pizza and subs.
The salads are vibrant, packed with fresh vegetables, and dressed with house-made dressings that enhance every bite.
The Caesar Salad is a classic favorite, featuring crisp romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan, crunchy croutons, and a tangy Caesar dressing. It can also be easily customized by adding grilled chicken or shrimp for a protein boost.
For something lighter and more colorful, the Garden Salad includes a mix of fresh greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots, dressed with your choice of vinaigrette or ranch.
On the sides menu, crispy seasoned fries and golden mozzarella sticks are popular choices that perfectly complement any entrée. These sides are prepared fresh and served hot, making them ideal for sharing.
The variety ensures there is something for everyone, whether you prefer something crunchy, cheesy, or fresh.
Salads & Sides Options
- Caesar Salad: Romaine, Parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing
- Garden Salad: Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots
- Seasoned Fries: Crispy, golden, lightly spiced
- Mozzarella Sticks: Breaded, fried, served with marinara
“Our salads and sides are crafted to perfectly complement every meal, offering freshness and flavor in every bite.”
Kids’ Menu
Penny Pizza & Sub understands the importance of catering to younger guests, which is why the Kids’ Menu is thoughtfully created with smaller portions and flavors that appeal to children. The menu balances fun and nutrition, providing options that satisfy kids while reassuring parents about the quality of ingredients and preparation.
Popular items include the Mini Cheese Pizza, a personal-sized pizza topped with gooey mozzarella and mild tomato sauce. The Chicken Tenders option is another favorite, featuring crispy, golden strips served with a choice of dipping sauces.
Mac and cheese rounds out the menu, offering a creamy, comforting dish that kids love.
Each kids’ meal is served with a side of fresh fruit or fries and a drink, making it a complete and balanced option. This attention to detail ensures that younger diners enjoy their meal just as much as adults, making Penny Pizza & Sub a family-friendly destination.
Kids’ Favorites
| Dish | Description | Side Options |
| Mini Cheese Pizza | Personal-sized cheese pizza with tomato sauce | Fruit cup or fries |
| Chicken Tenders | Crispy breaded chicken strips with dipping sauce | Fruit cup or fries |
| Mac and Cheese | Creamy macaroni with cheddar cheese | Fruit cup or fries |
“We strive to make every child’s dining experience enjoyable with tasty, kid-friendly meals made from quality ingredients.”
Beverages and Desserts
No meal at Penny Pizza & Sub is complete without a selection of refreshing beverages and indulgent desserts. The menu offers a range of drink options, from classic sodas and iced teas to specialty lemonades and coffee.
These beverages are carefully chosen to complement the flavors of the food and provide a refreshing finish or accompaniment.
For dessert lovers, Penny Pizza & Sub features several sweet treats that satisfy any sweet tooth. The classic New York-style cheesecake is a rich, creamy option that melts in your mouth.
Chocolate chip cookies and brownies are baked fresh daily, offering a warm, comforting end to any meal. Seasonal desserts also rotate throughout the year, adding excitement and variety.
Whether you’re looking for a simple drink to pair with your pizza or a decadent dessert to cap off your dining experience, the beverage and dessert menu at Penny Pizza & Sub ensures a satisfying conclusion to every meal.
Popular Drinks & Desserts
- Sodas: Cola, lemon-lime, root beer, diet options
- Iced Tea & Lemonade: Freshly brewed and house-made
- New York Cheesecake: Creamy, classic dessert
- Freshly Baked Cookies: Chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin
“Our dessert and beverage selections are designed to delight and refresh, completing your meal with memorable flavors.”
Ordering and Delivery Options
Penny Pizza & Sub offers a variety of convenient ordering and delivery options designed to fit into busy lifestyles. Whether you prefer dining in, pickup, or delivery, the process is streamlined and customer-friendly.
The restaurant supports online ordering through an easy-to-navigate platform as well as traditional phone orders.
Delivery services cover a broad radius, ensuring that customers can enjoy Penny Pizza & Sub’s delicious menu from the comfort of their homes. The delivery team is trained to handle orders with care, ensuring that pizzas arrive hot and subs remain fresh.
Special packaging helps maintain quality during transit.
For those who enjoy dining in, the atmosphere is warm and inviting with ample seating and attentive service. Seasonal promotions and combo deals are often available through the online ordering system, providing added value and encouraging customers to explore the menu more deeply.
Ordering Methods
| Method | Details | Benefits |
| In-Restaurant | Casual dining with full menu access | Immediate service, fresh experience |
| Pickup | Order online or by phone, pick up in-store | Convenient, no waiting in line |
| Delivery | Order online or by phone, delivered to your door | Comfort of home, timely service |
“Our goal is to make enjoying Penny Pizza & Sub as effortless and enjoyable as possible, no matter where you are.”
With a menu that expertly balances tradition and innovation, Penny Pizza & Sub continues to be a premier destination for pizza and sub lovers. The variety of offerings, from signature pizzas to customizable options, hearty subs to fresh salads, ensures that every diner finds something perfect for their taste and appetite.
Attention to quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and welcoming service combine to create a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable.
Whether grabbing a quick lunch, enjoying a family dinner, or ordering for a group gathering, Penny Pizza & Sub delivers consistent excellence. Their commitment to freshness and flavor shines through every dish, while the diverse menu caters to a wide range of preferences and dietary needs.
The inclusion of kid-friendly meals and tempting desserts rounds out the menu, making it a well-rounded choice for all ages.
Ultimately, Penny Pizza & Sub isn’t just about food — it’s about bringing people together through shared meals and great taste. The menu is a testament to their passion for quality and customer satisfaction, inviting everyone to experience the joy of exceptional pizza and subs.
With convenient ordering options and a dedication to friendly service, Penny Pizza & Sub remains a trusted and beloved eatery in the community.
