When you step into Old Rail Pizza, you’re not just entering a pizzeria—you’re embarking on a flavorful journey that celebrates the art of pizza-making. The menu reflects a commitment to tradition and innovation, blending classic ingredients with unique twists that cater to every palate.
From hand-tossed crusts baked to perfection to an array of fresh, locally sourced toppings, Old Rail Pizza offers a satisfying experience for casual diners and connoisseurs alike. Whether you’re craving a hearty meat lover’s pie or a vibrant vegetarian masterpiece, the menu presents options that are thoughtfully crafted and deeply satisfying.
What sets Old Rail Pizza apart is its dedication to quality and variety. Each item is designed to highlight the rich textures and balanced flavors that define exceptional pizza.
The menu extends beyond just pizzas, featuring appetizers, salads, and desserts that complement the main offerings beautifully. This diversity ensures that every visit feels fresh and exciting, inviting guests to explore new favorites or enjoy tried-and-true classics.
Understanding the Old Rail Pizza menu means appreciating the layers of flavor and the careful attention to detail that goes into every dish. The culinary team’s passion shines through in every bite, making Old Rail Pizza a destination where comfort, creativity, and community come together.
Whether dining in, ordering takeout, or sharing with friends, the menu promises a memorable experience that honors the time-honored craft of pizza-making.
Signature Pizzas
Old Rail Pizza’s signature pizzas embody the heart and soul of their culinary philosophy. Each pizza is crafted with a base of hand-stretched dough, topped with a house-made sauce and premium ingredients that elevate traditional flavors.
These pizzas are designed to offer a balanced taste experience, combining savory, tangy, and fresh elements in every slice.
The menu features a variety of signature options, each with its own unique profile. From the bold and spicy to the savory and subtle, the signature pizzas cater to a wide spectrum of taste preferences.
The crusts are known for their perfect blend of crispness and chewiness, providing a sturdy foundation without overpowering the toppings.
Popular Signature Varieties
- The Old Rail Classic: Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms, and fresh basil.
- Firehouse BBQ: Smoky barbecue sauce, grilled chicken, red onions, cilantro, and mozzarella.
- Garden Harvest: Roasted bell peppers, zucchini, red onions, black olives, and feta cheese.
- Spicy Italian: Spicy sausage, jalapeños, roasted garlic, and mozzarella with a drizzle of chili oil.
“Our signature pizzas are crafted to reflect the passion and creativity we pour into every pie. Each bite tells a story of quality and tradition.” – Head Chef, Old Rail Pizza
The secret behind these pizzas lies not only in the ingredients but also in the preparation. Each signature pie is baked in a stone oven, which enhances the crust’s texture and intensifies the overall flavor.
The menu encourages diners to savor the complexity of tastes, whether it’s the smokiness from the BBQ sauce or the fresh zest from garden vegetables.
Build Your Own Pizza
For those who appreciate personalization, Old Rail Pizza offers a comprehensive Build Your Own Pizza option. This section allows guests to select their preferred crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings, empowering them to create a pizza tailored exactly to their cravings.
The build-your-own approach is perfect for accommodating dietary preferences, adventurous combinations, or simple classics. The menu outlines each step clearly, making it easy for guests to customize their pizza without feeling overwhelmed.
This flexibility is a cornerstone of Old Rail Pizza’s customer-centric philosophy.
Customization Options
- Crust Choices: Classic hand-tossed, thin crust, gluten-free, or whole wheat.
- Sauces: Traditional tomato, garlic alfredo, barbecue, and pesto.
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, goat cheese, and vegan cheese.
- Toppings: Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, spinach, jalapeños, pineapple, and more.
| Crust Type | Calories (per serving) | Texture |
| Classic Hand-Tossed | 280 | Soft and chewy with a crisp outer edge |
| Thin Crust | 220 | Crispy and light, perfect for a crunchy bite |
| Gluten-Free | 260 | Firm and slightly crumbly |
| Whole Wheat | 300 | Nutty flavor, denser texture |
Building your own pizza is not only fun but also a way to control the nutritional content and flavor combinations, ensuring a satisfying meal every time.
Appetizers and Sides
Complementing the pizza offerings are a variety of appetizers and sides designed to enhance the dining experience. These small plates are perfect for sharing or enjoying as a starter before the main course.
Old Rail Pizza’s appetizers range from classic favorites to unique creations that showcase the kitchen’s flair. Each item is prepared with fresh ingredients and crafted to pair well with the pizzas and beverages available.
Popular Appetizers
- Garlic Knots: Freshly baked dough knots brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with Parmesan.
- Buffalo Wings: Crispy wings tossed in spicy buffalo sauce, served with celery and blue cheese dressing.
- Caprese Skewers: Cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and a balsamic glaze drizzle.
- Stuffed Mushrooms: Button mushrooms filled with a blend of cheeses, herbs, and breadcrumbs.
“Our appetizers are crafted to ignite your appetite and prepare your palate for the main event — the pizza.” – Restaurant Manager, Old Rail Pizza
Each appetizer is designed with balance in mind, offering flavors that are bold but not overwhelming. The garlic knots, for example, provide a buttery, herbaceous start, while the buffalo wings add a fiery kick.
These dishes are not only delicious but also great for sharing among friends or family.
Salads and Healthy Choices
For guests seeking lighter or health-conscious options, the menu features a selection of fresh salads and nutritious dishes. These choices provide a refreshing contrast to the indulgence of pizza while maintaining the same commitment to quality ingredients.
Salads at Old Rail Pizza are made with crisp greens, vibrant vegetables, and house-made dressings that enhance natural flavors. The healthy dishes incorporate protein and fiber-rich ingredients to satisfy hunger without excess calories.
Featured Salads
- Caesar Salad: Crisp romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, croutons, and creamy Caesar dressing.
- Mediterranean Salad: Mixed greens, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, and red onions with a lemon vinaigrette.
- Grilled Chicken Salad: Mixed greens topped with grilled chicken breast, avocado, cherry tomatoes, and a balsamic glaze.
| Salad | Calories | Key Ingredients |
| Caesar Salad | 350 | Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons, Caesar Dressing |
| Mediterranean Salad | 320 | Greens, Olives, Feta, Cucumbers, Lemon Vinaigrette |
| Grilled Chicken Salad | 420 | Grilled Chicken, Avocado, Greens, Tomatoes, Balsamic Glaze |
These salads are perfect for those looking to balance indulgence with wellness, providing fresh, nutrient-dense options that complement the heartier menu items.
Desserts
Old Rail Pizza rounds out the meal with a selection of desserts designed to satisfy any sweet tooth. These treats incorporate classic flavors with a modern twist, offering a delightful conclusion to the dining experience.
The dessert menu emphasizes indulgence without excess, focusing on quality ingredients and balanced sweetness. Whether you prefer rich chocolate or fruity freshness, there’s something to please every palate.
Sweet Endings
- Chocolate Lava Cake: Warm chocolate cake with a molten center, served with vanilla ice cream.
- Tiramisu: Classic Italian dessert with layers of mascarpone, espresso-soaked ladyfingers, and cocoa dusting.
- Seasonal Fruit Tart: Crisp pastry filled with custard and topped with fresh seasonal fruits.
“Our desserts are crafted to offer the perfect balance of richness and freshness, making them the ideal finale to your meal.” – Pastry Chef, Old Rail Pizza
Each dessert is made fresh daily, reflecting Old Rail Pizza’s dedication to authenticity and quality. The chocolate lava cake is particularly popular, with its decadent texture and warm, gooey center providing a memorable experience.
For those seeking a lighter finish, the seasonal fruit tart offers a crisp and refreshing option.
Beverages
Complementing the menu is an extensive beverage selection, featuring classic soft drinks, craft beers, and carefully chosen wines. These drinks are curated to enhance the flavors of the food and provide a well-rounded dining experience.
The beverage menu reflects Old Rail Pizza’s commitment to pairing quality drinks with exceptional food. From local brews to international favorites, the options cater to a variety of tastes and occasions.
Drink Selection Highlights
- Craft Beers: Rotating selection from local breweries, including IPAs, stouts, and lagers.
- Wines: Red, white, and rosé options, carefully selected to pair with different pizza styles.
- Non-Alcoholic: House-made lemonades, iced teas, and classic sodas.
| Beverage | Type | Pairing Recommendation |
| IPA Craft Beer | Beer | Spicy Italian Pizza |
| Pinot Noir | Wine | Firehouse BBQ Pizza |
| House Lemonade | Non-Alcoholic | Garden Harvest Pizza |
The thoughtful beverage options ensure that every meal is complemented perfectly, enhancing both flavor and enjoyment.
Special Dietary Options
Old Rail Pizza recognizes the importance of catering to diverse dietary needs. The menu includes a range of options designed for gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan customers, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a satisfying meal.
Special dietary choices are clearly marked and prepared with dedicated care to prevent cross-contamination. This attention to detail reflects the restaurant’s inclusive philosophy and commitment to quality.
Diet-Friendly Selections
- Gluten-Free Crust: Made with a specially formulated blend of rice and tapioca flours.
- Vegan Cheese: Dairy-free cheese alternative made from coconut oil and nuts.
- Vegetarian Pizzas: Featuring fresh vegetables, herbs, and meat substitutes.
“Providing delicious options for all dietary needs is not just good business; it’s our responsibility to foster an inclusive dining environment.” – Owner, Old Rail Pizza
With these options, guests with dietary restrictions can enjoy the same great taste and quality that defines Old Rail Pizza. The menu’s transparency and variety make it easy for everyone to find something delicious and safe to eat.
Conclusion
Old Rail Pizza’s menu is a testament to the power of thoughtful ingredients, expert craftsmanship, and a passion for flavor. It successfully balances tradition and innovation, offering a wide array of choices that cater to diverse tastes and dietary needs.
From the rich, comforting signature pizzas to the customizable build-your-own options, every item invites patrons to savor a carefully curated experience.
The thoughtful inclusion of appetizers, salads, desserts, and beverages ensures that the dining journey is complete and satisfying. Equally important is the attention paid to special dietary requirements, ensuring that everyone can partake in the joy of great pizza without compromise.
The menu’s design reflects a deep understanding of what makes pizza not just food, but a shared celebration of community and craft.
Whether you visit Old Rail Pizza for a quick meal or a leisurely gathering, the menu promises quality, variety, and an authentic taste experience. It’s a place where every bite is crafted with care, inviting you to return time and again to discover new favorites and enjoy timeless classics.
In embracing both the familiar and the adventurous, Old Rail Pizza stands as a beacon of culinary excellence in the world of pizza.
