New York Bagel Company Menu

New York Bagel Company has long been celebrated for bringing authentic New York-style bagels and deli favorites to communities nationwide. Whether you’re craving a fresh, chewy bagel or a hearty sandwich, their menu offers an extensive range of options carefully crafted with quality ingredients and classic recipes.

a detailed overview of the New York Bagel Company menu, highlighting their bagels, spreads, sandwiches, salads, beverages, and much more. Whether you are a first-time visitor or a loyal customer, understanding their menu in depth helps you make the most of your dining experience.

Contents

Bagels

The cornerstone of New York Bagel Company is, of course, their bagels. Each bagel is hand-rolled and baked fresh daily, boasting the perfect combination of a slightly crisp exterior and a soft, chewy interior.

Customers can choose from a variety of bagel flavors to suit their taste preferences.

Bagel Type	Description	Price
Plain	Classic New York style plain bagel, perfect for any topping.	$1.50
Everything	A savory blend of poppy seeds, sesame seeds, onion, garlic, and salt.	$1.75
Cinnamon Raisin	Sweet cinnamon and juicy raisins baked into a soft bagel.	$1.85
Sesame	Toasted sesame seeds atop a perfectly baked bagel.	$1.75
Blueberry	Fresh blueberries incorporated into the dough for a fruity taste.	$1.90
Onion	Rich onion flavor infused in the dough and topped with dried onions.	$1.75
Pumpernickel	Dark rye flavor with a subtle sweetness and hearty texture.	$1.85

“Our bagels are more than bread – they are a tradition and a labor of love baked fresh each day.”

Bagel Spreads & Cream Cheeses

No bagel experience is complete without a delicious spread. New York Bagel Company offers a wide selection of classic and specialty cream cheeses, as well as other spreads to complement your choice of bagel.

Spread	Description	Price (per serving)
Plain Cream Cheese	Rich and creamy classic spread made from fresh dairy.	$1.50
Chive Cream Cheese	Classic cream cheese blended with fresh chives for a mild onion flavor.	$1.75
Vegetable Cream Cheese	Cream cheese mixed with diced peppers, onions, and herbs.	$1.85
Jalapeño Cream Cheese	A spicy twist with the kick of fresh jalapeños.	$1.85
Smoked Salmon Spread	Delicious spread made with smoked salmon and cream cheese.	$2.50
Peanut Butter	Classic creamy peanut butter, perfect for sweet bagels.	$1.25
Butter	Fresh churned butter to melt into your warm bagel.	$1.00
Honey Walnut Spread	Sweet and nutty cream cheese spread with honey and walnuts.	$1.95

Tip: Pair an Everything bagel with chive cream cheese for a savory experience, or try cinnamon raisin with honey walnut spread for a sweet delight.

Signature Sandwiches

For those looking for a meal rather than just a snack, New York Bagel Company offers a variety of hearty sandwiches made with fresh bagels and premium deli meats. Each sandwich is crafted with care, combining classic flavors with fresh ingredients.

Sandwich Name	Description	Price
The Classic Nova	Smoked Nova salmon, cream cheese, tomato, onion, and capers on an everything bagel.	$8.95
The New Yorker	Roast beef, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and horseradish sauce on a pumpernickel bagel.	$9.50
Turkey Avocado Deluxe	Sliced turkey breast, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a plain bagel.	$9.75
Egg & Cheese	Scrambled eggs with melted cheddar cheese on a sesame bagel.	$5.50
BLT Bagel	Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a toasted plain bagel.	$7.95
Veggie Delight	Cucumber, tomato, sprouts, avocado, and veggie cream cheese on an onion bagel.	$8.25
The Italian	Salami, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing on an everything bagel.	$9.95
Pastrami Special	Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, mustard, and pickles on a rye bagel.	$10.25

“Our sandwiches are crafted with the same dedication as our bagels – fresh, flavorful, and satisfying.”

Breakfast Options

Start your day right with the New York Bagel Company’s selection of breakfast items. Aside from egg and cheese sandwiches, they offer a variety of choices to please early risers and breakfast lovers.

Bagel & Lox Platter: Classic smoked salmon with cream cheese, tomato, onion, and capers. Served with a choice of bagel. $12.50
Breakfast Burrito: Scrambled eggs, cheese, sausage, and peppers wrapped in a warm tortilla. $7.95
Oatmeal Bowl: Hearty oatmeal topped with fresh fruit and brown sugar. $4.95
Fresh Fruit Cup: Seasonal fresh-cut fruits served chilled. $5.50
Croissant Sandwich: Flaky croissant filled with eggs, cheese, and your choice of bacon or sausage. $6.95
Breakfast Combo: Bagel with cream cheese, scrambled eggs, and a small coffee. $7.50

Salads & Sides

Complement your meal with fresh salads or classic deli sides. These options are perfect for lighter meals or pairing alongside your sandwich or bagel.

Item	Description	Price
Potato Salad	Creamy, tangy potato salad with fresh herbs.	$3.95
Coleslaw	Crisp shredded cabbage with a creamy dressing.	$3.50
Garden Salad	Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots with your choice of dressing.	$5.50
Caesar Salad	Crisp romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing.	$6.25
Pickle Spear	Crisp dill pickle, a perfect palate cleanser.	$1.25
Chips	Assorted potato chips, perfect for a crunchy side.	$1.50

Soups

On chilly days or whenever you need comfort in a cup, the New York Bagel Company offers a rotating selection of soups made fresh daily. Popular favorites include classic chicken noodle, matzo ball, and creamy tomato bisque.

Soup	Description	Price (Cup/Bowl)
Chicken Noodle	Traditional soup with tender chicken, egg noodles, and vegetables.	$4.50 / $6.95
Matzo Ball Soup	Classic Jewish comfort food with fluffy matzo balls in savory broth.	$5.25 / $7.50
Tomato Bisque	Creamy tomato soup with herbs and spices.	$4.75 / $7.25
Vegetable Minestrone	Hearty vegetable soup with beans, pasta, and fresh herbs.	$4.50 / $6.95

Beverages

Quench your thirst with a broad range of beverages available at New York Bagel Company. From freshly brewed coffee to iced teas and soft drinks, they have something for every preference.

Beverage	Description	Price
Fresh Brewed Coffee	Regular or decaffeinated, served hot.	$2.25 / $2.75 (small/large)
Espresso	Rich and strong double shot espresso.	$3.00
Cappuccino	Espresso topped with steamed milk foam.	$3.75
Latte	Smooth espresso with steamed milk.	$4.00
Iced Coffee	Chilled brewed coffee served over ice.	$2.75
Iced Tea	Freshly brewed iced tea, sweetened or unsweetened.	$2.50
Soft Drinks	Assorted sodas and lemonades.	$2.25
Bottled Water	Refreshing bottled spring water.	$1.50

Desserts & Pastries

Complete your meal with a sweet treat from the dessert and pastry selection. Made fresh daily, these items pair perfectly with coffee or tea.

Cheesecake Slice: Creamy New York-style cheesecake with a graham cracker crust. $4.95
Chocolate Chip Cookie: Soft and chewy classic cookie. $2.25
Rugelach: Traditional Jewish pastry filled with fruit preserves and nuts. $3.50
Apple Strudel: Flaky pastry filled with spiced apples and raisins. $4.25
Blueberry Muffin: Moist muffin studded with fresh blueberries. $3.25
Croissant: Buttery, flaky French pastry. $3.75

Family & Catering Options

New York Bagel Company also offers catering services perfect for corporate events, family gatherings, and special occasions. Their catering menu includes bagel platters, sandwich trays, salad assortments, and dessert packages.

Catering Item	Description	Price
Bagel Platter	Assortment of 24 bagels with cream cheese spreads.	$55.00
Sandwich Tray	24 assorted deli sandwiches on fresh bagels with condiments.	$140.00
Salad Tray	Large garden and Caesar salads with dressings.	$45.00
Dessert Platter	Assortment of cookies, rugelach, and pastries (24 pieces).	$60.00
Breakfast Catering	Bagels, cream cheese, fruit salad, and coffee for 12 people.	$90.00

Contact the store directly to customize your catering order or to inquire about delivery options.

Nutritional Information & Dietary Notes

New York Bagel Company strives to provide clear nutritional information to help customers make informed choices. While the menu features some vegetarian options, many deli sandwiches contain meat and dairy products.

Gluten-Free Notice: Traditional bagels contain wheat and gluten. The company currently does not offer gluten-free bagels but provides other gluten-free items such as salads and certain beverages.

Allergens: Many items contain common allergens such as dairy, eggs, nuts (especially in spreads like honey walnut), and sesame seeds. Customers with allergies should inquire with staff to ensure safety.

“We welcome all guests and are happy to assist with special dietary needs whenever possible.”

Ordering Tips & Recommendations

To get the most out of your New York Bagel Company experience, consider these helpful tips:

Try the Everything Bagel: It’s the quintessential New York bagel, bursting with flavor and perfect with any spread.
Customize Your Sandwich: Most sandwiches can be customized with extra veggies, different cheeses, or sauces.
Order Early for Catering: For large orders and catering, place your order at least 24-48 hours in advance.
Pair Coffee and Pastry: A fresh croissant paired with a latte is an unbeatable morning combo.
Ask About Daily Specials: Seasonal and daily specials offer unique flavors and savings.

In summary, New York Bagel Company offers a comprehensive menu that honors New York’s rich bagel and deli heritage. From simple bagels with cream cheese to elaborate sandwiches and catering options, every item reflects attention to quality, freshness, and authentic flavor.

Whether you’re stopping by for a quick breakfast, a filling lunch, or ordering for a large group, their menu is designed to satisfy a wide range of tastes and preferences.