Mulberry Street Bay Shore is a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, known for its delightful blend of traditional Italian flavors with a contemporary twist. The restaurant’s menu is thoughtfully crafted to offer an exceptional dining experience, whether you’re seeking a casual lunch, a celebratory dinner, or a cozy night out.
The ingredients are sourced locally whenever possible, ensuring freshness and quality in every dish. Diners appreciate the balance of classic recipes with innovative preparations, making Mulberry Street Bay Shore a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
The menu caters to a variety of tastes, offering everything from handcrafted appetizers to rich, flavorful entrées and decadent desserts. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, complemented by attentive service that understands the importance of not just feeding, but delighting patrons.
Whether you are a fan of hearty pasta, fresh seafood, or vibrant salads, you’ll find something that satisfies your palate.
Understanding the menu’s layout and highlights can help you make the most of your visit. Each section offers unique dishes that showcase the kitchen’s expertise and passion for Italian cuisine.
This exploration of the Mulberry Street Bay Shore menu reveals the depth and diversity of choices available, making it easier to navigate and select dishes that suit your mood and preferences.
Appetizers: A Flavorful Introduction
The appetizer section at Mulberry Street Bay Shore sets a high standard with an array of starters that awaken the palate. These dishes are designed to be shared or enjoyed solo, providing a perfect prelude to the main courses.
Fresh ingredients and bold flavors characterize this part of the menu, giving guests a taste of what’s to come.
Signature offerings include traditional Italian favorites like bruschetta, calamari, and caprese salad, each prepared with an elevated touch. The bruschetta features toasted bread topped with ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, and a hint of garlic, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil.
The calamari is lightly fried for a crispy exterior while maintaining a tender inside, served with a tangy marinara sauce.
For those seeking something lighter, the caprese salad is a fresh choice, combining juicy mozzarella, vine-ripened tomatoes, and fragrant basil leaves, finished with a balsamic reduction. Each appetizer is crafted to balance flavors and textures, ensuring a satisfying starter.
Popular Appetizer Highlights
- Bruschetta al Pomodoro: Toasted Italian bread, fresh tomatoes, basil, garlic, and olive oil
- Calamari Fritti: Crispy fried calamari rings with house-made marinara
- Caprese Salad: Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, balsamic glaze
- Stuffed Mushrooms: Filled with a savory blend of cheese, herbs, and breadcrumbs
“The appetizers at Mulberry Street Bay Shore are the perfect way to start your meal – fresh, vibrant, and full of authentic Italian flavors.” – A frequent diner’s review
Pasta Selections: Tradition Meets Innovation
The pasta section is a cornerstone of the Mulberry Street Bay Shore menu, showcasing both classic and contemporary Italian pasta dishes. Each plate is prepared with precision, using homemade or imported pasta paired with rich sauces and fresh ingredients.
The diversity in this section caters to a wide range of preferences, from creamy alfredo to robust tomato-based sauces.
One of the standout dishes is the Fettuccine Alfredo, which features perfectly cooked pasta tossed in a luscious cream sauce with parmesan and butter. Another favorite is the Spaghetti Carbonara, made with pancetta, eggs, and pecorino romano, delivering a comforting yet sophisticated flavor profile.
For those seeking something with a bit more zest, the Penne Arrabbiata offers a spicy tomato sauce that ignites the senses.
Vegetarian options are plentiful, with dishes like the Primavera, which combines seasonal vegetables with a light garlic and olive oil sauce. This section’s diverse offerings ensure that pasta lovers will find a dish that perfectly suits their taste and dietary needs.
Comparison of Popular Pasta Dishes
| Dish | Main Ingredients | Flavor Profile |
| Fettuccine Alfredo | Cream, parmesan, butter, fettuccine | Rich, creamy, mild |
| Spaghetti Carbonara | Pancetta, eggs, pecorino romano, spaghetti | Savory, smoky, creamy |
| Penne Arrabbiata | Tomato, garlic, chili flakes, penne | Spicy, tangy, bold |
| Primavera | Seasonal vegetables, garlic, olive oil, penne | Fresh, light, herbaceous |
Seafood Dishes: Fresh from the Bay
Mulberry Street Bay Shore takes pride in sourcing fresh seafood, offering a range of dishes that celebrate the flavors of the ocean. This section highlights the kitchen’s ability to balance delicate seafood with robust Italian seasonings and cooking techniques.
Seafood lovers will find a variety of options, from grilled fish to seafood pasta.
Notable dishes include the Grilled Branzino, a whole fish seasoned with herbs and lemon, cooked to perfection with a crispy skin and tender inside. The Seafood Fra Diavolo features a medley of shrimp, scallops, and mussels in a spicy tomato sauce, served over linguine.
Another popular choice is the Shrimp Scampi, sautéed with garlic, white wine, and butter, delivering a fragrant and flavorful experience.
Each dish is paired with complementary sides such as sautéed spinach or roasted potatoes, enhancing the overall meal. The focus remains on quality and freshness, which shines through every bite.
Essential Seafood Pairings
- Grilled Branzino: Herb-infused, lemon-accented, served with seasonal vegetables
- Seafood Fra Diavolo: Spicy tomato sauce with shrimp, scallops, mussels, linguine
- Shrimp Scampi: Garlic, white wine, butter, served with linguine or risotto
“The seafood at Mulberry Street Bay Shore is as fresh as it gets, perfectly seasoned and cooked to highlight natural flavors.” – Executive Chef
Entrees: Hearty and Satisfying Main Courses
The entrée section of the menu offers a variety of robust options that cater to meat lovers and those seeking hearty, fulfilling meals. From classic Italian dishes like Chicken Parmesan to innovative preparations of veal and beef, this section is designed to satisfy even the most discerning appetites.
Chicken Parmesan is a standout, featuring breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, served alongside spaghetti. Veal Marsala offers tender veal medallions sautéed with mushrooms in a rich Marsala wine sauce, creating a complex flavor profile.
For beef enthusiasts, the Filet Mignon provides a tender, juicy cut cooked to order, often accompanied by a red wine reduction or garlic herb butter.
Vegetarian options also feature prominently, including eggplant rollatini, which is thinly sliced eggplant filled with ricotta and herbs, baked in tomato sauce. Each entrée is thoughtfully plated, ensuring a balance of taste, texture, and visual appeal.
Highlights of Signature Entrées
- Chicken Parmesan: Breaded chicken, marinara, mozzarella, spaghetti
- Veal Marsala: Veal medallions, mushrooms, Marsala wine sauce
- Filet Mignon: Tender beef filet, red wine reduction, seasonal sides
- Eggplant Rollatini: Ricotta-stuffed eggplant, tomato sauce, baked to perfection
Salads and Sides: Fresh and Complementary
Salads and sides at Mulberry Street Bay Shore provide fresh and vibrant accompaniments that enhance the main dishes. The selection ranges from light, crisp salads to hearty vegetable sides, all prepared with fresh ingredients and thoughtful seasoning.
The House Salad features mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, and olives, dressed with a zesty Italian vinaigrette. Caesar Salad offers crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, and house-made croutons, tossed in a creamy dressing.
For sides, offerings include garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed broccoli rabe, and roasted seasonal vegetables, all perfect for complementing any entrée.
These options ensure that diners can customize their meals with fresh, flavorful additions that balance the richness of the main courses. The salads and sides also cater to those looking for lighter or vegetarian-friendly choices.
Popular Salad and Side Options
| Item | Description | Best Paired With |
| House Salad | Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, olives, Italian vinaigrette | Seafood dishes, pasta |
| Caesar Salad | Romaine, parmesan, croutons, creamy dressing | Chicken Parmesan, veal |
| Garlic Mashed Potatoes | Creamy potatoes with roasted garlic | Beef, veal entrees |
| Sautéed Broccoli Rabe | Bitter greens sautéed with garlic and olive oil | Seafood, chicken |
Desserts: Sweet Endings to Remember
The dessert menu captures the essence of Italian sweetness and indulgence, rounding off the meal with rich, flavorful treats. Desserts are crafted to complement the meal’s flavors, often featuring classic Italian ingredients like mascarpone, ricotta, and espresso.
Tiramisu is a beloved choice, with layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream dusted with cocoa powder. Cannoli offer a crunchy shell filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips, frequently garnished with pistachios or candied fruit.
For a warm option, the Chocolate Lava Cake is a decadent finale, featuring a molten center paired with vanilla gelato.
Each dessert is made in-house, showcasing the kitchen’s commitment to quality and tradition. These sweet options provide a perfect balance of richness and freshness to conclude the dining experience.
Signature Desserts
- Tiramisu: Espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone, cocoa dusting
- Cannoli: Crisp shells, sweet ricotta filling, pistachio garnish
- Chocolate Lava Cake: Molten chocolate center, vanilla gelato
- Gelato Selection: Seasonal flavors, creamy and refreshing
“Desserts at Mulberry Street Bay Shore are the perfect harmony of tradition and indulgence – each bite tells a story of authentic Italian sweetness.” – Pastry Chef
Beverage Offerings: Complementing Every Dish
The beverage menu at Mulberry Street Bay Shore is curated to enhance the dining experience, featuring a range of wines, cocktails, and non-alcoholic drinks. Carefully selected wines from Italy and around the world complement the rich flavors of the cuisine, while handcrafted cocktails add a modern twist to classic pairings.
Wine lovers can explore reds such as Chianti and Barolo or whites like Pinot Grigio and Vermentino. The cocktail menu includes Italian-inspired choices like the Negroni and Aperol Spritz, alongside house specials created to refresh and delight.
Non-alcoholic options such as sparkling waters, artisan sodas, and fresh juices ensure that every guest finds a perfect drink pairing.
Each beverage is chosen or crafted to balance the menu’s flavors, whether you’re enjoying a light appetizer or a hearty entrée. The knowledgeable staff is always ready to recommend pairings based on your preferences and meal selection.
Wine and Cocktail Pairing Suggestions
| Dish | Wine | Cocktail |
| Seafood Fra Diavolo | Vermentino | Aperol Spritz |
| Chicken Parmesan | Chianti | Negroni |
| Filet Mignon | Barolo | Old Fashioned |
| Primavera Pasta | Pinot Grigio | Italian Soda |
Conclusion: A Culinary Journey on Mulberry Street
Mulberry Street Bay Shore’s menu is a testament to the art of Italian cooking, blending tradition with creativity to deliver an unforgettable dining experience. Each section of the menu offers thoughtfully prepared dishes, showcasing fresh ingredients, rich flavors, and expert craftsmanship.
From the vibrant appetizers to the indulgent desserts, every item invites diners to savor the essence of Italy in a warm, welcoming setting.
The careful curation of ingredients and the balance between classic and contemporary dishes demonstrate a deep respect for culinary heritage while embracing modern tastes. The menu’s diversity ensures there is something for everyone, whether you prefer seafood, pasta, meat, or vegetarian fare.
Beverage pairings further elevate the meal, making each visit a holistic sensory experience.
Dining at Mulberry Street Bay Shore is more than just a meal; it is a celebration of flavor, culture, and community. Whether you are a local or a visitor, the menu offers a delicious journey through Italian cuisine that leaves a lasting impression and invites you to return time and again.
