Indianapolis is a city known for its thriving food scene, where culinary innovation meets Midwestern hospitality. Among the many eateries carving out a unique space in this dynamic landscape, Jimmy B’s stands out as a beloved institution.
Its menu, a vibrant tapestry of flavors and textures, has earned the loyalty of locals while continually sparking curiosity among visitors. Whether you’re in the mood for comfort classics or bold new taste experiences, Jimmy B’s Indianapolis menu is designed to satisfy a wide array of palates and preferences.
At Jimmy B’s, dining is more than a meal—it’s an experience that brings people together. The menu reflects a commitment to quality ingredients, creative culinary techniques, and a welcoming atmosphere that encourages guests to linger.
Each dish tells a story, drawing on regional influences and global inspirations. From the first bite to the last, Jimmy B’s delivers flavors that are at once familiar and excitingly fresh.
Whether you’re gathering with friends, celebrating with family, or simply treating yourself, every visit promises something memorable.
Starters: Setting the Culinary Stage
The journey through Jimmy B’s Indianapolis menu often begins with their celebrated starters. These appetizers are crafted to whet the appetite, foster conversation, and showcase the kitchen’s creativity.
From classic favorites to inventive bites, the starters set the tone for a memorable dining experience.
One of the most popular offerings is the Loaded Potato Skins, a dish that puts a flavorful twist on a familiar comfort food. Served piping hot, the potato skins are generously topped with cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, and fresh chives, then accompanied by a cool dollop of sour cream.
This starter is a testament to how simple ingredients can create a satisfying, crave-worthy dish.
For those seeking a lighter option, the Avocado Shrimp Cocktail is a standout. Plump shrimp are paired with creamy avocado and a zesty house-made cocktail sauce, delivering a harmonious balance of textures and flavors.
This dish is perfect for sharing or savoring solo, and it offers a refreshing start to any meal.
Jimmy B’s also offers a rotating selection of seasonal starters that highlight Indiana’s local produce. Guests can expect inventive creations such as roasted beet hummus or fried green tomatoes with a spicy remoulade.
These dishes not only reflect the chef’s ingenuity but also showcase a commitment to supporting local farmers.
- Loaded Potato Skins – Cheddar, bacon, chives, sour cream
- Avocado Shrimp Cocktail – Shrimp, avocado, house cocktail sauce
- Seasonal Starter – Chef’s choice, highlighting local ingredients
“The appetizers at Jimmy B’s are the reason I keep coming back. Their potato skins are the best in Indy!” – Local patron
Salads: Fresh and Flavorful Choices
For guests seeking lighter fare or a vibrant complement to the main course, Jimmy B’s salad selections shine. Each salad is thoughtfully composed, balancing freshness, flavor, and nutrition.
The menu’s variety ensures there’s something for every dietary preference.
The Signature Jimmy’s Chopped Salad is a perennial favorite. Featuring crisp romaine, grilled chicken, cherry tomatoes, smoked bacon, blue cheese crumbles, and a tangy vinaigrette, this salad is both satisfying and refreshing.
The combination of proteins and vegetables makes it a complete meal in itself.
Vegetarian diners gravitate toward the Roasted Vegetable Quinoa Salad. This bowl is packed with roasted seasonal vegetables, fluffy quinoa, baby spinach, and a light lemon-herb dressing.
The interplay of warm and cold elements, along with the hearty grains, makes it both nutritious and filling.
Those interested in bold flavors often select the Spicy Southwest Caesar. This twist on the classic features romaine lettuce, roasted corn, black beans, spicy Caesar dressing, and crunchy tortilla strips.
The heat from the dressing is perfectly moderated by the creamy house-made dressing.
- Jimmy’s Chopped Salad – Chicken, bacon, blue cheese, vinaigrette
- Vegetable Quinoa Salad – Roasted veggies, quinoa, spinach, lemon-herb dressing
- Southwest Caesar – Romaine, corn, black beans, spicy Caesar, tortilla strips
| Salad | Main Protein | Key Features |
| Jimmy’s Chopped | Grilled Chicken | Bacon, blue cheese, vinaigrette |
| Veggie Quinoa | Quinoa | Roasted veggies, spinach, lemon-herb |
| Southwest Caesar | None (Vegetarian) | Spicy Caesar, black beans, tortilla strips |
Sandwiches and Wraps: Satisfying Handhelds
Jimmy B’s is renowned for its array of sandwiches and wraps, which bring together high-quality ingredients and bold flavors in every bite. These menu items are designed for guests craving something hearty yet convenient, perfect for lunch or a casual dinner.
The Indy Steak Sandwich is an iconic choice, featuring locally sourced ribeye, caramelized onions, sautéed mushrooms, and melted provolone on a toasted hoagie roll. Each element is carefully prepared to deliver a robust, savory experience.
For those seeking a lighter option, the Grilled Veggie Wrap offers a colorful medley of grilled zucchini, squash, red peppers, and hummus, all bundled in a whole wheat tortilla. The vibrant vegetables provide a satisfying crunch, while the hummus adds creaminess and depth.
Jimmy B’s also offers a Classic Club Sandwich, layered with roasted turkey, smoked ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a tangy house sauce. Served on toasted multigrain bread, this sandwich is a nod to traditional American diners, elevated with fresh ingredients and attention to detail.
- Indy Steak Sandwich – Ribeye, onions, mushrooms, provolone
- Grilled Veggie Wrap – Zucchini, squash, peppers, hummus
- Club Sandwich – Turkey, ham, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, house sauce
“Jimmy B’s sandwiches are my go-to lunch in Indy. The Indy Steak is a must-try for any serious sandwich lover.” – Food critic, Indy Eats
Entrees: Heart of the Menu
The entrees at Jimmy B’s capture the essence of comfort and creativity. These dishes are crafted to provide a memorable main course experience, blending classic techniques with contemporary flavors.
From indulgent favorites to healthy choices, the entrée selection appeals to all tastes.
A signature item is the Maple Bourbon Glazed Salmon. This dish features a perfectly grilled salmon fillet, lacquered with a house-made maple bourbon glaze.
Served alongside garlic mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables, the entrée offers a harmonious balance of sweet and savory notes.
For meat lovers, the Hoosier Fried Chicken is a standout. Tender chicken breast is coated in a seasoned flour blend, fried to golden perfection, and served with creamy coleslaw and buttermilk biscuits.
It’s a dish that pays homage to Indiana’s culinary traditions while delivering exceptional flavor.
Vegetarians aren’t left out, thanks to the Stuffed Portobello Mushroom. Large mushroom caps are filled with a blend of spinach, ricotta, and sun-dried tomatoes, then baked until bubbly.
Finished with a drizzle of balsamic reduction, this entrée is both hearty and satisfying.
- Maple Bourbon Salmon – Grilled salmon, maple bourbon glaze, mashed potatoes, veggies
- Hoosier Fried Chicken – Fried chicken breast, coleslaw, biscuits
- Stuffed Portobello – Spinach, ricotta, sun-dried tomatoes, balsamic
| Entrée | Main Protein | Signature Flavor |
| Maple Bourbon Salmon | Salmon | Maple bourbon glaze |
| Hoosier Fried Chicken | Chicken | Seasoned breading, buttermilk biscuits |
| Stuffed Portobello | Portobello mushroom | Spinach, ricotta, balsamic |
Signature Burgers: Craft and Creativity
Burgers at Jimmy B’s are more than just a menu staple—they’re a point of pride. Each burger is made with fresh, never frozen, Angus beef and served on a locally baked bun.
The kitchen’s devotion to quality and creativity is evident in every bite.
The Jimmy B’s Classic Burger is simplicity perfected. A juicy beef patty is topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, cheddar cheese, and the restaurant’s signature house sauce.
The result is a burger that’s both deeply satisfying and reliably delicious.
For those seeking a little heat, the Firecracker Burger delivers with jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, chipotle aioli, and crispy fried onions. The interplay of spicy, creamy, and crunchy elements creates a memorable flavor profile that keeps guests coming back.
Vegetarians can indulge in the Black Bean Avocado Burger. This plant-based option features a house-made black bean patty, creamy avocado, roasted red peppers, and a tangy cilantro-lime aioli.
It’s a burger that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture.
- Jimmy B’s Classic Burger – Angus beef, cheddar, house sauce
- Firecracker Burger – Jalapeños, pepper jack, chipotle aioli
- Black Bean Avocado Burger – Black bean patty, avocado, cilantro-lime aioli
“The Firecracker Burger at Jimmy B’s is the best burger in the city. Spicy, juicy, and absolutely unforgettable.” – Indy Burger Blog
Comfort Sides and Shareables
No meal at Jimmy B’s is complete without sampling their array of sides and shareable dishes. Designed to complement the main courses or to stand alone as satisfying snacks, these menu items are crowd-pleasers that add variety to every table.
The Truffle Parmesan Fries are a guest favorite, offering crispy fries tossed in aromatic truffle oil and dusted with freshly grated parmesan. These fries are the perfect blend of indulgent and sophisticated, making them a must-order for newcomers and regulars alike.
Another standout is the Mac ‘n’ Cheese Skillet. This side features elbow macaroni enveloped in a creamy three-cheese sauce, baked until bubbling and golden.
It’s a classic comfort dish elevated with premium cheeses and a buttery breadcrumb topping.
Health-conscious diners can opt for the Grilled Asparagus Spears or Seasonal Roasted Vegetables, both of which are prepared with minimal oil and showcased at the peak of freshness. These sides provide a lighter, nutrient-rich balance to the menu’s more indulgent offerings.
- Truffle Parmesan Fries – Truffle oil, parmesan, crispy fries
- Mac ‘n’ Cheese Skillet – Three cheeses, baked macaroni, breadcrumbs
- Grilled Asparagus – Fresh asparagus, olive oil, sea salt
- Seasonal Roasted Vegetables – Chef’s choice, local produce
| Side | Flavor Profile | Best Pairing |
| Truffle Parmesan Fries | Earthy, savory | Burgers, steak sandwich |
| Mac ‘n’ Cheese Skillet | Creamy, rich | Fried chicken, club sandwich |
| Grilled Asparagus | Light, fresh | Salmon, veggie wrap |
| Roasted Vegetables | Nutrient-rich, bright | Portobello, salads |
Desserts: Sweet Endings
A meal at Jimmy B’s wouldn’t be complete without indulging in one of their signature desserts. With each sweet treat, the restaurant’s pastry team demonstrates a passion for both tradition and innovation.
The dessert menu offers the perfect conclusion to a satisfying meal.
The Salted Caramel Bread Pudding is a guest favorite, featuring house-baked brioche soaked in a rich custard, studded with toasted pecans, and finished with a luscious salted caramel sauce. Each spoonful delivers a comforting blend of warmth and sweetness.
Chocolate lovers delight in the Double Chocolate Lava Cake. This dessert features a warm chocolate cake with a molten center, served with vanilla bean ice cream and fresh berries.
The contrast of temperatures and textures makes it irresistible.
For a lighter option, the Lemon Berry Parfait offers layers of tangy lemon curd, whipped cream, and seasonal berries. This dessert is as visually appealing as it is delicious, providing a refreshing end to any meal.
- Salted Caramel Bread Pudding – Brioche, pecans, caramel sauce
- Double Chocolate Lava Cake – Warm chocolate cake, ice cream, berries
- Lemon Berry Parfait – Lemon curd, whipped cream, berries
“If you try one thing at Jimmy B’s, make it the bread pudding. It’s the ultimate comfort dessert.” – Indy Desserts Review
Beverages: Pairings and Signature Drinks
Jimmy B’s beverage program is designed to complement every aspect of the menu, offering a curated selection of drinks for all tastes. The bar features local craft brews, creative cocktails, and a well-rounded wine list.
Whether you’re seeking a refreshing non-alcoholic option or a crafted cocktail, Jimmy B’s delivers.
For beer aficionados, the menu highlights a rotating collection of Indiana’s top craft breweries. Guests can sample seasonal IPAs, stouts, and lagers, each chosen to pair with specific menu items.
The staff is always happy to recommend the perfect brew for your meal.
The cocktail list features house specialties like the Indy Mule—a playful take on the classic Moscow Mule featuring local ginger beer and fresh lime. Another favorite is the Maple Old Fashioned, which incorporates Indiana maple syrup for a regional twist on a timeless drink.
Non-drinkers can enjoy a range of house-made sodas and fresh lemonades, each crafted with real fruit and herbs. These beverages offer a refreshing, flavorful alternative and are especially popular among families and designated drivers.
- Craft Beer Selection – Rotating local and regional brews
- Indy Mule – Vodka, local ginger beer, lime
- Maple Old Fashioned – Bourbon, maple syrup, bitters
- House Lemonades – Seasonal fruit, fresh herbs
| Beverage | Main Ingredient | Best Menu Pairing |
| Indy Mule | Vodka, ginger beer | Chicken, salads |
| Maple Old Fashioned | Bourbon, maple syrup | Steak sandwich, burgers |
| Craft Beer | Varies | Burgers, fries |
| House Lemonade | Fruit, herbs | Wraps, veggie dishes |
“The cocktail program at Jimmy B’s is as thoughtful as the food menu. Each drink is crafted to enhance the overall dining experience.” – Beverage Director, Indy Food Fest
Conclusion: Why Jimmy B’s Indianapolis Menu Stands Out
Jimmy B’s Indianapolis menu is a celebration of culinary diversity, quality, and hospitality. What sets this beloved eatery apart is not just the range of dishes offered, but the care and creativity invested in every plate.
From starters that spark anticipation to desserts that leave a lasting impression, each menu item is a reflection of the restaurant’s commitment to exceptional dining.
The menu’s balance of classic comfort foods and innovative creations ensures that every guest finds something to love. Ingredients are sourced thoughtfully, supporting local farmers and producers whenever possible.
The kitchen team’s expertise is evident in every detail, from perfectly cooked proteins to vibrant, seasonal vegetables.
Jimmy B’s also stands out for its inviting atmosphere and attentive service. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, the staff is dedicated to making each meal enjoyable and memorable.
The beverage program, with its local craft brews and inventive cocktails, complements the food menu beautifully, rounding out the dining experience.
Above all, Jimmy B’s is a place where food brings people together. The menu tells a story of community, creativity, and a genuine love for great food.
For anyone seeking a true taste of Indianapolis—where tradition meets innovation—Jimmy B’s offers a dining experience that’s both deeply familiar and endlessly exciting.
