Step through the doors of Gumby’s Pizza and you’re instantly greeted by the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked crust, bubbling cheese, and a symphony of savory toppings. More than just a college-town staple, Gumby’s Pizza has carved out a cult following thanks to its unconventional creations, endless customization, and welcoming atmosphere.
Whether you’re a die-hard pizza enthusiast or a casual diner seeking comfort food, their menu is designed to satisfy every craving and curiosity. What sets Gumby’s apart isn’t just the sheer variety—it’s the playful spirit behind every pie, wing, and side.
Each item promises a taste adventure, from the world-famous Pokey Stix to towering specialty pizzas and hearty sandwiches. The commitment to quality ingredients and creative options ensures that every visit offers something new to discover.
Dive into the Gumby’s Pizza menu and find yourself tempted by bold flavors, generous portions, and a menu that never takes itself too seriously—but always delivers on flavor. It’s time to explore what makes Gumby’s a beloved favorite in any town it serves.
Signature Pizzas: Creativity Meets Tradition
Gumby’s Pizza has mastered the art of the signature pie, blending classic flavors with inventive toppings for an unforgettable dining experience. Each pizza is crafted with care, offering both traditionalists and adventurous eaters plenty to love.
The menu boasts a dynamic range of options that cater to every palate, whether you crave the comfort of pepperoni or the thrill of experimental combinations.
At the heart of the menu lies a commitment to quality. Only the freshest ingredients are used, from the tangy tomato sauce to the gooey mozzarella that stretches with every bite.
Signature pizzas reflect Gumby’s playful spirit, with names and flavors that stand out from the crowd. The crust serves as the perfect canvas—crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and always baked to golden perfection.
What truly distinguishes Gumby’s signature pizzas is their willingness to take risks. You’ll find pies loaded with everything from classic Italian meats to spicy jalapeños and rich, creamy sauces.
These pizzas are designed for sharing but are so irresistible, you might want one all to yourself.
- Gumby Supreme: A loaded masterpiece with pepperoni, sausage, beef, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
- Stoner Pie: A fan favorite featuring mozzarella sticks, French fries, pepperoni, bacon, and extra cheese.
- Veggie Classic: A garden-fresh blend of tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives.
“Gumby’s pizzas are a canvas for flavor and fun—each slice tells its own story.”
With such a wide array of signature options, Gumby’s ensures that every guest finds a pizza worth savoring. From the first bite to the last crust, these pies keep diners coming back for more.
Build Your Own Pizza: Endless Customization
For those who believe that pizza is a deeply personal experience, Gumby’s offers a robust “Build Your Own” menu. This section empowers guests to design their perfect pie, selecting every element from crust thickness to an extensive list of toppings.
The result is a pizza tailored specifically to your tastes, dietary needs, and mood.
Customization starts with the basics: choose your crust style, from thin and crispy to thick and doughy. Next, pick a sauce—classic tomato, creamy ranch, tangy BBQ, or even spicy buffalo.
Cheese comes next, with options for extra, light, or even dairy-free alternatives.
Toppings are where creativity shines. With dozens of meats, veggies, and specialty ingredients available, the combinations are nearly limitless.
Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a loaded meat-lover’s delight, Gumby’s makes it easy to unleash your inner chef.
- Multiple crust options, including gluten-free
- Wide variety of sauces and cheeses
- Over 20 toppings—from pepperoni and pineapple to feta and jalapeños
Pro tip: Don’t be afraid to mix sauces or pile on unusual toppings. The staff loves seeing new creations come to life.
A build-your-own pizza at Gumby’s is more than just a meal—it’s an opportunity for self-expression. For families, it’s a great way to please picky eaters, while groups of friends can split pies that cater to everyone’s preferences.
Comparing Topping Choices
| Meats | Veggies | Cheeses |
| Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon | Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms | Mozzarella, Feta, Cheddar |
| Ham, Beef, Chicken | Black Olives, Spinach, Tomatoes | Extra Cheese, Vegan Cheese |
Gumby’s “Build Your Own” menu has earned a loyal following among those who crave variety and control. It’s an invitation to get creative—and always delivers a delicious result.
Pokey Stix: The Legendary Sidekick
No discussion of Gumby’s Pizza is complete without mentioning the iconic Pokey Stix. More than just a side dish, Pokey Stix have achieved legendary status, drawing crowds who crave their cheesy, garlicky goodness.
These breadsticks are the ultimate companion to any pizza order, but they’re also a delicious snack all on their own.
Pokey Stix start with Gumby’s signature dough, rolled out and topped with a generous layer of garlic butter and mozzarella cheese. They’re baked until golden and cut into strips, perfect for dipping and sharing.
The result is a melt-in-your-mouth treat with just the right balance of crunch and chew.
- Served with a choice of dipping sauces: marinara, ranch, garlic butter, or spicy buffalo
- Available in multiple sizes to suit solo snacking or group feasts
- Customizable with toppings like bacon, jalapeños, or extra cheese
The popularity of Pokey Stix is undeniable. Some fans come to Gumby’s for the pizza but stay for the stix, making them a must-try for newcomers.
Their crave-worthy reputation extends far beyond the restaurant, with late-night orders and social media shoutouts cementing their status as a menu legend.
“Pokey Stix are the reason I order from Gumby’s—it’s not just a side, it’s an obsession!”
Whether paired with a pizza or enjoyed solo, Pokey Stix deliver comfort and satisfaction in every bite. Their versatility and flavor have made them a beloved staple—and a defining feature of the Gumby’s experience.
Wings and Sides: Beyond the Pizza
While pizza may be the star, Gumby’s has built a robust supporting cast of wings and sides that transform any meal into a feast. These offerings are crafted with the same attention to quality and flavor as their main menu, ensuring every bite is memorable.
The wings menu stands out for its range of flavors and cooking styles. Whether you like your wings classic and crispy or drenched in bold sauces, there’s an option for everyone.
Sauces range from mild and tangy to fiery hot, allowing diners to dial up the heat or keep things mellow.
- Buffalo Wing Sauce: A classic choice for heat seekers
- BBQ: Smoky, sweet, and crowd-pleasing
- Garlic Parmesan: Rich and savory with a creamy finish
- Sweet Chili: Perfect for those who enjoy a balance of sweet and spice
Beyond wings, the sides menu offers something for everyone. From crispy French fries to savory mozzarella sticks and fresh salads, these dishes complement the main event beautifully.
Each side is made fresh and designed to satisfy a wide range of cravings.
Wing Flavor Comparison
| Flavor | Heat Level | Key Notes |
| Buffalo | High | Spicy, tangy |
| BBQ | Low | Sweet, smoky |
| Garlic Parmesan | None | Buttery, rich |
| Sweet Chili | Medium | Sweet, spicy |
For diners looking to round out their meal, Gumby’s wings and sides provide the perfect finishing touch. These menu items are ideal for sharing, making them a favorite choice for parties, game nights, and group gatherings.
Sandwiches and Calzones: Hearty Alternatives
While pizza may dominate the spotlight, Gumby’s sandwiches and calzones deliver just as much flavor and satisfaction. These hearty options offer a change of pace for those who crave something different but still want the signature Gumby’s taste.
The sandwich menu is packed with classics and creative twists alike. Whether you’re craving a meatball sub, chicken parmesan, or a veggie-packed delight, each sandwich is served hot and made to order.
Fresh-baked bread, high-quality meats, and flavorful sauces combine for a meal that’s as filling as it is tasty.
- Gumby’s Meatball Sub: Juicy meatballs, marinara, and melted mozzarella
- Chicken Parmesan: Crispy chicken breast, tangy sauce, and bubbling cheese
- Veggie Delight: Fresh veggies, provolone, and Italian dressing
Calzones provide another appealing alternative. Each calzone is stuffed with your choice of cheese, meats, and veggies before being baked to golden perfection.
The result is a crispy, flaky exterior with a piping-hot, melty interior—a comfort food classic with a Gumby’s twist.
“There’s nothing quite like biting into a freshly baked Gumby’s calzone. It’s comfort food at its finest.”
These menu items showcase the versatility of Gumby’s kitchen, proving that great flavor isn’t limited to just pizza. For a satisfying meal that goes beyond the ordinary, sandwiches and calzones are a must-try.
Salads and Lighter Fare: Freshness on the Menu
Gumby’s understands that not every diner is in the mood for something heavy. Their menu includes a thoughtful selection of salads and lighter fare, perfect for those seeking a balanced or vegetarian option without sacrificing flavor.
Each salad is made to order, ensuring crisp greens and vibrant toppings. The house salad features a medley of mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded cheese, and crunchy croutons.
Caesar salads bring the classic combination of romaine, parmesan, and creamy dressing, while specialty salads may include extras like grilled chicken or fresh avocado.
- House Salad: Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheese, croutons
- Caesar Salad: Romaine, parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing
- Greek Salad: Olives, feta, red onions, and tangy vinaigrette
Dressings are served on the side, allowing for complete customization. Gumby’s also offers add-ons like grilled chicken, crispy bacon, or extra cheese, so you can craft a salad that fits your appetite and preferences.
For those counting calories or seeking gluten-free options, Gumby’s salads deliver on both nutrition and taste.
Salad Comparison Table
| Salad | Main Ingredients | Best For |
| House | Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers | Light meal or side |
| Caesar | Romaine, parmesan, croutons | Classic lovers |
| Greek | Feta, olives, onions | Vegetarians, Mediterranean fans |
Lighter fare ensures that every guest can find something to enjoy at Gumby’s, making it a welcoming spot for all kinds of eaters. These fresh, flavorful options complement the heavier items perfectly, rounding out the menu with healthy balance.
Desserts and Sweet Endings
No meal at Gumby’s is complete without indulging in dessert. The sweet side of the menu is designed to satisfy any craving, offering classic treats and inventive creations that provide the perfect finale to your feast.
Dessert options at Gumby’s are all about comfort and nostalgia. Gooey brownies, chewy cookies, and cinnamon sugar sticks are top picks for those seeking a sweet finish.
These items are baked fresh and served warm, often accompanied by a drizzle of chocolate or a side of icing for dipping.
- Chocolate Chunk Brownie: Rich, fudgy, and perfect for sharing
- Giant Cookie: Soft-baked with generous chocolate chips
- Cinnamon Stix: Buttery breadsticks coated in cinnamon sugar and served with sweet icing
What sets Gumby’s desserts apart is their simplicity and quality. Each treat is made with premium ingredients, ensuring every bite delivers maximum flavor.
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just capping off a meal, these desserts hit the spot.
“Gumby’s desserts are the cherry on top—always the right choice to end your meal with a smile.”
For sweet tooths and casual diners alike, Gumby’s dessert menu is a delightful way to wrap up the dining experience. Don’t skip the sweet endings—they’re worth every bite.
Deals, Combos, and Group Specials
Gumby’s Pizza has built a reputation for value as well as flavor. Their menu is packed with deals, combos, and group specials that make it easy to feed a crowd without breaking the bank.
Whether you’re planning a party, fueling a study session, or just looking for a great deal, Gumby’s delivers.
Combo meals pair pizzas with sides, wings, and drinks at a discounted rate. These packages are designed for sharing and provide a little something for everyone.
Group specials often feature extra-large pies and a selection of sides, perfect for events and gatherings.
- Family Combo: Large pizza, Pokey Stix, wings, and drinks
- Party Pack: Extra-large pizzas, multiple sides, and dessert
- Late-Night Special: Discounted menu items for after-hours cravings
Beyond combos, Gumby’s frequently offers limited-time promotions and student discounts, making it a go-to spot for those on a budget. Portions are generous, ensuring no one leaves hungry.
Ordering as a group? Gumby’s staff are happy to help customize your order for dietary needs and preferences.
Combo Comparison
| Combo | Includes | Best For |
| Family Combo | Pizza, Pokey Stix, wings, drinks | Families, small groups |
| Party Pack | Pizzas, sides, dessert | Large groups, events |
| Late-Night Special | Discounted menu items | Students, night owls |
Value, variety, and convenience are cornerstones of the Gumby’s experience. These deals ensure that every guest enjoys a satisfying meal at a great price, no matter the occasion.
Dietary Options and Special Considerations
Gumby’s Pizza recognizes the importance of accommodating different dietary needs. Their menu has evolved to include options for vegetarians, vegans, and guests seeking gluten-free dishes.
This inclusive approach ensures that everyone can enjoy the Gumby’s experience.
Vegetarian and vegan diners will find plenty to love, from cheese-less pizzas loaded with veggies to salads and sides made with plant-based ingredients. Gluten-free crusts are available for most pizzas, providing a safe and delicious alternative for those with sensitivities.
- Vegetarian pizzas and calzones
- Vegan cheese and sauce options
- Gluten-free crusts upon request
Ingredient transparency is a priority at Gumby’s. The staff is well-trained to handle special requests and can guide diners through the menu to find suitable choices.
For those with allergies or specific dietary restrictions, clear labeling and customizable orders make dining stress-free.
“Gumby’s is my go-to for gluten-free pizza. They make it easy to enjoy great food without worry.”
With an ever-expanding range of options, Gumby’s proves that delicious pizza can—and should—be for everyone. Their commitment to inclusivity makes them a standout in the world of casual dining.
Conclusion: Why Gumby’s Pizza Menu Stands Out
Gumby’s Pizza isn’t just a place to grab a slice—it’s a destination where creativity, quality, and community come together. The menu reflects a passion for bold flavors and generous portions, ensuring every guest leaves with a full stomach and a smile.
From the legendary Pokey Stix to the customizable pizzas and hearty sides, there’s something for every appetite and occasion.
What truly sets Gumby’s apart is the spirit of inclusivity and fun that infuses every menu item. Whether you’re building your own pie, sampling a signature creation, or exploring the diverse range of wings, sides, and desserts, you’ll find that every dish is crafted with care and a sense of adventure.
Deals and group specials ensure that everyone can enjoy great food at a great value, while dietary accommodations make Gumby’s a welcoming spot for all.
For pizza lovers and foodies alike, Gumby’s Pizza offers more than just a meal—it delivers an experience. The ever-evolving menu invites repeat visits, promising something new to discover each time.
Whether you’re a first-timer or a loyal fan, Gumby’s menu is sure to leave a lasting impression. So gather your friends, bring your appetite, and get ready to savor what makes Gumby’s Pizza truly one of a kind.
