Nestled in the heart of Smithville, NJ, Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings has become a beloved local institution, renowned for its diverse and mouthwatering menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. From gourmet pizzas to classic Italian-American dishes, this family-friendly restaurant offers a culinary adventure that will leave you craving for more.
With its inviting atmosphere and commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings has earned a well-deserved reputation for delivering exceptional dining experiences. The menu is a masterful blend of traditional flavors and innovative creations, ensuring that every visit is a delightful journey of gastronomic discovery.
Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza or a bold and flavorful Buffalo Chicken creation, Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings has something to satisfy every craving. Beyond pizzas, the menu also features a tantalizing array of appetizers, salads, burgers, sandwiches, and signature dishes that showcase the restaurant’s dedication to culinary excellence.
Gourmet Pizzas
At Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings, the gourmet pizza offerings are a true delight for the taste buds. Their Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a crowd favorite, featuring a perfect blend of tangy buffalo sauce, juicy chicken, and a creamy ranch drizzle atop a crispy crust. The Margherita Pizza is a classic Italian masterpiece, showcasing fresh basil, sliced tomatoes, and melted mozzarella on a bed of robust tomato sauce.
For those seeking a unique twist, the Crispy Pepperoni Hot Honey Pie is a must-try. This pizza boasts crispy cups of pepperoni drizzled with a sweet and spicy hot honey glaze, creating an irresistible flavor explosion. The Fuggeddaboudit Pizza is a true representation of Costello’s creativity, featuring a savory combination of Italian sausage, roasted peppers, and caramelized onions, topped with a sprinkle of grated parmesan.
If you’re feeling adventurous, the Pizza Palermo is a culinary journey you won’t want to miss. This unique creation features a white sauce base, topped with prosciutto, arugula, and a drizzle of balsamic reduction, providing a perfect balance of flavors and textures.
Appetizers and Sides: A Tempting Array to Share and Savor
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings understands the importance of a delectable start to any meal, which is why their appetizer and side offerings are a true delight. Whether you’re looking to share a few starters with friends or simply want to whet your appetite before diving into the main course, their menu has something for everyone.
One of the standout items is the Jalapeno Poppers, a classic crowd-pleaser that combines the heat of jalapeños with the creamy goodness of melted cheese. These bite-sized morsels are perfectly crispy on the outside and deliciously gooey on the inside, making them an irresistible choice for those who love a little kick.
For those seeking a unique twist on a familiar favorite, the Buffalo Mac & Cheese Eggrolls are a must-try. Imagine the comforting flavors of mac and cheese infused with the tangy and spicy notes of Buffalo sauce, all wrapped in a crispy eggroll wrapper. These innovative appetizers are sure to tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving for more.
But that’s not all – Costello’s offers a diverse selection of appetizers and sides to cater to every palate. From classic mozzarella sticks and loaded nachos to zucchini fries and garlic knots, there’s something to satisfy every craving. And with generous portions perfect for sharing, these starters make for an excellent way to kick off your dining experience with friends and family.
Soups and Salads
At Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings, you’ll find a delightful selection of soups and salads to complement your meal or satisfy your cravings for lighter fare. The soup offerings are a true testament to the restaurant’s commitment to authentic Italian-American flavors.
One standout option is the Pasta Fagioli, a hearty and comforting soup brimming with pasta, beans, and aromatic vegetables in a rich tomato broth. Each spoonful is a delicious blend of textures and flavors that will transport you straight to an Italian kitchen.
Another crowd-pleaser is the Chicken Tortellini soup, featuring tender cheese-filled tortellini and succulent pieces of chicken in a savory broth. This warming and satisfying soup is the perfect choice for chilly days or when you’re in need of a comforting meal.
For those seeking a lighter option, Costello’s offers a variety of fresh and crisp salads. The Classic Caesar salad is a timeless favorite, with crisp romaine lettuce, tangy Caesar dressing, and crunchy croutons. You can also opt for the Costello’s House Salad, a vibrant mix of greens, vegetables, and your choice of dressing.
No matter your preference, the soups and salads at Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings are sure to delight your taste buds and provide a refreshing and flavorful addition to your dining experience.
Burgers and Chicken Sandwiches
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings takes burgers and chicken sandwiches to the next level with their creative and mouthwatering offerings. For burger lovers, the Blue Bacon Burger is a must-try. This juicy patty is topped with crumbled blue cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and a tangy blue cheese dressing, all nestled between a soft brioche bun. The combination of flavors is simply irresistible, with the rich blue cheese perfectly complementing the salty bacon and savory beef.
If you’re in the mood for a chicken sandwich, the Bruschetta Chicken Sandwich is a standout choice. Tender grilled chicken breast is topped with a vibrant bruschetta mixture of diced tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, and a balsamic glaze. The flavors burst in your mouth with each bite, making it a refreshing and satisfying option. The sandwich is served on a toasted ciabatta roll, adding a delightful crunch to the overall texture.
Whether you’re craving a classic burger or a unique twist on a chicken sandwich, Costello’s has something to satisfy every palate. Their burgers and sandwiches are made with high-quality ingredients and served with a side of crispy fries or a fresh salad, ensuring a complete and satisfying dining experience.
Costello’s Classics
If you’re craving something truly unique and flavorful, Costello’s Classics are sure to delight your taste buds. These signature items showcase the restaurant’s creativity and commitment to delivering exceptional dining experiences.
One of the standout offerings is The Fatty Sub, a towering sandwich that defies traditional expectations. Packed with succulent pulled pork, crispy bacon, and melted provolone cheese, this sub is a flavor explosion. The tangy barbecue sauce and creamy coleslaw provide the perfect balance of sweet and tangy notes, making each bite a delightful adventure.
For those who love the bold flavors of Buffalo chicken, the Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla is a must-try. Tender chunks of chicken are tossed in a zesty Buffalo sauce and nestled between layers of melted cheese and crispy tortillas. The combination of spicy, savory, and gooey textures creates a truly craveable dish that will have you reaching for more.
Costello’s Classics menu also features other unique offerings, such as the Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls and the Loaded Potato Skins. These inventive twists on classic favorites showcase the restaurant’s commitment to pushing culinary boundaries and delivering unforgettable dining experiences.
Kid’s Menu
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings understands the importance of catering to the littlest members of the family. Their kid’s menu is designed to delight young taste buds while providing a welcoming and enjoyable dining experience for the whole family.
One of the standout options on the kid’s menu is the classic Cheese Pizza. Made with fresh ingredients and a perfectly baked crust, this simple yet delicious pizza is sure to be a hit with even the pickiest eaters. For those seeking something a little heartier, the Chicken Tenders are a crowd-pleaser. Served with a side of fries or a small salad, this dish is a familiar favorite that kids love.
But Costello’s doesn’t stop there. They also offer a Grilled Cheese Sandwich, a comforting and nostalgic choice that never fails to satisfy. And for the little ones with a sweet tooth, the Kid’s Sundae is a delightful treat featuring vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate syrup and whipped cream.
What truly sets Costello’s apart is their commitment to creating a family-friendly atmosphere. The restaurant’s warm and inviting ambiance, coupled with attentive service, ensures that parents and children alike feel welcomed and comfortable. Whether it’s a special occasion or a casual family outing, Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings is the perfect spot to create lasting memories over delicious food and good company.
Desserts and Beverages
No meal at Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings is complete without indulging in one of their decadent desserts. For those with a sweet tooth, the Cannoli is a must-try. These crisp pastry shells are filled with a rich, creamy sweetened ricotta cheese filling, often studded with chocolate chips or candied fruit. Each bite is a delightful harmony of textures and flavors that will leave you craving more.
If you’re a chocolate lover, the Chocolate Mud Pie is sure to satisfy your cravings. This indulgent treat features a thick, fudgy chocolate filling nestled in a crisp cookie crust, topped with a layer of whipped cream and chocolate shavings. It’s a chocolate lover’s dream come true, with each bite delivering an intense, rich cocoa flavor that will have you savoring every bite.
To complement your meal or dessert, Costello’s offers a variety of beverages to quench your thirst. From classic sodas and iced teas to specialty Italian sodas and smoothies, there’s something to suit every taste preference. For those seeking an adult beverage, a selection of beers and wines are available to pair perfectly with your Italian-American fare.
Signature Subs and Other Items
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings offers a tantalizing array of signature subs, calzones, and strombolis that are sure to satisfy any craving. Their sub sandwiches are generously stuffed with fresh ingredients and served on locally-sourced bread, making each bite a delightful experience.
One of the standout offerings is the legendary Buffalo-style chicken subs. These subs are packed with juicy, crispy chicken tenders tossed in Costello’s signature Buffalo sauce, creating a perfect balance of heat and flavor. The combination of the tender chicken, tangy sauce, and crisp veggies makes for an unforgettable sandwich.
For those seeking a heartier option, the calzones and strombolis are a must-try. Costello’s calzones are stuffed to the brim with a variety of fillings, from classic pepperoni and sausage to unique combinations like spinach and feta. The strombolis, on the other hand, are rolled and baked to perfection, with a crispy exterior and a savory filling that will leave you craving for more.
Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Italian sub or a unique twist on traditional favorites, Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings has something to satisfy every palate. Their commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients ensures that each bite is a flavor explosion you won’t soon forget.
Conclusion
Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings in Smithville, NJ, offers a diverse and mouthwatering menu that caters to every craving. From gourmet pizzas with unique toppings to classic Italian-American dishes, there’s something for everyone. The family-friendly atmosphere and kid’s menu make it an ideal destination for a fun dining experience.
Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty burger, a flavorful chicken sandwich, or a signature sub, Costello’s has you covered. Don’t forget to save room for their tempting desserts, like the decadent Chocolate Mud Pie or the classic Cannoli.
Experience the flavors of Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings for yourself by visiting their location in Smithville or ordering online for convenient pickup or delivery. Visit https://costellospizzaandwings.com/order-online to place your order and indulge in the deliciousness today!