Stepping into Carollo’s Deli is like entering a world where tradition and innovation blend seamlessly. The tantalizing aroma of freshly baked breads, simmering sauces, and seasoned meats fills the air, inviting guests on a culinary journey through classic Italian flavors and contemporary deli favorites.
Carollo’s Deli Menu is thoughtfully curated, highlighting generations-old recipes alongside inventive new combinations, all crafted with premium ingredients and genuine care. Whether you’re seeking a comforting hot sandwich after a long day, a refreshing salad for a light lunch, or a tray of antipasti for a special gathering, Carollo’s promises satisfaction.
Their commitment to quality is evident in every bite, making the deli not just a place to eat, but a memorable experience worth savoring. With a menu that is both expansive and focused, Carollo’s Deli stands out as a beacon for food lovers seeking authenticity without compromise.
Every dish tells a story, and each visit offers a chance to discover something new and delicious.
Signature Sandwiches: The Heart of Carollo’s Deli
The foundation of Carollo’s Deli menu lies in its remarkable selection of sandwiches. Crafted with local and imported ingredients, each sandwich is a testament to the artistry of deli cuisine.
Whether you prefer hot or cold, meat-packed or vegetarian options, the offerings are sure to please every palate.
Classic Italian subs remain a crowd favorite, each layered with carefully sourced meats and cheeses. For those seeking warmth and comfort, Carollo’s hot sandwiches deliver, featuring slow-roasted meats and hearty sauces that soak perfectly into the bread.
Vegetarian selections are equally robust, brimming with grilled vegetables, fresh mozzarella, and flavorful spreads.
The bread at Carollo’s deserves special mention. Each loaf is baked fresh daily, boasting a crusty exterior and soft, airy interior.
The dedication to freshness elevates every sandwich, ensuring a consistent and satisfying texture.
Customization is welcomed, allowing guests to add or substitute ingredients to match their cravings. With each bite, the passion and expertise of the Carollo’s team shines through.
- Classic Italian Sub: Genoa salami, ham, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar
- Chicken Parmigiana: Crispy chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, melted mozzarella, toasted Italian roll
- Veggie Delight: Grilled eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto
“Every sandwich at Carollo’s is a tribute to our family heritage, made with the same care our grandparents brought from the old country.” – Chef Antonio Carollo
Homemade Soups: Comfort in Every Spoonful
As the seasons change, so do Carollo’s soup offerings. These homemade creations are the epitome of warmth and comfort, perfect for pairing with a sandwich or enjoying on their own.
Each soup is crafted daily with market-fresh vegetables, meats, and aromatic herbs.
The menu features both time-honored classics and inventive new recipes. There’s always a sense of excitement in discovering what’s simmering in the kitchen each day.
Whether you’re drawn to the richness of a creamy bisque or the rustic heartiness of a minestrone, Carollo’s has something to satisfy every craving.
Soups at Carollo’s are made in small batches to ensure optimal flavor and freshness. The chefs use slow-cooking techniques to extract maximum taste from every ingredient, resulting in broths and bases that are deep, layered, and satisfying.
For guests with dietary preferences, vegetarian and gluten-free options are consistently available. It’s an inclusive approach that allows everyone to experience the comfort that only a great bowl of soup can provide.
- Italian Wedding Soup – Mini meatballs, escarole, acini di pepe pasta, rich chicken broth
- Minestrone – Seasonal vegetables, beans, pasta, tomato base, finished with fresh herbs
- Chicken and Rice – Tender chicken, carrots, celery, long-grain rice, savory stock
- Roasted Tomato Basil Bisque – Creamy roasted tomatoes, garden basil, a touch of cream
“A bowl of our soup is more than a meal—it’s a reminder that simple ingredients, when treated right, create extraordinary flavor.” – Maria Carollo
Artisanal Salads: Freshness Meets Flavor
Carollo’s Deli redefines what it means to enjoy a salad. These are not mere sides, but thoughtfully composed dishes that burst with color, texture, and taste.
Each salad is made to order, using only the freshest greens, vegetables, and house-made dressings.
Signature salads highlight Italian flavors—think peppery arugula, ripe tomatoes, creamy cheeses, and briny olives. Proteins such as grilled chicken, tuna, or imported prosciutto can be added for those seeking a heartier meal.
The balance between crisp greens and robust toppings ensures every bite is both satisfying and invigorating.
Dressings are a point of pride at Carollo’s. From classic balsamic vinaigrette to zesty lemon-oregano, each is crafted in-house to complement the unique combinations found in the salads.
This attention to detail makes every salad a standout.
Customer favorites range from traditional Caesar to inventive creations featuring roasted vegetables, nuts, and fruit. There is truly a salad for every mood and appetite.
- Antipasto Salad – Mixed greens, salami, provolone, roasted peppers, olives, tomatoes, house vinaigrette
- Caprese Salad – Sliced vine tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic reduction
- Roasted Veggie Salad – Grilled eggplant, zucchini, artichokes, arugula, toasted pine nuts, lemon dressing
| Salad | Main Ingredients | Dressing |
| Antipasto | Salami, Provolone, Roasted Peppers | House Vinaigrette |
| Caprese | Tomato, Mozzarella, Basil | Olive Oil, Balsamic Reduction |
| Roasted Veggie | Eggplant, Zucchini, Artichokes | Lemon Dressing |
House-Made Sides: Perfect Complements
No deli experience is complete without an array of thoughtfully crafted sides. Carollo’s Deli offers a selection of house-made accompaniments that elevate every meal.
Each side is prepared fresh daily, using quality ingredients and seasoned with care.
From crispy arancini to tangy marinated olives, the sides menu is a celebration of Italian snacking traditions. These dishes are perfect for sharing or adding a little extra variety to your plate.
Every option is designed to pair harmoniously with the deli’s sandwiches and salads.
Hot sides like meatballs in marinara and eggplant rollatini offer a taste of home-cooked comfort. Cold options, such as pasta salad and giardiniera, provide a refreshing counterpoint to richer fare.
Carollo’s commitment to variety ensures there’s always a side to suit your mood.
For guests seeking a true Italian feast, combination plates allow you to mix and match several sides. It’s a wonderful way to sample the breadth of Carollo’s culinary talents.
- Arancini: Crispy risotto balls stuffed with mozzarella and peas
- Marinated Olives: Selection of Sicilian olives, citrus zest, fresh herbs
- Meatballs in Marinara: Beef and pork meatballs, slow-cooked in savory tomato sauce
- Pasta Salad: Rotini pasta, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, feta, Italian dressing
“Our sides are more than add-ons—they’re a way to experience the flavors that define Italian comfort food.” – Lucia Carollo
Prepared Foods and Catering: Bringing Carollo’s Home
Carollo’s Deli understands that great food is best when shared. Their prepared foods and catering services bring the deli’s celebrated flavors to any occasion, large or small.
Whether you’re planning a family gathering or a corporate luncheon, Carollo’s offers abundant and customizable options.
Prepared foods are available daily, featuring hearty entrées, baked pasta dishes, and seasonal specialties. These ready-to-eat selections make weeknight dinners effortless, saving time without sacrificing quality or flavor.
Every dish is packaged with care, ensuring freshness and ease of reheating.
The catering menu is impressively broad, ranging from sandwich and antipasto platters to hot trays of lasagna and chicken marsala. Customization is encouraged, allowing hosts to tailor their order to guests’ preferences and dietary needs.
Carollo’s experienced team provides guidance and support throughout the planning process. Their attention to detail and responsive service make every event shine, ensuring guests leave satisfied and impressed.
- Hot Entrées: Lasagna, chicken parmigiana, sausage & peppers
- Cold Platters: Italian meats & cheeses, marinated vegetables, artisan breads
- Pasta Trays: Baked ziti, penne vodka, stuffed shells
- Dessert Platters: Cannoli, biscotti, tiramisu squares
| Catering Option | Best For | Serving Size |
| Sandwich Platter | Office lunches, parties | 10-20 people |
| Hot Entrée Tray | Family gatherings | 8-12 people |
| Dessert Platter | Celebrations | 15-25 people |
Old-World Italian Specialties: Tradition on Every Table
At the core of Carollo’s Deli is a reverence for old-world Italian recipes. These cherished dishes are steeped in tradition, prepared with techniques and flavors passed down through generations.
Guests return again and again for a taste of authentic Italian comfort food.
Homemade sausages, hand-rolled gnocchi, and slow-braised meats anchor the specialties menu. Each preparation reflects a dedication to using time-honored methods, from hand-mixing doughs to slow-simmering sauces for hours.
The result is a menu that feels both nostalgic and deeply satisfying.
Seasonal specialties highlight regional Italian favorites, such as Sicilian caponata in summer and hearty polenta dishes in winter. Carollo’s takes pride in importing select ingredients—like San Marzano tomatoes and Parmigiano-Reggiano—to ensure every dish is as authentic as possible.
Diners seeking a true taste of Italy need look no further than these dishes. Each bite is a celebration of history, family, and the enduring appeal of Italian cuisine.
- Homemade Sausage: Pork, fennel, garlic, house spice blend
- Eggplant Parmigiana: Breaded eggplant, marinara, mozzarella, Parmigiano-Reggiano
- Handmade Gnocchi: Potato dumplings, choice of marinara or pesto sauce
- Osso Buco (Seasonal): Slow-braised veal shank, rich vegetable ragù
“Preserving our culinary heritage isn’t just about recipes—it’s about creating memories, one meal at a time.” – Giovanni Carollo
Decadent Desserts: Sweet Finishes
Every meal deserves a sweet ending, and Carollo’s Deli delivers with its array of decadent desserts. Each treat is prepared in-house or sourced from local Italian bakeries, ensuring authenticity and quality.
The dessert menu is a blend of classic Italian pastries and innovative confections, all designed to satisfy any sweet tooth.
Cannoli, with their crisp shells and creamy ricotta filling, are a perennial favorite. Tiramisu, delicately layered with espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone, offers a perfect balance of flavors.
Carollo’s biscotti, available in flavors like almond and chocolate hazelnut, are ideal for pairing with coffee or espresso.
Seasonal specialties add excitement to the dessert case, with offerings like sfogliatelle in winter and fruit tarts in summer. Carollo’s also accommodates special orders for birthdays, holidays, and celebrations, making it easy to bring a touch of Italian sweetness to any occasion.
Every dessert is crafted with the same attention to detail as the savory dishes. From the first bite to the last, guests are treated to a memorable finale that lingers long after the meal is over.
- Cannoli: Hand-rolled pastry shells, sweet ricotta filling, chocolate chips
- Tiramisu: Espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone, cocoa
- Biscotti: Twice-baked cookies in almond, pistachio, and chocolate flavors
- Sfogliatelle: Flaky pastry, orange-scented ricotta filling
| Dessert | Main Flavors | Perfect Pairing |
| Cannoli | Ricotta, Chocolate | Espresso |
| Tiramisu | Coffee, Mascarpone | Cappuccino |
| Biscotti | Almond, Chocolate | Latte |
Beverages and Specialty Drinks: The Perfect Pairing
No meal at Carollo’s Deli is complete without the right beverage to complement your dish. The selection includes everything from classic Italian sodas to rich, aromatic coffees.
Whether you’re looking for a refreshing drink on a hot day or a warming cup to accompany dessert, there’s something for every preference.
The coffee bar features espresso, cappuccino, and traditional brewed coffee, all made with premium beans. These offerings pair beautifully with Carollo’s pastries and desserts.
For those seeking something unique, the deli also offers specialty drinks such as affogato—espresso poured over vanilla gelato—for an indulgent treat.
Imported Italian sodas and sparkling waters provide a crisp, refreshing alternative to standard soft drinks. Flavors like blood orange, lemon, and chinotto offer a taste of Italy in every sip.
Carollo’s also stocks a selection of fine teas, both hot and iced, to round out the menu.
Guests are encouraged to explore beverage pairings that enhance their meal. The staff is always happy to recommend the perfect drink, ensuring that every visit ends on a flavorful note.
- Espresso: Rich, intense Italian coffee, served solo or as the base for other drinks
- Italian Sodas: Blood orange, lemon, peach, and more
- Affogato: Espresso poured over creamy vanilla gelato
- Herbal Teas: Chamomile, Earl Grey, peppermint
“Pairing the right beverage with your meal is an art—and one we’re passionate about perfecting for our guests.”
Conclusion: The Carollo’s Deli Experience
Carollo’s Deli menu is more than a list of dishes—it’s a celebration of culinary heritage, innovation, and community. The passion behind every sandwich, salad, and pastry is palpable, offering guests a genuine taste of Italy with every visit.
Whether you’re a regular seeking comfort in the familiar, or a newcomer eager to explore new flavors, Carollo’s welcomes you with open arms and an abundance of delicious options.
The variety and quality found throughout the menu reflect a commitment to excellence that has defined Carollo’s for generations. By honoring tradition while embracing creativity, the deli has carved out a unique place in the hearts—and appetites—of its patrons.
Each meal is an opportunity to connect, to savor, and to create lasting memories around the table.
Choosing Carollo’s Deli means choosing authenticity, hospitality, and a dedication to great food. From the first sip of espresso to the last bite of cannoli, every experience is crafted to delight.
Discover the flavors, the stories, and the warmth that make Carollo’s Deli a cherished destination for all who appreciate the very best in Italian-American cuisine.
