Brooklyn Pickle in Utica offers an exciting culinary experience that blends authentic New York deli flavors with a contemporary twist. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and carefully curated menu, this eatery has become a favorite destination for locals and visitors alike.
Whether you’re craving classic deli sandwiches, innovative salads, or crave-worthy sides, Brooklyn Pickle delivers with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold, satisfying tastes. Its unique approach to traditional deli fare ensures every bite is memorable, making it a standout spot in Utica’s bustling food scene.
The menu at Brooklyn Pickle is thoughtfully designed to cater to a variety of palates, from meat lovers to vegetarians, ensuring no one leaves hungry or disappointed. Each dish showcases the kitchen’s commitment to quality and creativity, featuring house-made pickles that add a signature zing to every plate.
The combination of hearty portions and well-balanced flavors creates a dining experience that’s both comforting and exciting.
Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or planning a relaxed dinner with friends, Brooklyn Pickle’s menu offers something for everyone. Their dedication to blending traditional deli staples with contemporary culinary influences makes dining here a truly unique Utica experience.
Signature Sandwiches
The heart of Brooklyn Pickle’s menu lies in its signature sandwiches, each crafted with care and a nod to classic New York deli traditions. These sandwiches are a celebration of bold flavors, generous portions, and the unmistakable crunch of their house-made pickles.
Perfect for lunch or a casual dinner, they capture the essence of a true deli experience with a modern edge.
Each sandwich includes freshly baked bread that is carefully selected to complement the fillings, whether it’s a soft rye, crusty hero roll, or a fluffy brioche bun. The menu features options ranging from the classic Reuben to inventive creations that incorporate unexpected ingredients for a fresh take.
Meat quality is a priority, with premium cuts of pastrami, corned beef, and smoked turkey.
Popular Choices
- The Brooklyn Classic: Piled high with pastrami, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye bread.
- Smoked Turkey Avocado: Tender smoked turkey breast with creamy avocado, lettuce, tomato, and a zesty chipotle mayo on brioche.
- Veggie Delight: Grilled seasonal vegetables, hummus, and fresh arugula on a toasted hero roll.
Each sandwich is served with a side of Brooklyn Pickle’s famous pickles, offering a crunchy, tangy counterpoint to the rich and savory fillings. This pairing is essential to the overall flavor profile and distinguishes their sandwiches from the rest.
“Our sandwiches are about honoring tradition while embracing innovation. Every bite tells a story of quality, care, and creativity.”
Fresh Salads and Bowls
For those seeking lighter fare without sacrificing taste, Brooklyn Pickle’s selection of fresh salads and bowls provides a vibrant alternative. These dishes highlight seasonal produce and thoughtfully balanced ingredients, ideal for health-conscious diners or anyone looking to refresh their palate.
Salads are crafted with an emphasis on texture and flavor contrasts, combining crisp greens, crunchy nuts, and savory proteins. The bowls often include grains like quinoa or farro, paired with fresh herbs and a variety of dressings that range from tangy vinaigrettes to creamy tahini-based sauces.
These options are perfect for a nutritious meal that doesn’t compromise on satisfaction.
Signature Salads
- Harvest Bowl: Roasted sweet potatoes, kale, quinoa, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, and apple cider vinaigrette.
- Southwest Chicken Salad: Grilled chicken, black beans, corn, avocado, tortilla strips, and chipotle ranch dressing.
- Mediterranean Quinoa Salad: Quinoa, cucumbers, tomatoes, olives, feta cheese, and lemon herb dressing.
Each salad or bowl can be customized with additional proteins or toppings, allowing for a personalized dining experience. The freshness of the ingredients is always a priority, ensuring vibrant flavors and satisfying textures.
| Salad/Bowl | Main Ingredients | Calories (Approx.) |
| Harvest Bowl | Sweet potatoes, kale, quinoa, cranberries, pumpkin seeds | 450 |
| Southwest Chicken Salad | Chicken, black beans, corn, avocado, tortilla strips | 520 |
| Mediterranean Quinoa Salad | Quinoa, cucumbers, tomatoes, olives, feta | 400 |
Appetizers and Small Plates
Brooklyn Pickle’s appetizers and small plates set the tone for a flavorful meal, offering guests a chance to sample unique tastes and shareable bites. These dishes are perfect for starting a meal or enjoying alongside drinks with friends.
The variety spans from classic deli snacks to inventive creations inspired by both local and international flavors.
The kitchen focuses on bold seasoning and balanced flavors, using fresh ingredients and house-made components whenever possible. The small plates are designed to complement the main courses, with options that range from light and fresh to rich and indulgent, catering to all kinds of appetites.
Popular Starters
- Pickle Platter: A selection of house-made pickles including spicy dill, bread and butter, and garlic dill varieties.
- Buffalo Cauliflower Bites: Crispy battered cauliflower tossed in a tangy buffalo sauce served with blue cheese dressing.
- Smoked Salmon Dip: Creamy dip with smoked salmon, capers, and fresh dill, served with toasted baguette slices.
Appetizers can be paired with Brooklyn Pickle’s carefully curated beverage menu, enhancing the overall dining experience. The emphasis on house-made pickles even in the starters highlights the restaurant’s signature touch.
“Our appetizers are crafted to excite the palate and complement the main dishes, creating a cohesive and memorable meal.”
Sides and Extras
To enhance any meal, Brooklyn Pickle offers a variety of sides and extras that embody the spirit of classic deli cuisine with a modern flair. These sides are perfect for sharing or adding a little extra to your sandwich or salad, rounding out your meal perfectly.
The selection includes both traditional deli staples and innovative accompaniments that bring additional textures and flavors. Each side is prepared with the same care as the main dishes, ensuring quality and freshness.
Must-Try Sides
- Hand-Cut Fries: Crispy, golden fries seasoned with sea salt and served with house-made ketchup.
- Mac and Cheese: Creamy and cheesy baked macaroni with a crunchy breadcrumb topping.
- Coleslaw: A tangy and refreshing mix of shredded cabbage and carrots in a light vinaigrette.
Many of these sides incorporate Brooklyn Pickle’s signature flavors, such as the tangy pickled elements or the use of bold spices, making every bite interesting and satisfying. They are designed to complement rather than overshadow the main dishes.
| Side | Description | Pairing Suggestions |
| Hand-Cut Fries | Sea salted, crispy fries with house ketchup | Classic sandwiches, burgers |
| Mac and Cheese | Creamy baked macaroni with breadcrumb topping | Smoked meats, chicken dishes |
| Coleslaw | Tangy shredded cabbage and carrot salad | Fried foods, sandwiches |
Desserts
Brooklyn Pickle rounds out its menu with a selection of indulgent desserts that provide a sweet finish to the meal. These treats combine classic deli dessert inspirations with innovative touches that surprise and delight.
Each dessert is crafted to balance sweetness with texture, often incorporating elements like nuts, fruit, or rich chocolate. The dessert offerings are perfect for sharing or enjoying solo as a well-deserved finale to your dining experience.
Popular Desserts
- New York Cheesecake: Creamy and dense cheesecake with a graham cracker crust, served with fresh berry compote.
- Chocolate Babka Bread Pudding: A decadent twist on bread pudding featuring rich chocolate babka and a drizzle of caramel sauce.
- Pickled Cherry Ice Cream: A unique flavor combining tart pickled cherries with creamy ice cream.
The dessert menu reflects Brooklyn Pickle’s commitment to creativity, inviting guests to end their meal with something both comforting and unexpected.
“Dessert at Brooklyn Pickle is about reimagining tradition with a twist—familiar flavors transformed into something extraordinary.”
Beverage Selection
Complementing the food, Brooklyn Pickle offers a thoughtfully curated beverage menu that includes craft beers, artisanal sodas, and carefully selected wines. The beverage options are designed to enhance the flavors of the dishes and provide a well-rounded dining experience.
The drink menu features both local and international selections, with an emphasis on quality and variety. Whether you prefer a crisp lager, a rich red wine, or a refreshing non-alcoholic option, there’s something to suit every taste.
Featured Beverages
- Local Craft Beers: Rotating taps featuring popular Utica breweries and regional favorites.
- Artisanal Sodas: House-made sodas with unique flavors like ginger-lime and blackberry hibiscus.
- Wine Selection: A small but well-chosen list of reds, whites, and rosés to pair perfectly with deli fare.
Brooklyn Pickle also offers seasonal cocktails crafted with fresh ingredients and creative flavor combinations, making the beverage menu a destination in its own right.
| Beverage | Type | Recommended Pairing |
| Brooklyn Lager | Craft Beer | Pastrami Sandwich, Hand-Cut Fries |
| Ginger-Lime Soda | Non-Alcoholic | Veggie Delight Sandwich, Salads |
| Pinot Noir | Red Wine | Smoked Turkey Avocado, Mac and Cheese |
Special Dietary Options
Recognizing the diverse dietary needs of its patrons, Brooklyn Pickle offers a range of special dietary options that cater to gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan preferences. The kitchen is attentive to these requirements, ensuring that dishes are both safe and delicious.
These options are clearly marked on the menu, and the staff is knowledgeable about ingredient details and cross-contamination precautions. This commitment allows guests with specific diets to enjoy a satisfying meal without compromising on flavor or variety.
Dietary Highlights
- Gluten-Free: Several sandwiches and salads can be made with gluten-free bread or without bread entirely.
- Vegetarian and Vegan: Multiple plant-based dishes, including the Veggie Delight sandwich and several salads, are prepared without animal products.
- Allergy-Friendly: The staff can accommodate common allergies and suggest suitable menu items.
Brooklyn Pickle’s dedication to inclusivity means that everyone can find something enjoyable and thoughtfully prepared on the menu, reinforcing their reputation as a welcoming neighborhood spot.
“Our goal is to create a menu where every guest feels catered to, no matter their dietary needs or preferences.”
Conclusion
Brooklyn Pickle in Utica offers a menu that masterfully balances tradition and innovation, creating a dining experience that is both nostalgic and refreshingly modern. Its dedication to quality ingredients, house-made pickles, and carefully crafted dishes ensures every meal is memorable.
The variety of offerings—from hearty sandwiches and fresh salads to indulgent desserts and curated beverages—caters to a broad spectrum of tastes and preferences.
The restaurant’s attention to detail extends beyond flavor, embracing dietary inclusivity and providing options for gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan diners. This commitment reflects a deep understanding of the community it serves and a desire to make everyone feel welcome.
The thoughtful pairing of sides and drinks further enhances the overall experience, encouraging guests to savor every bite and sip.
Whether you’re a longtime deli aficionado or new to this style of cuisine, Brooklyn Pickle’s menu promises a satisfying and enjoyable meal. It’s a place where quality, creativity, and community come together, making it a standout choice for dining in Utica.
