Nestled in the heart of Lawton, Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria has become a beloved culinary landmark for locals and visitors alike. With its welcoming ambiance and commitment to authentic flavors, this eatery stands out as a hub for pizza enthusiasts seeking both traditional and inventive creations.
From the moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering tomato sauce envelops you, evoking a sense of comfort and anticipation. The pizzeria’s menu is a testament to its dedication to quality, offering a diverse array of options that cater to classic tastes while also daring to surprise with unique combinations.
Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria is more than just a spot to grab a slice—it’s a gathering place where families, friends, and food lovers come together to share laughter, stories, and, of course, exceptional food.
The menu reflects this spirit of community, featuring not only hand-tossed pizzas but also hearty appetizers, savory pasta dishes, fresh salads, and indulgent desserts. Whether you’re a purist who craves a perfectly executed Margherita or an adventurous eater eager to sample specialty pies, Ben And Jay’s promises a memorable dining experience.
The menu’s thoughtful design ensures there’s something to satisfy every craving and dietary preference, making it a must-visit destination in Lawton.
Signature Pizzas: The Heart of the Menu
The signature pizzas at Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria form the backbone of their menu, showcasing the artistry and passion that go into every pie. Each pizza is crafted with a dedication to authenticity and flavor, utilizing high-quality ingredients and time-honored techniques.
Diners can choose from a curated selection of classic and inventive options, ensuring a delightful experience for every palate.
Ben And Jay’s takes pride in their dough, which is fermented for over 24 hours to develop a complex, satisfying texture. The sauce is simmered daily from vine-ripened tomatoes, and the cheese blend is carefully sourced for optimal melt and taste.
This attention to detail elevates each pizza, transforming familiar favorites into unforgettable bites. Whether you stick to tradition or try something new, the signature pizzas set the standard.
Customer Favorites
- Margherita: A timeless classic with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of extra-virgin olive oil.
- Pepperoni Deluxe: Generous layers of spicy, crispy pepperoni atop bubbly cheese and tangy sauce.
- The Lawton Supreme: Piled high with sausage, bell peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
- BBQ Chicken Pizza: Tender grilled chicken, smoky barbecue sauce, and red onions.
Each signature pizza is available in three sizes, making it easy to order for solo diners or larger groups. The menu also highlights the option to customize your pie, allowing guests to swap out sauces, cheeses, or toppings for a truly personalized meal.
“The best pizzas in Lawton—every bite reminds me of home. Ben And Jay’s has mastered the art of comfort food.” — Local patron review
For those seeking a taste of the region, the Lawton Supreme delivers local flair through its hearty toppings and bold flavors. Specialty pizzas rotate seasonally, ensuring there’s always a new creation to try.
The signature selection is a celebration of the pizzeria’s commitment to quality and culinary creativity.
Build-Your-Own Pizza Experience
For guests who crave control over their meal, the build-your-own pizza option is an enticing feature of Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria. This interactive approach empowers diners to select every element of their pizza, from the crust to the finishing drizzle.
It’s a popular choice for families, groups, and anyone with specific dietary needs or adventurous tastes.
The process begins with the choice of crust: traditional hand-tossed, thin and crispy, or gluten-free. Next comes the selection of sauces, including classic tomato, creamy Alfredo, spicy arrabbiata, or herb-infused pesto.
This variety ensures that every pizza can be tailored to match unique preferences.
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, provolone, feta, goat cheese, and vegan cheese.
- Proteins: Pepperoni, sausage, grilled chicken, bacon, anchovies, and tofu.
- Vegetables: Mushrooms, bell peppers, spinach, artichokes, onions, sun-dried tomatoes, jalapeños, and more.
Ben And Jay’s encourages experimentation by offering a wide array of premium toppings. Signature finishing touches, such as garlic oil, balsamic glaze, or chili flakes, can be added to elevate the final product.
The staff is always happy to accommodate special requests or dietary modifications, making the experience inclusive for everyone.
| Crust Options | Specialty Sauces | Available Sizes |
| Hand-Tossed, Thin, Gluten-Free | Tomato, Alfredo, Arrabbiata, Pesto | Small, Medium, Large |
The build-your-own pizza feature has become a hallmark of Ben And Jay’s, offering endless possibilities for creative expression. It’s not just a meal—it’s an experience that brings people together to share their culinary creations and discover new favorites.
Delectable Appetizers and Sides
Before diving into a pizza masterpiece, many guests choose to start their meal with an appetizer or side. Ben And Jay’s offers a tempting selection of starters designed to complement their main dishes and set the stage for a satisfying experience.
Each option balances flavor, texture, and visual appeal, providing something for every appetite.
Among the most popular appetizers are the garlic knots, freshly baked and brushed with a savory blend of herbs and butter. These bite-sized treats are perfect for sharing and pair beautifully with the house-made marinara sauce.
The menu also features crispy mozzarella sticks, lightly battered and served with a tangy dip, as well as loaded fries topped with cheese, bacon, and scallions.
Fresh Salads and Lighter Choices
For those seeking a lighter start, Ben And Jay’s selection of salads offers crisp, refreshing options. Favorites include the Caesar salad with shaved parmesan and crunchy croutons, the Mediterranean salad bursting with feta, olives, and cucumbers, and the seasonal Caprese, featuring ripe tomatoes and basil.
- Garlic Knots: Soft, warm, and packed with flavor.
- Mozzarella Sticks: Gooey cheese with a crispy golden shell.
- Loaded Fries: Generously topped and ideal for sharing.
- Caesar Salad: Classic flavor with a house-made dressing.
The attention to freshness is evident in every appetizer and side. Local ingredients are prioritized, and each dish is prepared to order, ensuring maximum flavor and satisfaction.
These starters not only whet the appetite but also set the tone for the meal to come.
“Ben And Jay’s garlic knots are legendary—no meal is complete without them!” — Regular customer
Pasta Dishes and Italian Classics
While pizza is the star of the show, Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria also excels in pasta and Italian comfort food. The menu boasts a range of traditional dishes, each made with authentic recipes and premium ingredients.
These hearty options are perfect for those seeking a change of pace or a taste of classic Italian fare.
From creamy Alfredo to robust Bolognese, each sauce is crafted in-house, simmered slowly to develop deep, layered flavors. Pasta is cooked to a perfect al dente, ensuring a satisfying bite every time.
The kitchen team takes pride in both the execution and presentation of these beloved dishes.
| Pasta Dish | Main Ingredients | Served With |
| Spaghetti Bolognese | Slow-cooked meat sauce, parmesan | Garlic bread |
| Chicken Alfredo | Grilled chicken, Alfredo sauce, fettuccine | Caesar salad |
| Vegetable Primavera | Seasonal vegetables, olive oil, penne | Side salad |
Vegetarian and Vegan Options
Ben And Jay’s offers several vegetarian and vegan pasta dishes to accommodate a variety of dietary needs. The Vegetable Primavera is a standout, featuring sautéed seasonal vegetables tossed in olive oil and herbs.
Vegan cheese and gluten-free pasta are available upon request, ensuring everyone can enjoy these comforting classics.
- Spaghetti Bolognese: Hearty and rich, simmered with care.
- Chicken Alfredo: Creamy, satisfying, and full of flavor.
- Vegetable Primavera: Light, fresh, and packed with nutrients.
The Italian classics at Ben And Jay’s round out the menu, providing something for everyone. Whether you’re craving the nostalgia of a family recipe or eager to try a new twist, these dishes are sure to satisfy.
Specialty and Seasonal Creations
One of the most exciting aspects of Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria is its commitment to innovation. Throughout the year, the menu features specialty and seasonal creations that reflect the chefs’ creativity and the bounty of local ingredients.
These limited-time offerings keep the dining experience fresh and encourage repeat visits.
The specialty pizzas are where the kitchen team truly showcases their inventive spirit. Recent highlights have included the Truffle Mushroom pizza, topped with wild mushrooms, truffle oil, and fontina cheese, as well as the Southwest Fiesta, featuring spicy chorizo, roasted corn, and chipotle crema.
Each seasonal pie is thoughtfully paired with recommended sides and beverages.
How Seasonal Menus Are Created
The process of developing new menu items begins with an exploration of seasonal produce and regional flavors. The chefs experiment with combinations that highlight the best of what’s available, drawing inspiration from both Italian tradition and international cuisines.
Feedback from guests plays a crucial role in determining which creations become future favorites.
- Truffle Mushroom Pizza: Earthy, aromatic, and sophisticated.
- Southwest Fiesta: Bold, spicy, and visually stunning.
- Spring Veggie Pizza: Light, vibrant, and perfect for warmer weather.
These specialty and seasonal offerings allow Ben And Jay’s to remain at the forefront of culinary trends while staying true to their roots. Guests are encouraged to ask about the latest creations or suggest new ideas, fostering a collaborative spirit that defines the restaurant’s approach.
“Our seasonal pizzas are inspired by what’s fresh and in demand. We love surprising our guests with something new every visit.” — Chef Jay
Desserts and Sweet Endings
No meal at Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria is complete without sampling one of their decadent desserts. The dessert menu features a carefully curated selection of sweet treats designed to provide the perfect finish to your dining experience.
Whether you prefer something rich and chocolatey or light and fruity, there’s a dessert to satisfy every craving.
The house-made tiramisu is a perennial favorite, boasting layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers, creamy mascarpone, and a dusting of cocoa powder. For those seeking a classic Italian indulgence, the cannoli offer a crisp shell filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips.
Chocolate lava cake, served warm with a scoop of vanilla gelato, is another standout.
- Tiramisu: Creamy, balanced, and elegantly presented.
- Cannoli: Crunchy, sweet, and delightfully rich.
- Chocolate Lava Cake: Decadent and gooey with a molten center.
- Seasonal Fruit Sorbet: Refreshing and dairy-free.
The dessert menu is updated seasonally to reflect the best fruits and flavors of the moment. Vegan and gluten-free options are available, ensuring no guest is left out of the sweet celebration.
Each dessert is crafted with the same attention to detail as the savory dishes, resulting in a memorable conclusion to the meal.
“The tiramisu at Ben And Jay’s is the best I’ve had outside of Italy. It’s the perfect ending to any pizza night.” — Satisfied customer
Beverages and Pairings
A well-chosen beverage can elevate the flavors of any meal, and Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria offers a carefully selected list of drinks to complement their menu. From classic sodas and craft beers to Italian wines and house-made lemonades, there is something for every preference and occasion.
The beverage menu features local and imported options, emphasizing quality and variety. Craft beer enthusiasts will appreciate the rotating selection of regional brews, while wine lovers can choose from reds, whites, and sparkling options that pair beautifully with pizza and pasta.
| Beverage | Best Menu Pairing | Notes |
| Craft IPA | Pepperoni Deluxe Pizza | Enhances spicy and savory notes |
| Pinot Grigio | Margherita Pizza, Caesar Salad | Crisp and refreshing |
| House Lemonade | Loaded Fries, Veggie Pizza | Balances richness with citrus |
Non-Alcoholic Choices
For guests who prefer non-alcoholic options, Ben And Jay’s offers a variety of sodas, teas, and specialty mocktails. The house-made lemonade, available in classic and seasonal flavors, is a refreshing choice, especially during the warmer months.
Kids and adults alike enjoy the Italian sodas, which can be customized with flavored syrups.
- Craft beers: Rotating selection from local breweries
- Italian wines: Red, white, and sparkling
- Artisan sodas: Classic and flavored varieties
- House-made lemonade: Freshly squeezed and naturally sweetened
The knowledgeable staff is always happy to recommend pairings, ensuring every meal is enhanced by the perfect drink. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a casual dinner, the beverage menu adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the Ben And Jay’s experience.
Family Meals, Specials, and Takeout
Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria understands the importance of convenience and value, especially for families and groups. The menu features a range of family meals and specials designed to provide generous portions at an affordable price.
These options are ideal for gatherings, celebrations, or simply enjoying a delicious meal at home.
Family meal deals typically include a combination of pizzas, salads, sides, and drinks, tailored to serve groups of various sizes. Specials rotate regularly and may highlight seasonal ingredients, newly launched pizzas, or limited-time discounts.
The pizzeria also offers a loyalty program, rewarding repeat customers with exclusive offers and savings.
Takeout and Delivery
Recognizing the demand for flexible dining options, Ben And Jay’s has streamlined its takeout and delivery services. Orders can be placed online, by phone, or in person, with a focus on speed and accuracy.
Packaging is designed to maintain freshness and quality, ensuring your meal arrives in perfect condition.
- Family Meal Deals: Pizza, salad, and sides bundled for value
- Weekly Specials: Rotating discounts and featured menu items
- Loyalty Rewards: Points earned with every purchase
- Online Ordering: Convenient and user-friendly
The combination of dine-in, takeout, and delivery options ensures that everyone in Lawton can enjoy Ben And Jay’s exceptional food, no matter the occasion. The pizzeria’s commitment to customer service and community shines through in every meal they serve.
“We love how easy it is to order for the whole family. Ben And Jay’s makes pizza night stress-free and delicious.” — Local family
Conclusion: The Spirit of Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria
Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria has earned its reputation as a cornerstone of Lawton’s dining scene, thanks to its unwavering dedication to quality, community, and innovation. The menu is a reflection of the passion that drives every member of the team—from the hands that knead the dough to the chefs who dream up new creations.
Each dish is an invitation to savor the flavors of tradition while embracing the excitement of culinary discovery.
What truly sets Ben And Jay’s apart is its ability to bring people together. The welcoming atmosphere, attentive service, and thoughtful menu design ensure that every guest feels at home.
Whether you’re gathering for a family celebration, catching up with friends, or simply treating yourself to a night off from cooking, Ben And Jay’s offers an experience that goes beyond the food itself.
Their commitment to accommodating diverse tastes and dietary needs means that everyone can find something to love on the menu.
As Lawton continues to grow, Ben And Jay’s remains a steadfast favorite—a place where memories are made, traditions are honored, and new favorites are discovered. The next time you find yourself craving a slice of something extraordinary, look no further than Ben And Jay’s Pizzeria.
With every bite, you’ll taste the difference that comes from genuine care, creativity, and community spirit.
