Pagliai’s Pizza in Kirksville has long been a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. Known for its inviting atmosphere and commitment to quality, the restaurant offers a diverse and thoughtfully curated menu that caters to all tastes.
Whether you crave the classic flavors of a thin-crust pepperoni or wish to explore unique combinations of fresh ingredients, Pagliai’s Pizza delivers with consistency and flair. The menu reflects a dedication to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients wherever possible, ensuring each bite bursts with authentic taste and texture.
Beyond just pizza, Pagliai’s offers an array of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and desserts, making it an ideal spot for group dining or a casual meal. The menu balances tradition with creativity, featuring time-honored recipes alongside innovative offerings that appeal to modern palates.
Whether you’re a longtime Kirksville resident or a visitor passing through, the variety and quality of Pagliai’s Pizza menu provide an inviting snapshot of Midwestern culinary charm.
The following sections dive deep into the various components of the Pagliai’s Pizza Kirksville menu, highlighting standout dishes, unique features, and tips for making the most of your dining experience at this local favorite.
Signature Pizzas
Pagliai’s Pizza specializes in a range of signature pizzas that have become staples for regular patrons. These pies showcase a perfect harmony between crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings, crafted to satisfy every craving.
Each pizza is made fresh to order with attention to detail, ensuring delightful textures and rich flavors.
The crust is a defining feature of Pagliai’s pizzas, offering a balance between crispness and chewiness. Traditional red sauce is made from a secret blend of ripe tomatoes and herbs, while the cheese is a premium blend designed to melt evenly without overpowering the toppings.
Some of the most popular signature options include the Classic Pepperoni, Veggie Deluxe, and the Meat Lover’s Special, each tailored to highlight specific tastes and ingredient combinations.
Popular Signature Pizzas
- Classic Pepperoni: A timeless favorite loaded with generous slices of spicy pepperoni atop rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella.
- Veggie Deluxe: A colorful medley of fresh bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives, and ripe tomatoes for a vibrant, hearty experience.
- Meat Lover’s Special: Combines pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, and ham for an indulgent and savory pizza that satisfies carnivores.
“Pagliai’s signature pizzas capture the essence of classic Italian-American flavor, making them a must-try for any pizza aficionado.”
Build-Your-Own Pizza
For those who prefer a more personalized approach, Pagliai’s Pizza offers a build-your-own pizza option. This allows customers to choose their preferred crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings, creating a customized pie tailored exactly to their tastes.
The flexibility of this option ensures that dietary restrictions, ingredient preferences, and flavor combinations are fully accommodated. Whether you desire a gluten-free crust or extra cheese, the build-your-own menu is designed to provide an enjoyable and inclusive dining experience.
Customers can select from a variety of toppings that range from traditional meats and vegetables to premium items like sun-dried tomatoes and artichoke hearts.
Customization Options
- Crust Choices: Classic hand-tossed, thin crust, and gluten-free options available.
- Sauces: Traditional red, garlic parmesan, barbecue, or white sauce to complement your toppings.
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, and vegan cheese for diverse textures and flavors.
- Toppings: Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, jalapeños, pineapple, and more.
| Crust Type | Texture | Calories (per slice) |
| Classic Hand-Tossed | Soft with a slight chew | 280 |
| Thin Crust | Crispy and light | 220 |
| Gluten-Free | Firm and slightly crumbly | 240 |
Appetizers and Starters
Pagliai’s Pizza Kirksville menu extends beyond pizza, featuring a variety of appetizers that perfectly complement your main course. These starters are crafted to offer bold flavors and shareable portions, ideal for groups or for kicking off a meal with diverse tastes.
From classic garlic breadsticks to unique offerings like stuffed jalapeños, the appetizer selection is designed to appeal to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters. Each item is prepared with fresh ingredients and seasoned to enhance the overall dining experience.
These starters serve as a great way to sample the kitchen’s creativity while providing satisfying bites that can be paired with a variety of beverages.
Recommended Appetizers
- Garlic Breadsticks: Warm, soft breadsticks brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese.
- Stuffed Jalapeños: Jalapeño peppers filled with a creamy cheese blend and wrapped in crispy bacon.
- Cheese Curds: Golden-fried cheese bites served with a tangy marinara dipping sauce.
- Spinach Artichoke Dip: Creamy blend of spinach, artichokes, and cheeses served with toasted pita chips.
“The appetizers at Pagliai’s provide a flavorful introduction to the meal, setting the tone for a satisfying dining experience.”
Salads and Healthy Options
For guests seeking lighter fare or a balance to the indulgent pizza offerings, Pagliai’s provides a selection of fresh salads and healthier menu items. These choices emphasize crisp vegetables, wholesome ingredients, and vibrant dressings.
The salads are crafted to be both filling and refreshing, making them an excellent choice for lunch or a lighter dinner. Each salad can also be customized with grilled chicken or other add-ons for extra protein.
Healthy eating without sacrificing taste is a core philosophy behind these menu items, reflecting the restaurant’s commitment to accommodating varied dietary preferences.
Popular Salad Selections
- Caesar Salad: Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, croutons, and parmesan cheese.
- Garden Salad: A mix of fresh greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, and shredded carrots with your choice of dressing.
- Greek Salad: Romaine, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, cucumbers, and red onions drizzled with a lemon-oregano vinaigrette.
| Salad | Calories | Protein (g) | Vegan Friendly |
| Caesar Salad | 320 | 10 | No |
| Garden Salad | 150 | 4 | Yes |
| Greek Salad | 280 | 8 | Yes (without feta) |
Sandwiches and Subs
Pagliai’s also features a selection of sandwiches and subs, perfect for those who want a handheld meal with bold flavors. These offerings highlight quality meats, fresh breads, and flavorful condiments that complement the restaurant’s pizza-centric menu.
Each sandwich is carefully assembled to balance textures and tastes, whether you prefer something classic like an Italian sub or a more indulgent option like the meatball sandwich. Served with a side of chips or salad, the sandwiches provide a satisfying alternative to pizza.
For those looking for a quick bite or a casual meal, the sandwich menu offers variety without compromising on quality.
Featured Sandwiches
- Italian Sub: Layers of ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing on a hoagie roll.
- Meatball Sandwich: Juicy meatballs smothered in marinara sauce and topped with melted mozzarella on toasted Italian bread.
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich: Marinated grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, and mayo served on a toasted bun.
“Pagliai’s sandwiches are crafted with the same care and passion as their pizzas, offering a delicious dining alternative.”
Desserts and Sweet Treats
No meal at Pagliai’s Pizza is complete without indulging in their selection of desserts. These sweet treats offer the perfect finish to any dining experience, featuring classic favorites and unique creations alike.
The dessert menu includes options that cater to a variety of tastes, from rich chocolate-based items to lighter fruit-inspired dishes. Each dessert is made fresh, providing a satisfying conclusion to your meal.
Whether you are celebrating a special occasion or simply craving something sweet, the desserts at Pagliai’s are designed to delight.
Popular Desserts
- Cinnamon Breadsticks: Warm, soft breadsticks coated in cinnamon sugar and served with a cream cheese dipping sauce.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet: A warm, gooey chocolate chip cookie baked in a skillet and topped with vanilla ice cream.
- Tiramisu: Classic Italian dessert with layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cream, and cocoa powder.
| Dessert | Portion Size | Calories |
| Cinnamon Breadsticks | 4 sticks | 350 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet | 1 skillet | 650 |
| Tiramisu | 1 slice | 420 |
Beverages and Drink Options
Complementing the rich and flavorful food menu, Pagliai’s Pizza offers a variety of beverages, including soft drinks, specialty coffees, and alcoholic options. These drinks are curated to enhance the dining experience and pair well with different menu items.
Whether you prefer a classic soda, a freshly brewed cup of coffee, or a cold beer, the drink menu provides options that cater to diverse tastes. Seasonal and local craft beers are also a highlight, adding a regional touch to the beverage selection.
The staff can also recommend pairings based on your food choices, ensuring a harmonious balance between flavors.
Drink Selection Highlights
- Soft Drinks: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, root beer, and more served chilled.
- Coffee and Tea: Freshly brewed hot coffee, iced coffee, and a variety of teas.
- Beers and Wines: Selection of local craft beers, domestic favorites, and a curated wine list.
“Pagliai’s beverage menu is thoughtfully designed to complement every dish, elevating the overall dining experience.”
Conclusion
Pagliai’s Pizza Kirksville menu stands out not only for its variety but also for the quality and care put into every dish. From the handcrafted signature pizzas to the customizable build-your-own options, the menu caters to a wide range of tastes and dietary preferences.
The inclusion of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, desserts, and beverages further enriches the dining experience, making it a versatile choice for any occasion.
The commitment to fresh ingredients, balanced flavors, and thoughtful preparation shines through every item, establishing Pagliai’s as a cornerstone of Kirksville’s culinary scene. Whether you are visiting for a casual meal or celebrating a special moment, the menu offers something memorable and satisfying.
Exploring Pagliai’s Pizza is more than just ordering food; it’s about enjoying a crafted experience that blends tradition with innovation. The diverse menu ensures that every guest leaves with a full stomach and a contented palate, eager to return for more.
