Nestled in the heart of Paducah, Over Under Paducah has quickly become a culinary hotspot known for its innovative approach to Southern-inspired dishes and a welcoming atmosphere that invites diners to savor every bite.
The restaurant offers a menu that perfectly balances tradition and modernity, showcasing fresh, locally sourced ingredients with an eye for flavor and presentation. Whether you’re a longtime resident or just passing through, the Over Under Paducah menu promises a memorable dining experience filled with bold flavors, creative combinations, and comforting classics that resonate with a wide variety of palates.
Each dish on the menu tells a story, reflecting the rich cultural heritage of the region while embracing contemporary culinary trends. From small plates perfect for sharing to hearty entrées, the menu is thoughtfully curated to accommodate different tastes and dietary preferences.
The attention to detail extends beyond the food, as the beverage selection complements the dishes superbly, enhancing the overall dining journey. Over Under Paducah’s commitment to quality and authenticity shines through every item, creating an inviting space where guests feel right at home and excited to explore new flavors.
Appetizers and Small Plates
The appetizer section of the Over Under Paducah menu sets the tone for a flavorful meal, offering a variety of small plates designed to stimulate the palate. These selections are perfect for sharing or enjoying as a light starter before diving into the main courses.
The appetizers blend classic Southern influences with inventive twists, making them a must-try for anyone looking to experience the essence of the restaurant’s culinary philosophy.
Popular choices include dishes crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, showcasing the best of Paducah’s produce and meats. The appetizers often feature bold spices balanced by subtle flavors, creating an enticing contrast that excites the taste buds.
Whether you prefer something crispy, creamy, or tangy, the small plates deliver a spectrum of textures and tastes that complement the main menu beautifully.
Signature Starters
- Fried Green Tomatoes – Lightly breaded and fried until golden, served with a zesty remoulade sauce that adds a perfect kick.
- Smoked Wings – Slow-smoked and finished with a house-made hot honey glaze that balances heat and sweetness.
- Charcuterie Board – A curated selection of cured meats, artisan cheeses, and pickled vegetables ideal for sharing.
“Our appetizers are crafted to ignite conversation and awaken the senses, making every meal a communal celebration.” – Executive Chef
Each appetizer is thoughtfully prepared to complement the upcoming courses, ensuring guests start their dining experience on a high note. The focus on quality ingredients and balanced flavors demonstrates Over Under Paducah’s dedication to excellence from the very first bite.
Entrées and Main Dishes
The entrée offerings at Over Under Paducah showcase a robust variety of dishes that highlight the richness of Southern cuisine with a contemporary flair. Designed to satisfy both hearty appetites and refined tastes, the main dishes emphasize freshness, bold seasoning, and expert technique.
These plates often feature seasonal ingredients, reflecting the chef’s commitment to sustainable sourcing and local partnerships.
From succulent meats to thoughtfully prepared vegetarian options, the entrées cater to diverse dietary needs without compromising on flavor or presentation. The menu frequently changes to incorporate new inspirations and the best available ingredients, ensuring a dynamic and exciting dining experience every time.
Guests can expect generous portions paired with well-thought-out sides that elevate the overall dish.
Main Course Highlights
- Slow-Braised Beef Short Ribs – Tender ribs cooked to perfection, served with creamy mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables.
- Blackened Catfish – Freshly caught catfish seasoned with bold spices and served with a tangy remoulade and coleslaw.
- Vegetable Risotto – Arborio rice cooked slowly with seasonal vegetables, finished with Parmesan and fresh herbs.
| Dish | Main Protein | Signature Side | Flavor Profile |
| Slow-Braised Beef Short Ribs | Beef | Creamy Mashed Potatoes | Rich, savory, deeply umami |
| Blackened Catfish | Catfish | Coleslaw | Spicy, smoky, tangy |
| Vegetable Risotto | Vegetarian | Herb-Infused Seasonal Vegetables | Creamy, fresh, aromatic |
Each entrée is crafted with care, balancing bold spices and comforting textures. The interplay of flavors ensures that every dish is memorable and satisfying, reflecting Over Under Paducah’s dedication to both tradition and innovation.
Sandwiches and Burgers
The sandwich and burger menu at Over Under Paducah brings a modern spin to classic favorites, emphasizing quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations. These offerings are perfect for casual dining or a hearty lunch, providing satisfying meals that retain an element of gourmet creativity.
The sandwiches and burgers often feature house-made sauces, fresh buns, and thoughtfully selected toppings.
This section of the menu is designed for those who appreciate the comfort of familiar dishes with an elevated edge. Each item is carefully balanced to deliver maximum flavor in every bite, combining textures like crisp vegetables, juicy proteins, and soft breads.
The menu also offers options for those who prefer lighter or vegetarian-friendly sandwiches without sacrificing taste.
Popular Selections
- The Over Under Burger – A juicy beef patty topped with smoked cheddar, caramelized onions, and a tangy house aioli on a brioche bun.
- Fried Chicken Sandwich – Crispy fried chicken breast paired with pickles, spicy slaw, and honey mustard sauce.
- Portobello Mushroom Sandwich – Grilled mushroom cap with roasted red peppers, goat cheese, and arugula on ciabatta bread.
“Our sandwiches and burgers are a celebration of textures and tastes, crafted to satisfy both the adventurous and the traditional diner.” – Chef de Cuisine
From the first bite, these sandwiches offer a satisfying harmony of flavors and textures, making them a popular choice among locals and visitors alike. The use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients ensures each sandwich is not only delicious but also representative of Paducah’s vibrant food culture.
Salads and Lighter Fare
For guests seeking something lighter yet flavorful, the salad and lighter fare options provide fresh, vibrant choices that still pack a punch. These dishes are perfect for balancing a meal or enjoying as a refreshing standalone option.
The ingredients emphasize crisp vegetables, tangy dressings, and balanced seasonings that highlight the natural flavors.
Over Under Paducah takes pride in crafting salads that are satisfying and nourishing, incorporating seasonal produce and a variety of textures to keep each dish interesting. Protein add-ons are available to customize the salads, making them adaptable to different dietary needs and preferences.
These options reflect the restaurant’s commitment to health-conscious dining without sacrificing taste.
Featured Salads
- Southern Caesar Salad – Romaine lettuce tossed with a creamy, house-made Caesar dressing, topped with cornbread croutons and Parmesan.
- Harvest Salad – Mixed greens with roasted butternut squash, candied pecans, dried cranberries, and a maple vinaigrette.
- Grilled Chicken Salad – Fresh greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, and grilled chicken breast topped with a light lemon-herb dressing.
These salads offer a perfect balance between fresh ingredients and bold dressings, making them a popular choice for those who want something light yet satisfying.
| Salad | Main Ingredients | Dressing | Protein Options |
| Southern Caesar | Romaine, Cornbread Croutons, Parmesan | Creamy Caesar | Chicken, Shrimp |
| Harvest Salad | Mixed Greens, Butternut Squash, Pecans, Cranberries | Maple Vinaigrette | None (Vegetarian) |
| Grilled Chicken Salad | Mixed Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers | Lemon-Herb | Chicken |
“Our lighter fare options are designed to nourish the body and delight the palate, featuring the freshest ingredients with carefully crafted dressings.” – Nutrition Consultant
Desserts and Sweet Treats
The dessert menu at Over Under Paducah offers an irresistible conclusion to any meal, combining traditional Southern sweets with inventive twists that surprise and delight. Each dessert is meticulously crafted to provide the perfect balance of sweetness, texture, and presentation.
The selection often features seasonal ingredients and classic flavors elevated to new heights.
Guests can expect rich, decadent options alongside lighter, fruit-forward desserts, catering to a variety of preferences. The presentation is as important as the taste, with each dessert often adorned with fresh garnishes or sauces that enhance the overall experience.
These sweet treats provide a memorable finale that embodies the warmth and creativity of the restaurant.
Must-Try Desserts
- Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie – A rich pecan pie infused with bourbon and topped with a dollop of whipped cream.
- Peach Cobbler – Classic Southern cobbler made with fresh peaches and served warm with vanilla ice cream.
- Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake – Creamy cheesecake with a hint of lemon, topped with fresh blueberries and a graham cracker crust.
Each dessert is crafted to evoke comfort and indulgence, celebrating the flavors that make Southern sweets beloved across generations.
| Dessert | Main Flavor | Texture | Best Paired With |
| Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie | Chocolate, Bourbon, Nutty | Crunchy, Creamy | Espresso or Bourbon Cocktail |
| Peach Cobbler | Sweet Peach, Cinnamon | Soft, Juicy | Vanilla Ice Cream or Sweet Tea |
| Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake | Tart Lemon, Sweet Blueberry | Creamy, Smooth | Light White Wine or Lemonade |
“Dessert is not just an end, but a celebration of flavors and textures that leaves a lasting impression.” – Pastry Chef
Beverage and Cocktail Selection
Over Under Paducah boasts a thoughtfully curated beverage menu that complements the diverse food offerings. The selection includes craft cocktails, local beers, fine wines, and non-alcoholic options, ensuring there is something for every guest.
The beverage program is designed to enhance the dining experience by pairing perfectly with the dishes and offering unique flavor combinations.
The cocktail menu features creative concoctions that incorporate fresh ingredients and house-made infusions. Classic Southern favorites are reimagined with a modern twist, while the beer and wine lists highlight regional producers and popular international selections.
Non-alcoholic drinks are given equal attention, with handcrafted mocktails and fresh juices that refresh and satisfy.
Featured Drinks
- Mint Julep – A timeless Southern cocktail made with fresh mint, bourbon, and a touch of sweetness.
- Over Under Old Fashioned – A signature twist on the classic Old Fashioned, featuring house-made bitters and smoked cherry garnish.
- Local Craft Beers – Rotating selection of Paducah’s finest breweries, featuring IPAs, stouts, and lagers.
The beverage menu is carefully designed to offer choices that elevate every meal and accommodate a range of tastes and preferences.
| Beverage | Type | Flavor Notes | Pairing Suggestions |
| Mint Julep | Cocktail | Fresh, Minty, Sweet | Spicy or Fried Dishes |
| Over Under Old Fashioned | Cocktail | Smoky, Sweet, Bitter | Beef, Rich Entrées |
| Local Craft IPA | Beer | Hoppy, Citrus, Bitter | Grilled or Fried Foods |
“Our beverage selections are crafted with the same passion as our food, designed to complement and enhance every bite.” – Beverage Director
Dietary Accommodations and Customizations
Over Under Paducah recognizes the importance of accommodating a variety of dietary needs and preferences, offering flexibility and thoughtful options to ensure every guest enjoys their experience. The menu includes vegetarian, gluten-free, and allergy-conscious dishes, with staff trained to assist in customizing orders to meet individual requirements.
Guests with specific dietary restrictions are encouraged to communicate with the service team, who are knowledgeable and attentive in providing recommendations and adjustments. This commitment to inclusivity is evident throughout the menu, which offers flavorful choices without compromising on taste or quality.
Over Under Paducah strives to create a welcoming environment where everyone can dine comfortably and confidently.
Customization Options
- Gluten-Free Substitutes – Gluten-free bread for sandwiches, and alternative flours used in select dishes.
- Vegetarian and Vegan Choices – Multiple plant-based dishes and sides available, clearly marked on the menu.
- Allergen Awareness – Detailed ingredient lists and staff guidance to avoid common allergens.
Customization is a cornerstone of the dining experience here, ensuring that all guests leave satisfied and cared for.
“Our goal is to make everyone feel welcome at the table, with menu options and customizations that respect individual needs.” – General Manager
Conclusion
The Over Under Paducah menu is a testament to the restaurant’s passion for blending traditional Southern flavors with modern culinary creativity. Each section of the menu, from appetizers to desserts, is thoughtfully designed to showcase fresh, local ingredients while offering a wide range of options that appeal to diverse tastes and dietary preferences.
The attention to detail in flavor profiles, presentation, and ingredient sourcing creates an exceptional dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.
Whether indulging in the hearty entrées, savoring the innovative cocktails, or enjoying the lighter salads and desserts, guests can expect a harmonious balance of comfort and sophistication. Over Under Paducah’s dedication to quality, inclusivity, and genuine hospitality shines through every dish and drink, making it a standout destination for both locals and visitors eager to explore the rich culinary landscape of Paducah.
The menu invites diners to not only enjoy a meal but to embark on a flavorful journey that celebrates the best of Southern cuisine with a contemporary twist.
