Nestled in the heart of Lancaster, NY, Muscarella’s Pizza has become a cherished fixture for pizza enthusiasts and families alike. The aroma of freshly baked dough, tangy tomato sauce, and bubbling mozzarella wafts invitingly out the doors, greeting patrons as soon as they set foot inside.
Muscarella’s isn’t just a pizzeria—it’s a local gathering place where stories are shared, milestones are celebrated, and every bite brings a sense of comfort and nostalgia. It’s a place where tradition meets innovation, offering classic favorites while daring to explore new culinary frontiers.
What makes Muscarella’s Pizza truly special is its commitment to quality and community. Every ingredient is carefully selected, from the ripest tomatoes for their signature sauce to the premium cheeses that melt perfectly atop each pizza.
The menu is a testament to their love for Italian cuisine, with options that cater to every palate—whether you’re craving the simplicity of a margherita or the bold flavors of a meat lover’s feast. Muscarella’s isn’t just serving food; they’re serving memories, creating an experience that keeps diners coming back again and again.
It’s more than a meal—it’s a slice of Lancaster’s vibrant spirit, served hot and fresh every day.
The Heart of the Menu: Signature Pizzas
Muscarella’s Pizza has built its reputation on a foundation of signature pizzas that honor tradition while delighting with inventive twists. Each pizza begins with hand-stretched dough, a process that ensures the perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness in every bite.
The sauce, crafted from ripe tomatoes and a secret blend of herbs, forms a rich base that complements the high-quality cheeses and toppings.
The variety of options on the menu speaks to the pizzeria’s dedication to satisfying all kinds of cravings. Whether diners prefer the simplicity of a classic cheese pizza or the complexity of specialty pies loaded with gourmet toppings, there’s something for everyone.
The signature pizzas are more than just meals—they’re expressions of Muscarella’s enduring love for Italian flavors and local tastes.
For those seeking bold flavors, the Meat Lovers and Buffalo Chicken pizzas are perennial favorites. Meanwhile, vegetarians and purists gravitate towards the Margherita and Veggie Supreme.
Each pizza is available in multiple sizes, making it easy to share with friends or savor solo.
- Traditional Cheese Pizza: A timeless classic with mozzarella, tangy sauce, and a golden crust.
- Margherita: Fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and creamy mozzarella.
- Meat Lovers: Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham piled high.
- Veggie Supreme: Mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, and more.
- Buffalo Chicken: Spicy buffalo sauce, tender chicken, and blue cheese crumbles.
“Every pizza at Muscarella’s is a labor of love. We craft each pie as if we’re making it for our own family.”—Owner, Muscarella’s Pizza
The attention to detail is evident in every slice. With a focus on freshness and flavor, Muscarella’s signature pizzas remain Lancaster’s go-to choice for those who crave authentic, satisfying Italian fare.
Beyond Pizza: Appetizers and Sides
While the pizzas are the star of the show, Muscarella’s offers a robust selection of appetizers and sides designed to enhance every meal. These options are perfect for sharing, snacking, or building a multi-course Italian feast.
The menu ranges from traditional starters to creative bites that surprise and delight.
Garlic knots, one of Muscarella’s most beloved appetizers, feature hand-rolled dough brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with herbs. These warm, pillowy bites are a favorite way to start any meal, often paired with a side of marinara for dipping.
Mozzarella sticks, crispy on the outside and gooey inside, are another crowd-pleaser.
For those seeking something heartier, Muscarella’s wings and meatballs offer robust flavors. The wings come in a variety of sauces, from classic buffalo to sweet BBQ, ensuring there’s a flavor for every palate.
The meatballs, simmered in rich tomato sauce, showcase the kitchen’s commitment to homemade comfort food.
- Garlic Knots: Warm, buttery, and fragrant with herbs.
- Seasoned French Fries: Crispy and golden, perfect as a side.
- Buffalo Wings: Available in multiple sauces, from mild to extra hot.
- Homemade Meatballs: Tender and flavorful, served in marinara.
“Our appetizers are more than just sides—they’re a way to bring people together around the table.”
These starters set the stage for the meal to come, inviting diners to relax and savor every moment. With such a diverse selection, it’s easy to create a personalized dining experience at Muscarella’s.
Customization: Build Your Own Pizza
Recognizing that every pizza lover has unique tastes, Muscarella’s offers a build-your-own pizza option that puts diners in control. This section of the menu is all about creativity, allowing guests to choose their crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings for a truly personalized meal.
The process begins with a choice of crust, ranging from traditional hand-tossed to thin and crispy. Guests then select their preferred sauce—classic tomato, garlic white, or tangy BBQ.
A generous layer of mozzarella cheese forms the foundation, but adventurous diners can opt for blends like cheddar or provolone.
Topping options are extensive, offering both classic and gourmet choices. From pepperoni and sausage to artichoke hearts and sun-dried tomatoes, every combination is possible.
This flexibility ensures that vegetarians, meat lovers, and everyone in between can craft their ideal pizza.
| Crust | Hand-Tossed, Thin Crust, Gluten-Free |
| Sauces | Tomato, Garlic White, BBQ |
| Cheeses | Mozzarella, Cheddar, Provolone |
| Toppings | Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Spinach, Olives, Artichoke, Sun-Dried Tomatoes |
Muscarella’s build-your-own option is perfect for families and groups, as everyone can design a pizza that suits their preferences. The staff is always happy to offer recommendations or suggest flavor combinations that have become local favorites.
With so many choices, every visit to Muscarella’s can be a new culinary adventure.
The build-your-own pizza embraces Lancaster’s diverse tastes and ensures that no two pizzas are ever alike.
Pasta Dishes: Italian Classics Reimagined
Muscarella’s culinary expertise doesn’t stop at pizza. The pasta menu is a celebration of classic Italian recipes, reimagined with fresh, local ingredients and the kitchen’s signature flair.
Each dish is prepared to order, ensuring vibrant, robust flavors in every bite.
The pasta selection ranges from comforting favorites like spaghetti and meatballs to rich, layered lasagna. Each plate is generously portioned, making it easy to satisfy even the heartiest appetites.
The sauces, simmered slowly to coax out deep flavors, are a testament to Muscarella’s dedication to traditional cooking methods.
For those craving something lighter, the menu offers primavera and Alfredo dishes, featuring crisp vegetables and creamy sauces. Gluten-free pasta options are available, ensuring everyone can enjoy these Italian classics.
- Spaghetti & Meatballs: Hand-rolled meatballs atop al dente spaghetti, bathed in homemade sauce.
- Lasagna: Layers of pasta, ricotta, mozzarella, and savory meat sauce.
- Fettuccine Alfredo: Rich, creamy sauce with a hint of garlic, served over tender fettuccine.
- Pasta Primavera: Fresh vegetables tossed in olive oil and garlic.
“Our pasta dishes bring the warmth of an Italian kitchen to every table. We don’t just serve food—we create memories.”
The pasta menu is designed to complement the pizzas, offering something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for comfort or adventure, Muscarella’s pasta dishes deliver satisfaction with every forkful.
Subs, Sandwiches, and Calzones: Satisfying Every Craving
Muscarella’s menu extends beyond pizza and pasta, offering a range of hearty subs, sandwiches, and calzones to satisfy any craving. These items are crafted with the same attention to quality and flavor that defines the rest of the menu, making them popular choices for lunch or dinner.
The sub selection features both classic Italian and American favorites. Each sub is made to order with fresh-baked rolls, crisp vegetables, and premium meats and cheeses.
Options like the Italian Combo, Chicken Parmesan, and Steak & Cheese ensure there’s a sandwich for every palate.
Calzones, with their golden-brown crusts and gooey interiors, are a must-try for fans of stuffed breads. Filled with ricotta, mozzarella, and a choice of toppings, these hand-held delights are perfect for a satisfying meal on the go.
- Italian Combo Sub: Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
- Chicken Parmesan Sandwich: Breaded chicken, marinara, and melted mozzarella on a fresh roll.
- Steak & Cheese Sub: Tender steak, sautéed onions, peppers, and provolone.
- Custom Calzones: Choose your favorite pizza toppings, baked in a golden crust.
| Sub/Sandwich | Main Ingredients |
| Italian Combo | Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, Veggies |
| Chicken Parmesan | Breaded Chicken, Marinara, Mozzarella |
| Steak & Cheese | Steak, Onions, Peppers, Provolone |
| Custom Calzone | Ricotta, Mozzarella, Choice of Toppings |
Whether you’re in the mood for a hot, melty sub or the comforting embrace of a calzone, Muscarella’s has an option to please every appetite.
Salads and Lighter Fare: Freshness on the Menu
For diners seeking a lighter option, Muscarella’s offers an array of fresh salads and lighter fare. These dishes balance the heartier items on the menu, providing crisp, refreshing flavors that complement pizza, pasta, and subs alike.
The salad selection is diverse, ranging from simple garden salads to more elaborate creations like the Antipasto and Greek salads. Each salad features fresh greens, ripe vegetables, and a variety of flavorful toppings, all tossed to order.
Dressings are made in-house whenever possible, ensuring a vibrant, homemade taste. For added protein, diners can customize their salads with grilled chicken, tuna, or extra cheese.
- Garden Salad: Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and croutons.
- Antipasto Salad: Italian meats, cheese, olives, and crisp veggies on a bed of greens.
- Greek Salad: Feta, olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, and tangy dressing.
- Caesar Salad: Romaine, parmesan, croutons, and creamy Caesar dressing.
“We believe freshness matters in every dish, from our pizzas to our salads. Quality ingredients make all the difference.”
These lighter options make it easy to enjoy a balanced meal at Muscarella’s, whether as a side or a satisfying entrée.
Kid-Friendly Choices and Family Meals
Muscarella’s Pizza is a family-owned restaurant, and that spirit is reflected in a menu designed to please diners of all ages. The kid-friendly options ensure even the youngest guests find something they love, while family meal deals make it easy to feed a crowd.
The children’s menu features smaller portions of popular items, such as mini pizzas, pasta, and chicken tenders. Every dish is prepared with the same attention to quality, making parents confident in their choices.
Family meal packages, which combine pizza, sides, and drinks at a value price, are perfect for gatherings, celebrations, or just an easy night in. These bundles take the guesswork out of ordering, ensuring there’s enough variety to keep everyone happy.
- Mini Cheese Pizza: A personal-sized pizza just for kids.
- Spaghetti Bowl: Kid-sized pasta with homemade sauce.
- Chicken Tenders: Crispy and golden, served with fries.
- Family Pizza Pack: Multiple pizzas, breadsticks, and drinks for group dining.
Muscarella’s makes family dining convenient, affordable, and fun, with plenty of options for picky eaters and adventurous palates alike.
The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with a menu tailored to families, has made Muscarella’s a beloved destination for celebrations, casual dinners, and everything in between.
Desserts and Beverages: The Perfect Finish
No meal at Muscarella’s Pizza is complete without a sweet treat or a refreshing beverage. The dessert menu features Italian classics and American favorites, offering a delicious way to end any dining experience.
Cannoli, with their crispy shells and creamy ricotta filling, are a highlight, delivering an authentic taste of Italy. Cheesecake and tiramisu round out the menu, providing rich, indulgent flavors that satisfy any sweet tooth.
A variety of beverages are available, including fountain drinks, juices, and an assortment of coffees and teas. For adults, Muscarella’s offers a selection of local craft beers and Italian wines, perfect for pairing with pizza or pasta.
- Cannoli: Crisp pastry shells filled with sweet ricotta cream.
- New York Cheesecake: Creamy and decadent, topped with berry sauce.
- Tiramisu: Layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream.
- Italian Sodas and Espresso: For a traditional finish to your meal.
| Dessert | Main Ingredients |
| Cannoli | Ricotta, Sugar, Chocolate Chips, Pastry Shell |
| Cheesecake | Cream Cheese, Sugar, Graham Crust, Berries |
| Tiramisu | Ladyfingers, Espresso, Mascarpone, Cocoa |
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging after a great meal, Muscarella’s desserts and beverages provide the perfect finishing touch.
Conclusion: A Lancaster Tradition Worth Savoring
Muscarella’s Pizza Menu in Lancaster, NY, is more than just a list of dishes—it’s a reflection of the community’s love for great food and genuine hospitality. Every item, from the signature pizzas to the decadent desserts, is crafted with care and a passion for quality.
The menu is designed to bring people together, creating moments of joy and connection around the table.
What truly sets Muscarella’s apart is its unwavering commitment to fresh ingredients, classic recipes, and innovative twists that keep diners coming back. The welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and family-friendly options make every visit memorable.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Muscarella’s offers a taste of Lancaster’s rich culinary tradition—a place where every meal is an opportunity to celebrate, connect, and savor life’s simple pleasures.
As you explore the menu, you’ll find more than just food—you’ll discover a legacy of flavor, community, and heartfelt service. Muscarella’s Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a destination for anyone who cherishes good company and great taste.
Every slice, every bite, and every gathering is a reminder that the best meals are those shared with others.
