Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern is more than just a local hangout; it’s a culinary destination where tradition meets innovation in every dish. Nestled in the heart of the community, the tavern prides itself on crafting a menu that celebrates comfort food classics while infusing them with contemporary twists.
Whether you’re stopping by for a casual lunch, unwinding after work, or gathering for a special occasion, Costello’s offers a diverse selection that caters to all tastes and cravings. The welcoming ambiance combined with a thoughtfully curated menu makes it a place where every visit feels like coming home.
The menu at Costello’s is carefully designed to highlight fresh, locally sourced ingredients and bold flavors. From hearty appetizers to indulgent desserts, each section showcases the chef’s commitment to quality and creativity.
Diners will find an array of options that reflect the neighborhood’s rich culinary heritage, alongside seasonal specials that keep the offerings exciting and new. The balance between familiar favorites and adventurous dishes invites patrons to explore and savor something unique every time they visit.
Beyond the food, Costello’s focuses on delivering an experience that emphasizes community and connection. The menu reflects this ethos through dishes that are perfect for sharing, pairing, and enjoying in good company.
For food lovers and casual diners alike, Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern presents a menu that is as inviting as its atmosphere—rich in flavor, variety, and heart.
Appetizers and Starters
The appetizer section at Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern sets the tone for a memorable meal. Designed to awaken the palate and spark anticipation, these starters combine classic tavern favorites with inventive new creations.
Each dish is crafted to be shared or enjoyed individually, offering a perfect balance of flavors and textures.
One standout feature is the use of locally sourced produce and artisanal ingredients, which lend freshness and authenticity to the offerings. From crispy calamari to savory flatbreads, the appetizers cater to a wide range of preferences, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
These small plates are perfect for pairing with the tavern’s extensive drink menu, encouraging guests to relax and savor the moment.
Popular Appetizers:
- Fire-Roasted Garlic Hummus served with house-made pita chips and fresh veggies
- Spicy Buffalo Wings tossed in a tangy blue cheese sauce
- Loaded Nachos with melted cheddar, jalapeños, sour cream, and guacamole
- Bruschetta Trio featuring tomato-basil, mushroom-garlic, and roasted pepper blends
Signature Dips and Shares
Costello’s offers an array of signature dips designed to be shared among friends. The Fire-Roasted Garlic Hummus is a particular favorite, known for its smoky undertones and creamy texture.
Paired with crisp pita and fresh vegetables, it’s a healthy and satisfying way to start any meal.
“The starters at Costello’s are not just appetizers; they are an invitation to gather and connect over great food.”
The Loaded Nachos bring a playful combination of textures and bold flavors, enhanced by fresh guacamole and a touch of heat from jalapeños. These appetizers encourage a communal dining experience, perfect for groups looking to sample a variety of tastes.
Comparative Flavor Profiles
| Dish | Flavor Notes | Texture | Best Paired With |
| Fire-Roasted Garlic Hummus | Smoky, garlicky, tangy | Creamy, smooth | Light white wine, crisp beer |
| Spicy Buffalo Wings | Spicy, tangy, rich | Crispy skin, tender meat | Cold lager, blue cheese dip |
| Loaded Nachos | Cheesy, spicy, fresh | Crispy chips, creamy toppings | IPA beer, margarita |
Soups and Salads
Freshness and balance are the hallmarks of Costello’s soups and salads. This section offers light yet satisfying options that emphasize seasonal ingredients and house-made dressings.
Whether you’re seeking a warm bowl of comfort or a crisp, refreshing salad, these choices provide healthy and flavorful options without compromising on taste.
The soups rotate seasonally, ensuring that each visit brings new and exciting flavors. From hearty stews to delicate broths, these dishes are perfect for a quick lunch or a nourishing start to a larger meal.
Salads feature a variety of greens, nuts, cheeses, and fruits, expertly combined to create layers of texture and complexity.
Highlights include:
- Roasted Butternut Squash Soup with a hint of sage and a drizzle of crème fraîche
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad featuring house-made croutons and shaved parmesan
- Quinoa and Arugula Salad with dried cranberries, toasted almonds, and citrus vinaigrette
Seasonal Soup Selections
Each season brings a new soup crafted from the freshest ingredients. The Roasted Butternut Squash Soup is particularly popular in the fall and winter months, offering a velvety texture and a subtle herbaceous note from sage.
This soup pairs beautifully with the tavern’s freshly baked bread.
During warmer months, lighter options like chilled gazpacho make an appearance, providing a refreshing and vibrant choice. The commitment to seasonal variation keeps the menu dynamic and encourages guests to try new flavors throughout the year.
“At Costello’s, the soups and salads are not just side dishes; they are thoughtfully created experiences that nourish both body and soul.”
Comparing Nutritional Profiles
| Dish | Calories | Protein | Key Ingredients |
| Roasted Butternut Squash Soup | 180 | 3g | Butternut squash, sage, cream |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad | 450 | 35g | Chicken breast, romaine, parmesan |
| Quinoa and Arugula Salad | 320 | 10g | Quinoa, arugula, cranberries |
Entrées and Main Courses
The main courses at Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern exemplify hearty, satisfying dishes crafted with attention to detail and an emphasis on quality. This section features a variety of proteins and preparations, from slow-cooked comfort foods to lighter, health-conscious plates.
Each entrée is designed to deliver robust flavors and memorable dining experiences.
Whether you crave classic American fare or international influences, the menu delivers with options that cater to diverse palates. The use of fresh herbs, house-made sauces, and seasonal vegetables elevates every dish, ensuring each bite is rich in depth and character.
Featured Entrées:
- Slow-Braised Beef Short Ribs with red wine reduction and garlic mashed potatoes
- Pan-Seared Atlantic Salmon accompanied by quinoa pilaf and sautéed greens
- Herb-Roasted Chicken served with roasted root vegetables and thyme jus
- Vegetarian Mushroom Risotto finished with truffle oil and parmesan shavings
Comfort Meets Elegance
The Slow-Braised Beef Short Ribs are a signature entrée, slow-cooked to tender perfection and served with a rich red wine reduction that enhances the meat’s natural flavors. The accompanying garlic mashed potatoes offer a creamy counterbalance, making this dish a favorite among regular patrons seeking indulgence.
For those who prefer lighter fare, the Pan-Seared Atlantic Salmon provides a delicate yet flavorful option. The quinoa pilaf adds a wholesome touch, while the sautéed seasonal greens bring freshness and texture.
This dish strikes a beautiful balance between health and taste.
“Each entrée at Costello’s is a crafted story of flavors, textures, and culinary passion.”
Entrée Comparison by Prep Style
| Dish | Cooking Method | Key Ingredients | Flavor Profile |
| Slow-Braised Beef Short Ribs | Braising | Beef ribs, red wine, garlic | Rich, savory, tender |
| Pan-Seared Atlantic Salmon | Searing | Salmon, quinoa, greens | Light, fresh, slightly smoky |
| Herb-Roasted Chicken | Roasting | Chicken, root vegetables, thyme | Herbaceous, earthy, juicy |
| Vegetarian Mushroom Risotto | Simmering | Mushrooms, arborio rice, truffle oil | Creamy, earthy, aromatic |
Burgers and Sandwiches
The burger and sandwich offerings at Costello’s are crafted to satisfy cravings for bold, fulfilling flavors presented with a gourmet touch. Each sandwich is built with fresh baked bread and quality ingredients, making them perfect for a casual meal or a hearty snack.
This section of the menu reflects the tavern’s commitment to elevating traditional comfort foods.
From classic cheeseburgers to inventive specialty sandwiches, the variety ensures that every guest can find a favorite. The use of house-made sauces, artisanal buns, and thoughtfully paired toppings turns each burger and sandwich into a celebration of taste and texture.
Standout Choices:
- The Costello Classic Burger with aged cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and house sauce
- BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich served with coleslaw on a brioche bun
- Grilled Portobello Mushroom Sandwich with roasted red peppers and garlic aioli
- Turkey Club stacked with crispy bacon, avocado, and mayo
Building the Perfect Burger
At the heart of the burger menu is the Costello Classic, a perfectly grilled beef patty topped with aged cheddar and fresh garden vegetables. The house sauce adds a unique tang that complements the savory flavors, while the soft yet sturdy bun holds everything together without overwhelming the palate.
Vegetarian options like the Grilled Portobello Mushroom Sandwich offer a flavorful alternative, featuring juicy mushrooms and smoky roasted peppers balanced by a creamy garlic aioli. This option highlights the tavern’s dedication to inclusivity and quality for all dietary preferences.
“Burgers and sandwiches at Costello’s are more than meals—they’re crafted experiences that honor tradition and innovation.”
Ingredient Highlights and Pairings
| Sandwich | Key Ingredients | Recommended Side | Suggested Drink Pairing |
| Costello Classic Burger | Beef patty, cheddar, lettuce, tomato | French fries | Amber ale |
| BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich | Pulled pork, BBQ sauce, coleslaw | Sweet potato fries | Dark stout |
| Grilled Portobello Mushroom | Portobello, red peppers, garlic aioli | Side salad | Pale ale |
| Turkey Club | Turkey, bacon, avocado, mayo | Potato chips | Light lager |
Sides and Accompaniments
Sides at Costello’s are thoughtfully prepared to complement and enhance the main dishes. This section offers a variety of options that range from classic tavern staples to fresh, seasonal vegetables.
Each side is made with the same care and attention to detail as the entrees, ensuring a balanced and satisfying meal.
Whether you prefer something crispy and indulgent or light and nutritious, the choices accommodate all tastes. The sides can be ordered individually or as part of combo meals, offering flexibility for diners to customize their plates.
Popular Sides Include:
- Truffle Parmesan Fries garnished with fresh herbs
- Garlic Sautéed Green Beans with toasted almonds
- Sweet Potato Wedges served with chipotle aioli
- Seasonal Roasted Vegetables drizzled with balsamic glaze
Elevating the Classic Side
Truffle Parmesan Fries are a luxurious take on a favorite, combining crispy fries with the earthy aroma of truffle oil and the sharpness of freshly grated parmesan cheese. This side pairs perfectly with burgers or sandwiches, adding an extra layer of indulgence.
For those seeking a healthier option, Garlic Sautéed Green Beans provide a vibrant, crunchy alternative with the added texture of toasted almonds. This dish showcases how simple ingredients can be transformed with thoughtful preparation.
“Sides at Costello’s are not afterthoughts; they are essential components that complete the culinary experience.”
Side Dish Nutritional Overview
| Side | Calories | Fat | Key Nutrients |
| Truffle Parmesan Fries | 410 | 22g | Carbohydrates, protein |
| Garlic Sautéed Green Beans | 120 | 5g | Vitamin C, fiber |
| Sweet Potato Wedges | 330 | 14g | Beta-carotene, potassium |
| Seasonal Roasted Vegetables | 150 | 7g | Vitamin A, antioxidants |
Desserts and Sweet Treats
Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern rounds out the dining experience with a thoughtfully curated dessert menu that offers indulgent finishes to any meal. These sweet treats blend classic comfort desserts with elegant presentations and surprising flavor combinations.
Each dessert is made in-house, maintaining high standards of quality and freshness.
The desserts are ideal for sharing or savoring solo, providing a satisfying conclusion to the savory journey through the menu. The variety includes rich chocolate options, light fruit-based dishes, and creamy custards, catering to diverse preferences and cravings.
Dessert Favorites:
- Chocolate Lava Cake served warm with vanilla bean ice cream
- Classic New York Cheesecake with a graham cracker crust and fresh berries
- Lemon Panna Cotta topped with raspberry coulis
- Apple Crisp featuring cinnamon-spiced apples and oat topping
Decadent and Light Options
The Chocolate Lava Cake epitomizes indulgence, with a molten center that oozes rich chocolate paired beautifully with the cool creaminess of vanilla bean ice cream. This dessert is a favorite for those seeking a luscious, comforting finale.
For a lighter but equally sophisticated choice, the Lemon Panna Cotta offers a delicate balance of tartness and sweetness. The raspberry coulis adds a vibrant color and a burst of fresh flavor that complements the creamy base.
“Desserts at Costello’s are crafted to satisfy the soul as much as the palate—each bite is a moment of pure delight.”
Comparing Dessert Textures and Flavors
| Dessert | Texture | Flavor Profile | Pairing Suggestions |
| Chocolate Lava Cake | Moist, gooey center | Rich, bittersweet chocolate | Espresso, port wine |
| New York Cheesecake | Creamy, dense | Sweet, tangy berries | Chardonnay, berry tea |
| Lemon Panna Cotta | Smooth, silky | Tart, sweet citrus | Prosecco, herbal tea |
| Apple Crisp | Crunchy topping, soft apples | Warm, spiced apple | Cider, cinnamon latte |
Beverages and Cocktails
Complementing the diverse menu is Costello’s thoughtfully crafted beverage selection, which offers everything from classic cocktails to local craft beers and non-alcoholic options. The drinks menu is designed to pair seamlessly with the food, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Mixologists at Costello’s take pride in using fresh ingredients, house-made syrups, and artisan spirits to create cocktails that are both innovative and approachable. For those who prefer beer or wine, the tavern sources local breweries and wineries to showcase regional flavors and support community producers.
Featured Beverages:
- Costello Old Fashioned made with bourbon, bitters, and a hint of orange zest
- Seasonal Craft Beer Selection rotating taps featuring IPAs, stouts, and lagers
- House-Made Lemonade infused with fresh herbs and seasonal fruits
- Classic Red and White Wines carefully chosen to complement the menu
Cocktail Craftsmanship
The Costello Old Fashioned is a signature cocktail that perfectly balances the warmth of bourbon with aromatic bitters and a subtle citrus twist. This drink is a favorite among patrons looking for a refined yet familiar flavor profile.
Seasonal cocktails often incorporate fresh herbs and fruits sourced from local farms, ensuring vibrant flavors and an ever-changing menu. These creative drinks invite guests to try something new and exciting with every visit.
“Our beverage program is a reflection of Costello’s dedication to quality and community, offering drinks that enhance every moment.”
Beverage Pairing Recommendations
| Dish Type | Recommended Beverage | Flavor Match |
| Spicy Starters | Light lager, citrus cocktail | Refreshing, balances heat |
| Rich Entrées | Full-bodied red wine, bourbon cocktail | Complements bold flavors |
| Seafood Dishes | Crisp white wine, light beer | Enhances freshness |
| Desserts | Sweet wine, espresso | Balances sweetness |
Conclusion
Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern offers a menu that embodies the spirit of community, quality, and culinary creativity. Every section—from appetizers to desserts—is carefully curated to provide an experience that delights the senses and fosters connection.
The emphasis on fresh, local ingredients combined with thoughtful preparation results in dishes that are both comforting and exciting.
The diverse offerings ensure that every guest, whether a meat lover, vegetarian, or dessert enthusiast, will find something to savor and enjoy. The pairing of exceptional food with a well-crafted beverage menu further elevates the dining experience, making Costello’s a destination for memorable meals and meaningful moments.
Ultimately, Costello’s Neighborhood Tavern is not just a place to eat; it’s a place to gather, celebrate, and create lasting memories. The menu reflects this philosophy, inviting patrons to explore flavors, share plates, and enjoy the warmth of a true neighborhood tavern.
