Nestled in the heart of Burlington County, Bordentown Creamery has cultivated a reputation as a beloved local destination for ice cream enthusiasts and dessert lovers alike. As soon as you step through the doors, the tantalizing aroma of homemade waffle cones and the cheerful chatter of families and friends set the mood for a delightful experience.
The Creamery isn’t just an ice cream shop—it’s a community hub that captures the charm of small-town New Jersey while offering an extensive menu designed to delight patrons of all ages.
The Bordentown Creamery menu is a testament to creativity and tradition. From classic vanilla cones to inventive sundae creations and dairy-free options, there’s something to satisfy every craving.
Each menu item is crafted with care, using locally sourced ingredients and time-honored techniques. Whether you’re seeking a refreshing treat on a sweltering summer afternoon or a cozy dessert during a crisp autumn evening, the Creamery’s offerings promise to deliver quality, flavor, and a dash of nostalgia.
With a commitment to both innovation and timeless favorites, Bordentown Creamery has become a local staple. Exploring their menu is not just about indulging in sweet treats—it’s about creating memorable moments with family and friends, discovering new flavors, and revisiting cherished classics.
Let’s embark on a flavorful journey through the highlights of the Bordentown Creamery menu, uncovering the delicious details and hidden gems that make this destination truly special.
Signature Ice Cream Flavors
The heart and soul of Bordentown Creamery’s menu lies in its signature ice cream flavors. Each flavor is meticulously developed, balancing classic preferences with imaginative creations that keep customers returning for more.
The Creamery’s dedication to flavor innovation elevates the simple scoop into a memorable experience.
From the moment you step up to the counter, you’re greeted by a dazzling array of colors and scents. The Creamery’s ice cream base is made from high-quality dairy, ensuring a velvety texture and rich taste.
While staples like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry anchor the menu, seasonal specials and limited-edition flavors offer a reason to visit again and again.
Among the most popular choices are inventive blends such as Salted Caramel Pretzel, Blueberry Cheesecake, and Peanut Butter Brownie Swirl. These unique flavors demonstrate the Creamery’s commitment to crafting both comforting and adventurous options.
- Salted Caramel Pretzel: A perfect mix of sweet and salty with crunchy pretzel bits
- Blueberry Cheesecake: Swirls of real blueberry and chunks of creamy cheesecake
- Peanut Butter Brownie Swirl: Decadent chocolate, peanut butter ribbons, and chewy brownie pieces
Customer Favorites
“The Salted Caramel Pretzel is my go-to every visit! The balance of flavors is absolutely perfect.” — Local Resident
The Creamery’s approach to flavor development is rooted in customer feedback and a spirit of experimentation. Each month, a new flavor is introduced, often inspired by local events or seasonal ingredients, keeping the menu fresh and exciting for regulars and newcomers alike.
Creative Sundaes and Parfaits
For those seeking something more indulgent, Bordentown Creamery’s menu of creative sundaes and parfaits showcases their flair for presentation and layered flavor. Sundaes here are more than just ice cream—they’re edible works of art.
Each sundae is thoughtfully composed, blending premium ice cream with house-made sauces, fresh fruit, and a variety of toppings. The result is a dessert that’s as visually stunning as it is delicious.
Parfaits, meanwhile, offer a lighter but equally enticing option, with artful layers of ice cream, yogurt, and crunchy granola.
Highlighting some of their most popular creations, the Brownie Explosion Sundae and Strawberry Shortcake Parfait stand out for their generous portions and harmonious flavors.
- Brownie Explosion Sundae: Fudgy brownies, chocolate ice cream, whipped cream, and fudge sauce
- Strawberry Shortcake Parfait: Fresh strawberries, vanilla bean ice cream, shortcake crumbles, and strawberry syrup
- Classic Hot Fudge Sundae: Simple yet decadent, with premium hot fudge and toasted nuts
Comparing Sundae Options
| Sundae | Main Ingredients | Flavor Profile |
| Brownie Explosion | Chocolate ice cream, brownies, fudge sauce | Rich, chocolatey, indulgent |
| Strawberry Shortcake Parfait | Vanilla ice cream, strawberries, shortcake | Sweet, fruity, refreshing |
| Hot Fudge Sundae | Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, nuts | Classic, nutty, satisfying |
Whether you crave the comforting warmth of gooey brownies or the tangy brightness of fresh berries, Bordentown Creamery’s sundaes and parfaits deliver an unforgettable dessert experience.
Dairy-Free and Vegan Options
Inclusivity is a core value at Bordentown Creamery, and their commitment to offering dairy-free and vegan options ensures that everyone can enjoy a sweet treat. The menu features thoughtfully crafted alternatives that don’t compromise on flavor or texture.
Non-dairy ice creams are made using coconut, almond, or oat milk bases, providing a creamy consistency that rivals traditional dairy. Flavors such as Chocolate Almond Fudge and Mango Sorbet have become favorites among vegan and lactose-intolerant customers.
For those seeking a lighter option, fruit-based sorbets offer a refreshing, naturally sweet alternative. These treats are made from pureed fruit and cane sugar, with no artificial additives.
- Chocolate Almond Fudge: Deep chocolate flavor with crunchy almond bits
- Mango Sorbet: Bright, tropical flavor made with ripe mangoes
- Strawberry Oat Milk: Creamy, plant-based take on a classic favorite
Commitment to Dietary Needs
“As someone with a dairy allergy, I’m thrilled by the variety and quality of vegan ice creams at Bordentown Creamery.” — Happy Customer
The staff is knowledgeable about allergens and happy to assist with recommendations. For those with gluten sensitivities, many options are available upon request, including gluten-free cones and toppings.
Specialty Milkshakes and Floats
Milkshakes and floats at Bordentown Creamery are legendary, blending nostalgia with modern twists. These specialty drinks are crafted to order, using hand-scooped ice cream and premium mix-ins for a thick, satisfying treat.
Classic milkshakes like Chocolate, Vanilla, and Strawberry are crowd-pleasers, but the menu also boasts inventive combinations. The Cookie Monster Shake and Mocha Java Float have earned loyal followings for their bold flavors and playful presentations.
- Cookie Monster Shake: Blue-tinted vanilla ice cream, cookie pieces, whipped cream, and a mini cookie on top
- Mocha Java Float: Coffee ice cream, chocolate syrup, and cold brew coffee, topped with whipped cream
- Root Beer Float: Classic vanilla ice cream with bubbly root beer
Each shake and float is customizable, allowing you to choose your preferred ice cream base and add-ins. This makes it easy to tailor your drink to your exact preferences.
Comparing Milkshake Varieties
| Drink | Base Flavor | Signature Add-Ons |
| Cookie Monster Shake | Vanilla | Cookie crumbles, blue coloring, whipped cream |
| Mocha Java Float | Coffee | Chocolate syrup, cold brew, whipped cream |
| Root Beer Float | Vanilla | Root beer, whipped cream (optional) |
Bordentown Creamery’s milkshakes and floats are not only delicious but also Instagram-worthy, making them a perfect pick for anyone looking to enjoy a treat that’s as fun as it is flavorful.
Waffle Cones, Cups, and Homemade Toppings
Presentation is a key part of the experience at Bordentown Creamery, and nothing elevates a scoop of ice cream quite like a freshly baked waffle cone or a perfectly sized cup. The Creamery’s homemade cones are crispy on the outside and slightly chewy within, providing the ideal vessel for any flavor.
Patrons can choose from a variety of serving options, including classic sugar cones, gluten-free cones, and eco-friendly compostable cups. The aroma of cones baking in-house adds to the sensory delight, making it almost impossible to resist upgrading your order.
Toppings are another highlight, with a menu of homemade sauces, sprinkles, nuts, and fruit compotes. The hot fudge and caramel sauces are made from scratch, ensuring a depth of flavor that packaged toppings can’t match.
- Homemade Waffle Cones: Crisp, golden, and lightly sweet
- Gluten-Free Cones: Specially crafted for sensitive diets
- House-Made Sauces: Hot fudge, caramel, strawberry, and marshmallow
- Fresh Fruit Toppings: Seasonal berries and compotes
The Art of the Perfect Cone
“There’s nothing like a warm, freshly made waffle cone filled with your favorite flavor—the crunch, the aroma, the taste—it’s pure happiness.” — Frequent Visitor
Attention to detail is evident in every element, from the careful rolling of cones to the generous drizzle of sauces. This dedication ensures that each order is a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds.
Seasonal Specials and Limited-Edition Treats
Bordentown Creamery thrives on creativity, and their seasonal specials and limited-edition treats are a testament to their innovative spirit. These offerings celebrate holidays, local harvests, and unique flavor trends, inviting patrons to try something new with every visit.
Autumn brings flavors like Pumpkin Pie and Maple Walnut, while summer highlights include Peach Cobbler and Watermelon Sorbet. Winter introduces decadent options such as Peppermint Bark and Gingerbread Cookie.
Each season offers its own set of exclusive sundaes, parfaits, and shakes.
- Pumpkin Pie Sundae: Pumpkin ice cream, graham cracker crumbles, and whipped cream
- Peach Cobbler Milkshake: Creamy vanilla ice cream with real peach compote and cinnamon
- Peppermint Bark Parfait: Chocolate ice cream, peppermint pieces, and marshmallow sauce
These special items are available for a limited time, creating a sense of excitement and urgency. For many loyal customers, the arrival of a favorite seasonal flavor has become a cherished tradition.
Table: Seasonal Offerings Overview
| Season | Featured Flavor | Signature Treat |
| Fall | Pumpkin Pie | Pumpkin Pie Sundae |
| Summer | Peach Cobbler | Peach Cobbler Milkshake |
| Winter | Peppermint Bark | Peppermint Bark Parfait |
The anticipation of new flavors and limited runs adds a dynamic element to the menu, ensuring that every visit to Bordentown Creamery promises something fresh and delightful.
Local Partnerships and Community Engagement
Bordentown Creamery’s menu is more than just a collection of desserts—it’s a reflection of their deep roots in the community. The Creamery partners with local farms and producers to source ingredients, ensuring that every bite supports the local economy and showcases the region’s agricultural bounty.
Fresh milk and cream are delivered from nearby dairies, while fruits and nuts are selected from trusted local growers. This commitment to local sourcing not only enhances the quality of the ice cream but also strengthens community bonds.
- Local Dairy: Fresh milk and cream for a superior base
- Seasonal Produce: Strawberries, blueberries, and peaches from regional farms
- Community Events: Ice cream socials, fundraisers, and school partnerships
Community Voices
“Bordentown Creamery is a cornerstone of our town. Their support for local farmers and schools makes every visit meaningful.” — Community Leader
The Creamery frequently hosts events that bring neighbors together, from summer celebrations to charity fundraisers. These gatherings underscore the shop’s role as a welcoming space where memories are made and shared.
Tips for Creating Your Perfect Order
Navigating the Bordentown Creamery menu can be both exhilarating and overwhelming, especially with so many tempting choices. To make the most of your visit, a few insider tips can help you craft the perfect ice cream experience.
Start by sampling flavors before making your final decision—staff are always happy to offer a taste. Mix and match scoops to discover new flavor combinations, or ask for recommendations based on your favorite profiles.
- Sample First: Don’t hesitate to try before you buy
- Mix Flavors: Combine two or more flavors for a unique creation
- Upgrade Your Cone: Opt for a homemade waffle cone for added crunch
- Customize Toppings: Layer sauces, fruits, and nuts for extra indulgence
Creating Memorable Moments
“The staff always remembers my favorite combination—it feels like a personalized experience every time.” — Regular Customer
For families, sharing a large sundae or ordering a flight of mini-scoops can turn dessert into an interactive event. Don’t forget to check the specials board for new arrivals and seasonal favorites.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a long-time fan, taking a few moments to explore the menu and personalize your order can transform an ordinary outing into a cherished memory.
Conclusion: Why Bordentown Creamery Stands Out
Bordentown Creamery has mastered the art of the ice cream experience, blending tradition, innovation, and a deep sense of community. Their menu is a vibrant tapestry of flavors, textures, and inspirations, ensuring there’s something for everyone—regardless of age, dietary need, or personal taste.
What sets the Creamery apart is not just the quality of their desserts, but the thoughtfulness behind every element. From locally sourced ingredients and house-made toppings to seasonal specialties and vegan options, the menu reflects a commitment to excellence and inclusivity.
Each visit feels like a celebration, whether you’re sampling a new flavor, indulging in a decadent sundae, or sharing laughs over a flight of floats.
The welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and dedication to supporting local partners make Bordentown Creamery a cherished cornerstone of the community. It’s a place where nostalgia meets novelty, and where every scoop serves as an invitation to slow down and savor the simple joys of life.
For anyone seeking a sweet escape and a taste of local flavor, Bordentown Creamery remains an essential destination—one delightful scoop at a time.
