Yoder’s Bakery has long been a beloved destination for those seeking traditional Amish baked goods infused with rich flavors and wholesome ingredients. Located in the heart of Amish country, Yoder’s Bakery prides itself on crafting desserts and breads that evoke nostalgia and comfort, blending time-honored recipes with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
This comprehensive menu guide introduces you to their wide variety of baked goods, from mouth-watering pies to hearty breads and delicious pastries. Whether you’re visiting in person or planning a special order, this detailed overview will help you discover the best that Yoder’s Bakery has to offer.
Signature Pies
Pies are the cornerstone of Yoder’s Bakery, where every crust is flaky and buttery, and fillings are rich and flavorful. Their pies are made fresh daily, with seasonal ingredients ensuring peak taste and quality.
Below is a summary of their most popular pie selections:
| Pie Name | Description | Available Sizes | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple Crumb Pie | Classic apple pie with a cinnamon-spiced crumb topping and tender, juicy apple slices. | 8-inch, 10-inch | $14.99 – $18.99 |
| Cherry Pie | Sweet and tart Michigan cherries baked in a double crust with a glossy finish. | 8-inch, 10-inch | $16.99 – $20.99 |
| Peach Pie | Juicy sliced peaches with a hint of vanilla and nutmeg, encased in a golden crust. | 8-inch only | $15.99 |
| Pecan Pie | Rich and gooey pecan filling with a perfect balance of sweetness and crunch. | 8-inch, 10-inch | $17.99 – $21.99 |
| Blueberry Pie | Hand-picked blueberries with a subtle lemon zest and flaky crust. | 8-inch only | $16.49 |
“Yoder’s pies are the epitome of homemade goodness — every bite takes you back to simpler times and family gatherings.” – Local Food Critic
Breads and Rolls
Yoder’s Bakery offers an impressive assortment of breads and rolls, made with natural starters and baked to a perfect crust. Their breads are ideal for breakfast, sandwiches, or complementing any meal.
Each loaf brims with hearty textures and authentic flavor.
| Bread Type | Description | Size/Weight | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amish White Bread | Soft, fluffy white bread with a golden crust, perfect for toast and sandwiches. | 1 lb loaf | $4.99 |
| Whole Wheat Bread | Wholesome wheat bread with a nutty flavor and dense texture. | 1 lb loaf | $5.49 |
| Rye Bread | Traditional rye with a slight tang and robust flavor, great for deli sandwiches. | 1 lb loaf | $5.99 |
| Hard Rolls | Crusty rolls with a soft interior, perfect for dinner or breakfast sandwiches. | 6-pack | $3.99 |
| Soft Dinner Rolls | Light and fluffy rolls, slightly sweet, ideal for holiday meals or everyday use. | 6-pack | $4.29 |
Cookies and Pastries
For those with a sweet tooth, Yoder’s Bakery features a delightful range of cookies and pastries. Each item is handcrafted with care, using traditional recipes passed down through generations.
| Item | Description | Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Chip Cookies | Soft and chewy cookies loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips. | 1 dozen | $7.99 |
| Snickerdoodles | Cinnamon-sugar coated cookies with a tender, buttery crumb. | 1 dozen | $7.49 |
| Butter Horns | Flaky crescent-shaped pastries filled with cinnamon sugar or fruit preserves. | 6-pack | $8.99 |
| Fruit-Filled Danishes | Light and flaky pastry topped with cream cheese and seasonal fruit. | Individual | $3.50 each |
| Oatmeal Raisin Cookies | Hearty cookies with plump raisins and a hint of cinnamon. | 1 dozen | $7.99 |
Specialty Cakes and Desserts
Yoder’s Bakery also offers specialty cakes and desserts that are perfect for celebrations or a special treat. These cakes combine moist textures with classic American flavors, beautifully decorated and available for custom orders.
| Cake | Description | Servings | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carrot Cake | Rich carrot cake with walnuts and cream cheese frosting. | 8-12 | $28.99 |
| German Chocolate Cake | Chocolate cake layered with coconut-pecan frosting. | 8-12 | $30.99 |
| Strawberry Shortcake | Light sponge cake layered with fresh strawberries and whipped cream. | 6-8 | $25.99 |
| Chocolate Fudge Cake | Decadent chocolate cake with rich fudge icing. | 8-12 | $29.99 |
| Seasonal Fruit Tart | Buttery crust filled with custard and topped with fresh seasonal fruits. | 6-8 | $24.99 |
Seasonal and Holiday Specials
Yoder’s Bakery takes special pride in celebrating seasonal flavors and holidays. Their limited-time offerings showcase fresh, local ingredients and traditional recipes that evoke holiday cheer and seasonal ambiance.
Fall and Winter Favorites: Pumpkin pies, apple cinnamon breads, gingerbread cookies, and pecan tassies are staples. During the Christmas season, specialty fruitcakes and peppermint bark cookies delight customers.
Spring and Summer Delights: Fresh berry pies, lemon bars, rhubarb crisps, and light angel food cakes highlight the warmer months. The bakery also offers refreshing iced teas and lemonade to complement these treats.
“The seasonal pies at Yoder’s are a highlight of the year — made with care and bursting with authentic flavors that celebrate every harvest.” – Frequent Visitor
Beverages and Add-ons
To round out your bakery experience, Yoder’s offers a variety of beverages and add-ons. These complement the baked goods and create a complete, satisfying visit.
| Item | Description | Size/Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fresh Brewed Coffee | Rich, smooth coffee brewed daily, available hot or iced. | 12 oz, 16 oz | $2.50, $3.00 |
| Hot Tea | Selection of black, green, and herbal teas. | 12 oz | $2.25 |
| Cold Lemonade | Freshly squeezed lemonade, perfect for summer. | 16 oz | $2.75 |
| Whipped Butter | Rich, creamy whipped butter to accompany breads and rolls. | 4 oz | $1.50 |
| Homemade Jams | Variety of fruit preserves including strawberry, raspberry, and apricot. | 8 oz jar | $5.99 |
Ordering and Customization
Yoder’s Bakery welcomes both walk-in customers and special orders. Custom cakes and bulk orders require advance notice to ensure freshness and quality.
The bakery staff is happy to accommodate dietary preferences such as nut-free or reduced-sugar options whenever possible.
To place an order, customers can visit the bakery in person or call ahead. During busy holiday seasons, placing orders early is highly recommended to secure your desired items.
About Yoder’s Bakery
Established over 50 years ago, Yoder’s Bakery has grown from a small Amish family bakery to a regional institution. Their commitment to quality, tradition, and community remains unchanged.
Using recipes passed down through generations, their baked goods continue to bring joy and comfort to every table.
Mission Statement: To provide wholesome, delicious baked goods made from scratch, using the finest ingredients and honoring the rich heritage of Amish baking traditions.
Customer Favorites
Many customers come back time and again for these standout items:
- Apple Crumb Pie: Praised for its perfect balance of sweet and tart with a buttery crumb topping.
- Amish White Bread: Known for its soft texture and lasting freshness.
- Butter Horns: A flaky, sweet pastry that pairs perfectly with morning coffee.
- Carrot Cake: Moist and flavorful with just the right amount of cream cheese frosting.
Conclusion
Yoder’s Bakery is more than just a place to buy baked goods; it is a culinary experience steeped in history and tradition. Their menu offers something for every taste, from rustic breads to decadent desserts.
Whether you are in search of a comforting pie, a fresh loaf of bread, or a special cake to celebrate a milestone, Yoder’s Bakery continues to deliver exceptional quality and heartfelt service.
Next time you are in Amish country or craving authentic homemade bakery delights, Yoder’s Bakery is an essential stop. Their dedication to craftsmanship and flavors that feel like home make every visit memorable.
