Nestled in a charming waterfront setting, The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill offers more than just a picturesque view—it presents a culinary journey that combines classic comfort food with innovative twists.
The menu is thoughtfully crafted to cater to a diverse clientele, from seafood enthusiasts to hearty meat lovers, ensuring that every guest finds something delightful. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual lunch, a lively dinner, or a late-night snack, the offerings at The Lost Paddle promise freshness, flavor, and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Careful attention is paid to sourcing ingredients locally, blending seasonal produce with traditional recipes to create dishes that are both timeless and contemporary. The Lost Paddle’s menu stands out not only for its variety but also for the balance it strikes between indulgence and health-conscious options.
The culinary team’s passion shines through in every plate, reflecting their commitment to quality and guest satisfaction.
Embarking on a meal at The Lost Paddle is more than just eating—it’s about savoring a rich tapestry of tastes, textures, and aromas that celebrate the spirit of the region and the creativity of the kitchen.
From appetizers to desserts, each section of the menu is designed with care and precision, inviting diners to explore and enjoy a memorable dining experience.
Appetizers: The Perfect Start
The appetizer selection at The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill is crafted to ignite the palate and set the tone for a satisfying meal. This section features a variety of light bites, from crispy fried delights to fresh and vibrant options, ensuring a great beginning for any dining occasion.
Guests can indulge in classic favorites like the signature calamari, which is lightly breaded and served with a zesty aioli. For those seeking something lighter, the fresh ceviche offers a tangy, refreshing introduction to the meal.
The appetizers are designed to be shareable, fostering a communal dining experience that encourages conversation and enjoyment.
Each dish emphasizes bold flavors and quality ingredients, with options that cater to both adventurous eaters and those preferring familiar tastes. The appetizers are also thoughtfully paired with the bar’s selection of craft cocktails and beers, enhancing the overall experience.
Signature Appetizer Highlights
- Calamari Fritti: Tender squid rings fried to golden perfection, served with a house-made lemon-garlic aioli.
- Island Ceviche: Fresh local fish marinated in lime juice, mixed with cilantro, tomatoes, and jalapeños for a spicy kick.
- BBQ Chicken Sliders: Mini sandwiches stacked with smoked chicken, tangy BBQ sauce, and crisp coleslaw.
“The appetizers here are a gateway to the flavors of the coast—fresh, bold, and perfectly balanced.” – Local Food Critic
Seafood Selections: Fresh from the Water
The Lost Paddle’s seafood menu is a tribute to the bounty of the nearby waters, featuring an array of dishes that highlight freshness and expert preparation. With an emphasis on sustainable sourcing, each seafood item promises quality and taste that seafood lovers crave.
From grilled fish to decadent shellfish platters, the seafood offerings provide something for every preference. The chefs use a variety of cooking techniques to enhance the natural flavors, whether through delicate steaming, robust grilling, or flavorful frying.
Seafood dishes are often accompanied by seasonal sides and house-made sauces, crafted to complement the main ingredients without overpowering them. The menu also offers options that accommodate dietary sensitivities, ensuring inclusivity and satisfaction.
Comparative Seafood Dishes
| Dish | Cooking Style | Flavor Profile | Price |
| Grilled Mahi-Mahi | Grilled | Light, smoky, citrus-infused | $22 |
| Blackened Red Snapper | Pan-seared | Spicy, robust, buttery | $24 |
| Seafood Platter | Fried and steamed mix | Varied textures, savory, rich | $28 |
Grill Favorites: Hearty and Satisfying
The grill section at The Lost Paddle offers a selection of robust, hearty dishes perfect for diners looking for comfort and flavor. From perfectly charred steaks to succulent burgers, these dishes are designed to satisfy even the most discerning appetites.
Each item is grilled to order, allowing guests to customize their preferences from rare to well-done. The menu also features unique marinades and rubs that enhance the natural flavor of the meats without overwhelming them.
Accompaniments like hand-cut fries, grilled vegetables, and house-made sauces add depth to each plate. The grill favorites are popular choices for those seeking a classic American dining experience with a local twist.
Popular Grill Items
- Ribeye Steak: A 12-ounce cut, marbled for tenderness, served with chimichurri sauce.
- Lost Paddle Burger: Juicy beef patty topped with smoked cheddar, caramelized onions, and house BBQ sauce.
- Grilled Portobello: A vegetarian option featuring marinated mushrooms, roasted peppers, and goat cheese.
“The grill section offers everything you crave — perfectly cooked, generously portioned, and full of flavor.” – Regular Patron
Salads and Light Fare: Fresh and Flavorful
For those seeking lighter options without sacrificing taste, the salads and light fare section delivers fresh, vibrant choices. These dishes incorporate crisp vegetables, seasonal fruits, and flavorful dressings that elevate simple ingredients.
The Lost Paddle’s salads range from traditional Caesar to innovative blends featuring local produce and unique toppings. Proteins like grilled chicken, shrimp, and tofu can be added to create a more substantial meal.
Each salad is crafted to balance texture and flavor, often including nuts, cheeses, and house-made croutons to add complexity. This section is designed to appeal to health-conscious diners and those looking to complement their meal with something refreshing.
Salad Selections
- Coastal Caesar: Romaine, parmesan, house dressing, and garlic croutons.
- Mango Avocado Salad: Mixed greens, fresh mango, avocado, toasted almonds, and honey-lime vinaigrette.
- Grilled Shrimp Salad: Shrimp over baby spinach with cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, and citrus dressing.
Beverages: Crafted to Complement
The beverage menu at The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill is thoughtfully curated to enhance the dining experience. It features an array of craft cocktails, local beers, fine wines, and non-alcoholic options.
Cocktails are prepared with fresh ingredients, house-made syrups, and creative garnishes, offering both classic recipes and unique signature drinks. The beer selection emphasizes local breweries, showcasing the region’s craft brewing scene.
Wine lovers can explore a carefully selected list that includes varietals from both domestic and international vineyards. Non-alcoholic options include fresh juices, mocktails, and artisan sodas, catering to all tastes and preferences.
Signature Cocktails
- Paddle Punch: A tropical blend of rum, pineapple juice, and fresh lime.
- Smoky Paloma: Tequila, grapefruit soda, and a hint of smoked sea salt.
- Ginger Basil Smash: Vodka muddled with fresh basil and ginger syrup.
| Beverage | Type | Price |
| Lost Paddle IPA | Local Craft Beer | $7 |
| Chardonnay | White Wine | $9/glass |
| Virgin Cucumber Mule | Non-Alcoholic Cocktail | $6 |
Desserts: Sweet Endings
The dessert offerings at The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill provide a satisfying conclusion to any meal. This section features homemade treats that balance indulgence with refined flavors, perfect for those with a sweet tooth.
From rich chocolate creations to light, fruity options, desserts are made fresh daily by the in-house pastry team. Seasonal specials often rotate, reflecting the best local fruits and ingredients available.
The presentation is just as important as the taste, with desserts served elegantly to delight the senses. Pairing suggestions with dessert wines or coffee are available to complete the dining experience.
Popular Dessert Choices
- Key Lime Pie: Tart and creamy, with a graham cracker crust and whipped cream topping.
- Chocolate Lava Cake: Warm chocolate cake with a gooey center, served with vanilla ice cream.
- Seasonal Berry Crisp: Fresh berries baked with a cinnamon oat topping, served warm.
“Desserts here turn a meal into an event — perfectly balanced sweet indulgences that keep guests coming back.” – Pastry Chef
Kids’ Menu: Fun and Flavorful
The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill welcomes families with a dedicated kids’ menu that offers healthy, tasty options designed for younger palates. This section balances nutrition and fun, ensuring children enjoy their meal just as much as adults.
Portion sizes are tailored to children, and the dishes include familiar favorites with wholesome ingredients. The menu also incorporates playful presentations to engage kids and encourage them to try new flavors.
The staff is attentive to food allergies and special dietary needs, making dining out easy and stress-free for families. The kids’ menu encourages sharing and introduces young diners to the joy of trying a variety of foods.
Kids’ Favorites
- Mini Cheeseburgers: Two small patties with cheddar cheese and a side of apple slices.
- Chicken Tenders: Crispy baked tenders served with honey mustard dipping sauce.
- Macaroni & Cheese: Creamy, cheesy pasta made with real cheddar.
| Meal | Portion Size | Price |
| Mini Cheeseburgers | 2 sliders | $7 |
| Chicken Tenders | 5 pieces | $6 |
| Macaroni & Cheese | Small bowl | $5 |
Conclusion: A Culinary Destination Worth Exploring
The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill menu offers an exceptional variety of dishes that cater to diverse tastes and preferences, making it a standout destination for casual and refined dining alike. From the first bite of an appetizer to the final taste of dessert, the culinary team’s dedication to quality and creativity is evident.
Each section of the menu showcases a thoughtful balance between tradition and innovation, with an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients that celebrate the region’s unique flavors. Whether you are craving fresh seafood, hearty grilled options, or light, refreshing salads, The Lost Paddle delivers with consistency and flair.
Beyond the food, the atmosphere and attentive service elevate the overall experience, creating a welcoming environment where guests feel valued and satisfied. The beverage program complements the menu perfectly, enhancing the enjoyment of each meal.
For families, couples, and solo diners alike, The Lost Paddle Bar and Grill stands as a testament to what great food and great hospitality can achieve.
