Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore is a culinary gem that artfully blends classic American flavors with a coastal twist, creating a dining experience that is both comforting and exciting. Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, this vibrant eatery has become a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike.
The menu at Mustang Sally’s is a reflection of its energetic atmosphere—bold, flavorful, and diverse, showcasing everything from hearty sandwiches to fresh seafood offerings. Whether you’re craving a casual lunch or a lively dinner, the menu offers something to satisfy every palate.
From the moment you glance at the menu, it’s clear that Mustang Sally’s places a strong emphasis on quality ingredients and creative preparation. Each dish is thoughtfully crafted to highlight fresh produce, premium meats, and unique seasonings that evoke the spirit of the coastal community.
The menu is designed to encourage sharing and exploration, inviting diners to try a variety of small plates, signature entrees, and indulgent desserts. This dedication to both tradition and innovation ensures that every visit is memorable.
Exploring the Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore menu reveals a commitment to culinary excellence paired with a warm, welcoming ambiance. The restaurant’s offerings pay homage to classic American comfort foods while incorporating subtle, inventive twists that keep the menu fresh and engaging.
Whether you are a seafood enthusiast, a burger lover, or someone who enjoys vibrant vegetarian options, Mustang Sally’s delivers with style and substance.
Appetizers: The Perfect Start
The appetizer section at Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore sets the tone for an exceptional meal. Designed to tantalize taste buds and encourage sharing, these starters are crafted with bold flavors and fresh ingredients.
Each dish provides a unique introduction to the menu, balancing comfort with creativity.
Popular choices include their signature Crab Dip, made with fresh crab meat and a blend of cheeses, delivering a creamy, savory experience that pairs perfectly with their house-made pita chips. Another standout is the Buffalo Cauliflower Bites, a vegetarian favorite offering a spicy kick with a cool ranch dip on the side.
The appetizers are portioned generously, making them ideal for groups or as a prelude to the main course.
Signature Appetizer Highlights
- Crab Dip: Rich, creamy, and loaded with fresh crab, served warm with pita chips.
- Buffalo Cauliflower Bites: Crispy and spicy, perfect for those seeking a vegetarian option.
- Loaded Nachos: Topped with melted cheese, jalapeños, sour cream, and fresh guacamole.
- Sweet Potato Fries: Served with a tangy chipotle aioli for dipping.
“The appetizers at Mustang Sally’s are the perfect blend of bold flavors and fresh ingredients, setting the stage for a remarkable dining experience.” – Local Food Critic
Burgers and Sandwiches: Classic Comfort Elevated
Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore takes the classic American burger and sandwich to new heights by using high-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations. This section of the menu offers a variety of options that satisfy hearty appetites without sacrificing sophistication.
The burgers are crafted with freshly ground beef or alternative proteins, grilled to perfection and topped with house-made sauces and fresh produce. The sandwiches feature artisan breads and thoughtfully paired fillings that range from traditional to adventurous.
Whether you prefer a juicy cheeseburger or a spicy chicken sandwich, Mustang Sally’s delivers bold flavors with every bite.
Popular Burgers and Sandwiches
| Item | Main Ingredients | Special Feature |
| Classic Sally Burger | Beef patty, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, mustard aioli | Signature house-made mustard aioli |
| Spicy Black Bean Burger | Black bean patty, pepper jack cheese, jalapeños, chipotle mayo | Vegetarian with a spicy kick |
| Grilled Chicken Sandwich | Marinated chicken breast, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato | Fresh avocado and smoky bacon |
| Philly Cheese Steak | Sliced beef, sautéed onions and peppers, provolone cheese | Classic Philly style with tender beef |
Each burger and sandwich is served with your choice of side: crisp fries, sweet potato wedges, or a fresh garden salad.
Fresh Seafood Selections
Given its coastal location, Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore offers an impressive range of seafood dishes that highlight freshness and flavor. These entrees balance traditional seafood preparations with innovative touches, appealing to lovers of the ocean’s bounty.
From flaky fish tacos to hearty seafood pasta, each dish is prepared with an emphasis on quality and sustainability. The seafood is sourced locally when possible, ensuring that every bite bursts with natural taste.
The menu caters to a variety of preferences, with options that range from light and healthy to rich and indulgent.
Seafood Favorites
- Fish Tacos: Grilled white fish with cabbage slaw, pico de gallo, and chipotle crema.
- Lobster Mac & Cheese: Creamy, cheesy pasta loaded with chunks of fresh lobster.
- Seared Ahi Tuna: Served rare with a sesame crust and wasabi aioli.
- Clam Chowder: Classic New England style, rich and hearty.
“The seafood at Mustang Sally’s is a celebration of local waters, offering dishes that feel both indulgent and authentic.” – Bay Shore Gourmet Magazine
Salads and Healthy Options
For those seeking lighter fare, Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore provides a thoughtfully curated selection of salads and health-conscious dishes. These options focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients combined with flavorful dressings and toppings.
The salads are vibrant and satisfying, often featuring superfoods, grilled proteins, and house-made elements like croutons and vinaigrettes. These dishes are perfect for diners who want to enjoy a nutritious meal without compromising on taste or portion size.
Popular Salad Choices
| Salad | Main Ingredients | Calories |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar | Romaine, grilled chicken, parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing | 450 |
| Quinoa & Kale Salad | Quinoa, kale, cranberries, almonds, lemon vinaigrette | 380 |
| Beet & Goat Cheese Salad | Roasted beets, goat cheese, mixed greens, walnuts, balsamic glaze | 400 |
| Asian Shrimp Salad | Shrimp, mixed greens, mandarin oranges, sesame dressing | 420 |
These salads are ideal for those who want a meal that is both nourishing and full of flavor.
Entrées: Hearty and Satisfying
The entrée section at Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore offers a variety of substantial dishes designed to satisfy even the heartiest appetites. These meals showcase the kitchen’s ability to balance classic comfort food with refined culinary techniques.
From slow-cooked ribs to succulent steaks and vegetarian pasta, the entrees are diverse and thoughtfully prepared. The portion sizes are generous, making each dish perfect for a main course whether dining solo or sharing.
Entrée Highlights
- BBQ Baby Back Ribs: Slow-cooked and glazed with a smoky house BBQ sauce.
- Ribeye Steak: Hand-cut, grilled to order, served with garlic mashed potatoes.
- Vegetable Primavera: Seasonal vegetables tossed in a light garlic olive oil sauce over pasta.
- Chicken Marsala: Pan-seared chicken breast with a rich mushroom and Marsala wine sauce.
“Every entrée at Mustang Sally’s is a testament to the kitchen’s passion for bold flavors and hearty portions.” – Culinary Expert Review
Desserts: Sweet Endings
No meal at Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore is complete without indulging in their decadent dessert offerings. This section features classic favorites alongside innovative sweets that provide the perfect finishing touch.
The desserts are crafted in-house with attention to detail and quality, using fresh ingredients and creative flavor pairings. Whether you prefer rich chocolate, fruity tarts, or creamy custards, there is a dessert to satisfy every craving.
Notable Desserts
| Dessert | Description | Price |
| Chocolate Lava Cake | Warm chocolate cake with a gooey molten center, served with vanilla ice cream. | $8 |
| Key Lime Pie | Tart and sweet, with a graham cracker crust and whipped cream topping. | $7 |
| Classic New York Cheesecake | Creamy cheesecake with a buttery graham crust and fresh berry compote. | $8 |
| Seasonal Fruit Sorbet | Light and refreshing, made with fresh seasonal fruits. | $6 |
Each dessert is designed to complement the flavors of the meal and leave diners with a lasting impression of sweetness and satisfaction.
Beverages: Refresh and Revitalize
The beverage menu at Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore features an eclectic mix of classic cocktails, craft beers, fine wines, and non-alcoholic options. This selection is curated to pair perfectly with the diverse menu and enhance the overall dining experience.
Signature cocktails incorporate fresh ingredients and creative twists on timeless recipes. The beer list includes local brews alongside popular favorites, while the wine selection offers a thoughtful range of varietals to suit all tastes.
Non-alcoholic options are equally refreshing, with house-made lemonades and iced teas.
Featured Beverages
- Mustang Mule: A refreshing take on the classic Moscow Mule, with fresh lime and ginger beer.
- Bay Shore Blonde Ale: Locally brewed, light, and crisp.
- House Red Blend: A smooth, medium-bodied wine with notes of cherry and oak.
- Freshly Brewed Iced Tea: Sweetened or unsweetened, made daily.
“The thoughtfully curated beverage menu at Mustang Sally’s elevates the dining experience, offering refreshment and complementing each dish.” – Beverage Specialist
Mustang Sally’s Bay Shore menu is a masterful collection that celebrates the essence of coastal American cuisine with a creative edge. Each section—from appetizers to desserts—reflects a dedication to quality, flavor, and hospitality.
The diverse offerings cater to all tastes and occasions, making it a versatile destination for casual meals or special celebrations. The thoughtful pairing of dishes and beverages ensures a harmonious dining experience that delights the senses.
Whether indulging in fresh seafood, savoring a juicy burger, or finishing with a decadent dessert, Mustang Sally’s provides a memorable culinary journey that embodies the spirit of Bay Shore’s vibrant food scene.
This commitment to excellence and innovation continues to establish Mustang Sally’s as a standout restaurant, inviting guests to return time and again for exceptional food, warm service, and an atmosphere that feels like home.
