Garden City Pizza And Catering Menu captures the essence of culinary craftsmanship and community spirit in every bite. With a commitment to fresh ingredients and bold flavors, it presents a diverse selection that appeals to families, professionals, and food enthusiasts alike.
The inviting aroma of hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and bubbling cheese sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. This menu balances timeless favorites with inventive creations, ensuring every guest discovers a new delight.
Beyond classic pies, the menu extends into artisanal salads, hearty pastas, and customizable catering packages designed for gatherings of all sizes. Each offering highlights locally sourced produce and thoughtfully paired toppings, celebrating quality at an accessible price.
Whether delivered hot to a backyard barbecue or enjoyed in a cozy dining room, the culinary journey remains consistent: fresh, flavorful, and made just for you. Explore the menu’s sections to uncover the perfect dish for any occasion.
Pizza Varieties
The foundation of Garden City’s appeal lies in its extensive pizza offerings. Every pizza starts with a choice of crust and sauce before layering on premium toppings.
Hand-tossed dough is prepared daily, resulting in a crispy exterior and a tender crumb. Signature sauces range from classic marinara to creamy garlic white sauce.
Cheese blends include part-skim mozzarella, provolone, and a three-cheese mix for a perfect melt. Toppings span from traditional pepperoni to gourmet prosciutto and arugula.
Crust Options
Thin crust lovers appreciate its light and crisp bite, while thick crust fans savor the doughy chew. The gluten-free alternative uses a rice-based flour blend without compromising texture.
Each crust pairs seamlessly with any sauce and topping choice.
- Classic Hand-Tossed
- Thin & Crispy
- Deep Dish Pan
- Gluten-Free
| Crust Type | Thickness | Texture |
| Thin & Crispy | 5mm | Crunchy |
| Hand-Tossed | 10mm | Chewy |
| Deep Dish | 15mm | Fluffy |
Specialty Pizzas
Garden City’s specialty pizzas showcase inventive combinations and bold seasonings. These signature pies reflect both classic inspirations and regional favorites.
Each specialty pizza features a curated list of toppings balanced in flavor and texture. Premium meats, fresh vegetables, and aromatic herbs come together in unexpected harmony.
The menu highlights seasonal ingredients to keep offerings dynamic throughout the year.
Featured Creations
“The Mediterranean Dream pie is a palette of flavors that feels both exotic and comforting,” praises a regular customer.
- Mediterranean Dream: Feta, kalamata olives, spinach
- BBQ Chicken Ranch: Grilled chicken, smoky sauce, red onion
- Buffalo Blue: Buffalo sauce, shredded chicken, blue cheese
- Pesto Primavera: Basil pesto, zucchini, cherry tomatoes
Seasonal specialties rotate with the harvest, ensuring fresh and vibrant toppings. Local partnerships supply heirloom tomatoes and farm-fresh basil in peak season.
These limited-time offerings invite guests to explore new flavor profiles regularly.
Calzones And Strombolis
Calzones and strombolis offer a handheld twist on the pizza experience. Each item is carefully folded and baked to golden perfection.
The calzone encloses fillings within a half-moon dough shell, while the stromboli wraps toppings in a full cylinder shape. Both are brushed with olive oil and sprinkled with herbs for a crisp finish.
A side of marinara or garlic dipping sauce complements the warm, gooey interior.
Popular Fillings
Pepperoni & Sausage: A spicy, meaty classic with melted cheese. Spinach & Ricotta: A vegetarian blend that’s rich and creamy.
Ham & Pineapple: A sweet-savory combination that delights the palate.
- Meat Lover’s Combo
- Garden Veggie Delight
- Four Cheese Blend
- Custom Build-Your-Own
Each calzone and stromboli is made to order, allowing for customization of sauces, cheeses, and toppings. Nutritional information is available upon request.
These items travel well for lunches and boxed meals, ensuring quality remains intact.
Pasta Dishes
Pasta selections at Garden City range from hearty classics to baked specialties. Each dish highlights high-quality noodles and house-made sauces.
Available in vegetarian and meat-based options, pastas cater to diverse tastes. Gluten-free shells are offered for those with dietary needs.
Portion sizes suit both solo diners and family-style sharing.
Signature Baked Ziti
The baked ziti features penne tossed in a robust tomato-meat sauce, layered with mozzarella, and baked until bubbly. A sprinkle of Parmesan and fresh basil crowns the dish.
It arrives piping hot in an oven-safe pan, ready to serve multiple guests.
| Dish | Small | Large |
| Baked Ziti | 4 servings | 8 servings |
| Alfredo Fettuccine | 2 servings | 6 servings |
| Penne Arrabbiata | 3 servings | 7 servings |
- Alfredo Fettuccine
- Penne Arrabbiata
- Lasagna Layers
- Spinach Ricotta Shells
Salads And Appetizers
Fresh salads and appetizers provide balance and variety. These lighter dishes complement the menu’s more indulgent options.
Crisp greens, seasonal vegetables, and homemade dressings enhance the salad selection. Appetizers include handheld bites and shareable platters.
Each item is designed for both flavor and presentation.
Signature Garden Salad
“The tangy balsamic vinaigrette transforms simple ingredients into a standout starter,” notes the head chef.
- Greek Salad with Feta and Olives
- Caesar Salad with House Croutons
- Bruschetta Trio Platter
- Garlic Parmesan Knots
The salad menu caters to vegan and gluten-free preferences through simple swaps. Appetizer platters are customizable for events.
Presentation matters, with garnishes and plating adding visual appeal.
Catering Packages
Garden City’s catering services streamline event planning with tailored menus. Packages range from light bites to full-service feasts.
Each package includes delivery, setup, and disposable servingware. Professional staff can assist with on-site service upon request.
The team collaborates on menu selection to match guest counts and dietary needs.
Event Tiers
- Casual Gathering: Pizzas, salads, and soft drinks
- Office Lunch: Sandwich platters, wraps, and bottled water
- Celebration Feast: Full pizza buffet, appetizers, and desserts
- Deluxe Package: Pasta stations, carving meats, and custom bartending
Customized quotes detail per-person pricing and package inclusions. Add-ons include beverage stations and dessert buffets.
Seasonal menus introduce limited-time dishes for weddings and corporate galas.
Beverages And Desserts
Beverage and dessert offerings complete the menu with satisfying sweet and refreshing options. Choices span from classic sodas to handcrafted beverages.
Soft drinks, iced teas, and lemonades are made fresh daily. A selection of craft sodas and bottled water enhances variety.
Dessert trays showcase crowd-pleasing favorites.
Dessert Specials
- New York Cheesecake: Rich, creamy, and topped with berry compote
- Chocolate Brownie Bites: Fudgy squares dusted with powdered sugar
- Cannoli Trio: Crisp shells filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips
- Seasonal Fruit Tart
Desserts are portioned for easy sharing, ideal for office events or family dinner finales. Beverage packages pair perfectly with any meal selection.
The team recommends chilled lemonade for a refreshing contrast to savory dishes.
Garden City Pizza And Catering Menu brings together centuries of pizza tradition, modern twists on Italian classics, and thoughtful catering solutions for events of every scale. From crispy thin-crust pies to loaded calzones, from baked pastas to fresh garden salads, each item is crafted with an unwavering focus on quality.
Customizable catering packages remove the stress of planning, offering flexible menus and professional service that let hosts savor their own gatherings.
Whether indulging in a family pizza night, hosting a business luncheon, or celebrating a milestone, the menu adapts to every taste and occasion. Locally sourced ingredients and house-made sauces ensure consistency and flavor excellence.
With attention to detail in presentation, portion sizing, and dietary accommodations, Garden City Pizza And Catering delivers a memorable dining experience that resonates long after the last slice is gone.
