Goodfellas Subs has carved out a distinctive niche in the world of sandwich shops by offering a menu that brilliantly blends authentic flavors with fresh ingredients. Known for its commitment to quality and traditional preparation methods, Goodfellas Subs delivers an experience that goes far beyond your typical sub shop.
Whether you’re a fan of classic Italian cold cuts or crave something a bit more adventurous, their menu presents a variety of options designed to satisfy every palate. The atmosphere of Goodfellas Subs complements the food itself, evoking the warmth and familiarity of an old-school deli with a modern twist.
The menu is thoughtfully crafted to highlight the best of Italian-American sandwich culture, emphasizing fresh bread, premium meats, and house-made dressings. Each sub is a testament to the brand’s dedication to authenticity and flavor balance.
Beyond sandwiches, the menu also offers a selection of salads, sides, and beverages that round out the dining experience. Whether you’re dining in, ordering takeout, or grabbing a quick lunch, Goodfellas Subs ensures every bite is memorable and satisfying.
From hearty classics to customizable options, Goodfellas Subs’ menu is a celebration of taste and tradition. The following sections will explore the various components of their menu, detailing the offerings and what makes each category stand out.
Signature Hot Subs
The heart of Goodfellas Subs’ menu lies in its signature hot subs, which are crafted with a perfect balance of flavors and textures. These subs are served on freshly baked rolls, toasted to a golden crisp, and packed with premium meats and cheeses.
The hot subs cater to those who appreciate a warm, hearty sandwich that delivers on both comfort and taste.
Goodfellas takes pride in using only the finest Italian-style meats that are sliced daily to ensure freshness. Each sandwich is then assembled with a blend of cheeses, vegetables, and homemade sauces that complement the rich flavors of the meats.
The hot subs range from classic options to more unique creations, offering something for every sandwich lover.
Popular choices in this section include the classic Meatball Sub, the spicy Italian Sausage, and the spicy Capicola. Each sub is carefully crafted to achieve a robust flavor profile that is both satisfying and memorable.
Popular Hot Subs Overview
- Meatball Sub: Traditional meatballs simmered in marinara sauce, topped with melted provolone cheese.
- Italian Sausage: Spicy sausage links grilled and served with sautéed peppers and onions.
- Spicy Capicola: Thinly sliced, spicy cured pork layered with hot peppers and provolone cheese.
“The perfect hot sub combines fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and just the right amount of heat to leave a lasting impression.” – Goodfellas Subs Chef
Classic Cold Subs
For those who prefer their sandwiches served cold, Goodfellas Subs offers a robust selection of classic cold subs. These sandwiches highlight freshly sliced deli meats, crisp vegetables, and house-made dressings nestled inside crusty rolls.
The cold subs provide a refreshing alternative with a focus on balanced flavors and quality ingredients.
Each cold sub is made with a careful layering technique that ensures every bite delivers a harmonious blend of taste and texture. The meats are sourced from trusted suppliers and sliced to order, preserving their natural flavors and freshness.
Customers can enjoy the simplicity of a classic Italian cold cut sub or explore options like turkey and roast beef.
Vegetarian options are also available in this section, with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil making for a delightful combination. Goodfellas Subs’ cold subs are perfect for a light yet satisfying meal on the go or a relaxed lunch.
Cold Sub Favorites
- Italian Classic: Genoa salami, ham, capicola, and provolone with lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
- Turkey & Cheese: Sliced turkey breast combined with Swiss cheese and a touch of mayo.
- Vegetarian Delight: Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and balsamic glaze on a toasted roll.
| Sub Name | Main Ingredients | Calories |
| Italian Classic | Salami, ham, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato | 550 |
| Turkey & Cheese | Turkey breast, Swiss cheese, mayo | 460 |
| Vegetarian Delight | Mozzarella, tomato, basil, balsamic glaze | 430 |
Customizable Sub Options
Goodfellas Subs understands the importance of personalization, which is why the menu offers a fully customizable sub section. This option allows customers to build their sandwich from scratch, choosing their preferred bread, meats, cheeses, toppings, and sauces.
The customization experience is designed to cater to individual tastes and dietary preferences.
The customizable subs start with a selection of freshly baked breads, including classic Italian, whole wheat, and gluten-free options. Customers can then choose from a variety of premium meats such as turkey, roast beef, ham, and various Italian cold cuts.
Cheese options include provolone, Swiss, mozzarella, and American, allowing for endless flavor combinations.
Vegetables and condiments can be added to enhance the taste and texture of the sandwich. From crisp lettuce and ripe tomatoes to spicy peppers and savory olives, the toppings are fresh and plentiful.
Sauces range from traditional mayo and mustard to house-made Italian dressing and spicy aioli.
Customization Highlights
- Bread Choices: Italian, whole wheat, gluten-free.
- Meats: Turkey, roast beef, ham, salami, capicola.
- Cheeses: Provolone, Swiss, mozzarella, American.
- Toppings: Lettuce, tomato, onion, peppers, olives.
- Sauces: Mayo, mustard, Italian dressing, spicy aioli.
“Customization empowers our customers to create a sub that perfectly fits their cravings and dietary needs.” – Goodfellas Subs Manager
Fresh Salads and Sides
Complementing the sandwiches, Goodfellas Subs offers a range of fresh salads and sides that provide lighter and healthier options. These dishes are prepared with the same attention to quality and freshness as the subs, making them a popular choice for health-conscious diners or those seeking variety.
The salads feature a mix of crisp greens, fresh vegetables, and premium proteins for a balanced meal. Dressings are made in-house, offering vibrant flavors that enhance the natural taste of the ingredients.
Sides include classic choices like chips and pickles, as well as unique offerings such as house-made pasta salad.
These sides and salads are designed to be versatile, serving as perfect accompaniments to any sandwich or as stand-alone meals for a lighter bite. They emphasize seasonality and freshness, ensuring each dish is vibrant and satisfying.
Popular Salads and Sides
- Caesar Salad: Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing.
- House Salad: Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, and Italian dressing.
- Pasta Salad: Tri-color rotini with fresh vegetables and a tangy vinaigrette.
- Classic Sides: Potato chips, dill pickles, and house-made coleslaw.
| Side | Description | Calories |
| Caesar Salad | Crisp romaine with Parmesan and Caesar dressing | 320 |
| Pasta Salad | Rotini, vegetables, vinaigrette | 280 |
| Potato Chips | Classic salted chips | 150 |
Signature Sauces and Dressings
One of the defining features of Goodfellas Subs’ menu is its selection of signature sauces and dressings. These house-made concoctions add depth and character to every sandwich and salad.
Crafted from traditional recipes, the sauces are a perfect balance of flavor and texture.
Goodfellas’ sauces range from tangy Italian dressings to creamy aiolis that complement the meats and cheeses perfectly. Each sauce is made fresh daily, ensuring consistency and freshness.
These dressings enhance the overall experience by adding subtle layers of flavor that elevate the simple sub to something extraordinary.
The menu encourages customers to experiment with different sauce combinations to discover their perfect match. From spicy to sweet, the sauces cater to a broad spectrum of taste preferences.
Popular Sauces and Their Uses
- House Italian Dressing: A zesty, herb-infused vinaigrette perfect for cold subs and salads.
- Spicy Aioli: Creamy with a kick, ideal for hot subs like Italian sausage or capicola.
- Garlic Mayo: Smooth and rich, adds a subtle garlic flavor that enhances any sandwich.
- Marinara Sauce: Traditional tomato sauce used primarily in meatball and sausage subs.
“Our sauces are the secret ingredient that turns a good sub into a great one.” – Head Chef, Goodfellas Subs
Beverages and Desserts
To complete the dining experience, Goodfellas Subs offers a thoughtfully curated selection of beverages and desserts. These options are designed to refresh the palate and provide a satisfying end to the meal.
The beverage menu features both classic and contemporary choices, catering to a variety of tastes.
Soft drinks, iced teas, and specialty lemonades are popular picks for their refreshing qualities. For those seeking an indulgent finish, desserts such as Italian cookies and cannoli are available.
These sweet treats are freshly made, echoing the traditional Italian roots of the brand.
The pairing of beverages and desserts with the menu items is encouraged to enhance the overall experience, whether it’s a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner.
Popular Beverage and Dessert Options
- Classic Soda Selection: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, and root beer.
- House-Made Lemonade: Freshly squeezed with a hint of mint.
- Italian Cookies: Assorted varieties including almond and chocolate chip.
- Cannoli: Traditional ricotta-filled pastry with chocolate chips.
| Item | Description | Calories |
| House-Made Lemonade | Freshly squeezed with mint | 120 |
| Cannoli | Ricotta-filled pastry with chocolate chips | 300 |
| Italian Cookie | Almond or chocolate chip | 180 |
Nutritional Information and Dietary Options
Goodfellas Subs is attentive to the nutritional needs of its customers and provides detailed information to help diners make informed choices. The menu clearly indicates calorie counts and potential allergens, catering to a diverse clientele with various dietary restrictions.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options are thoughtfully incorporated, ensuring that all guests can find something delicious and suitable. The use of fresh, high-quality ingredients supports a healthier eating experience without compromising on flavor.
For those monitoring their intake, the menu offers lighter options and the ability to customize subs to reduce calories and fats. This transparency and flexibility are a testament to Goodfellas Subs’ commitment to customer satisfaction and well-being.
Key Dietary Highlights
- Gluten-Free Bread: Available upon request for all subs.
- Vegetarian Subs: Fresh mozzarella and vegetable-based options.
- Calorie Information: Provided for all menu items to assist with dietary planning.
- Allergy Awareness: Menu notes potential allergens such as nuts, dairy, and gluten.
“Providing clear nutritional information empowers our customers to enjoy their meals with confidence.” – Nutrition Coordinator, Goodfellas Subs
Conclusion
Goodfellas Subs delivers a menu that is rich in tradition, quality, and variety, making it a standout choice for sandwich enthusiasts and casual diners alike. Their commitment to fresh ingredients, authentic flavors, and customer customization ensures that every visit is a satisfying culinary experience.
From their hearty hot subs to their crisp salads and thoughtfully crafted sauces, Goodfellas Subs offers something for everyone.
The attention to detail extends beyond taste to include nutritional transparency and accommodating dietary needs, making the menu accessible and enjoyable for a wide audience. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Italian cold cut or craving a customized creation, Goodfellas Subs provides an inviting, flavorful journey with every bite.
Ultimately, the menu reflects the brand’s passion for quality and customer satisfaction, proving that a great sub is more than just a sandwich—it’s a celebration of heritage, flavor, and community. For anyone seeking a memorable meal that honors Italian-American sandwich traditions while embracing modern tastes, Goodfellas Subs is the place to be.
