Mary Zifer’s Pizza in New Philadelphia stands as a beloved institution for locals and visitors alike, offering not just food but an experience that captures the essence of community and authentic flavor.
Known for its welcoming atmosphere and dedication to quality, Mary Zifer’s has carved a niche in the competitive world of pizza with a menu that balances tradition and creativity. Whether you are craving a classic slice or looking to explore innovative toppings and combinations, their diverse offerings promise satisfaction for every palate.
The menu is thoughtfully crafted to cater to various tastes, from hearty meat lovers to vegetarians seeking fresh, vibrant flavors. It’s not just about pizza; Mary Zifer’s also offers an array of appetizers, salads, and desserts that complement their main dishes beautifully.
Every item reflects a commitment to fresh ingredients and careful preparation, ensuring that each bite is memorable.
At the heart of Mary Zifer’s is a passion for bringing people together through food. The restaurant’s menu is a testament to that mission, inviting guests to savor quality, share moments, and discover new favorites.
Whether visiting for a casual meal or a special occasion, the menu’s diversity and depth provide something for everyone.
Signature Pizzas
Mary Zifer’s Signature Pizzas highlight the restaurant’s expertise in crafting unique, flavorful combinations that have become customer favorites over the years. These pizzas feature a harmonious blend of toppings, sauces, and cheeses, delivering a satisfying bite that reflects the brand’s commitment to excellence.
Each signature pizza is carefully balanced to showcase both classic and contemporary flavors. Ingredients are sourced locally whenever possible, ensuring freshness and supporting the community.
From the robust meat lover’s options to the lighter, vegetable-focused pies, the signature pizzas appeal to a wide audience.
Popular choices include the “Zifer Special,” which combines pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, and onions on a perfectly baked crust. Another standout is the “Garden Delight,” a vegetarian favorite featuring mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, and feta cheese.
The crust itself is a critical component, with a golden, crisp exterior and a chewy interior that holds toppings beautifully.
- Zifer Special: Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions
- Garden Delight: Mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, feta cheese
- Buffalo Chicken: Spicy buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, blue cheese
- Four Cheese: Mozzarella, cheddar, parmesan, provolone
“The Signature Pizzas at Mary Zifer’s are a true reflection of our passion for quality and flavor. Each bite tells a story of tradition and innovation.” – Chef Mary Zifer
Build-Your-Own Pizza
For those who prefer to tailor their meal to specific tastes, Mary Zifer’s offers an extensive Build-Your-Own Pizza option. This customizable approach empowers diners to select every element, from crust style to toppings, allowing for a truly personalized dining experience.
The process begins with choosing the crust type, including traditional hand-tossed, thin crust, or deep dish. Next comes the selection of sauce, ranging from classic marinara to garlic alfredo or spicy barbecue.
Finally, an assortment of toppings is available to create the perfect combination, whether simple or adventurous.
Vegetables, meats, and cheeses are fresh and plentiful, enabling endless creativity. This section of the menu is particularly popular among families and groups, as it allows each person to craft their ideal pizza without compromise.
Crust Options
- Hand-Tossed: Classic, slightly thick, and chewy
- Thin Crust: Crisp and light, perfect for a less filling meal
- Deep Dish: Thick, hearty, and loaded with toppings
Toppings Categories
- Meats: Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, grilled chicken
- Vegetables: Bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, spinach, tomatoes
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, feta, blue cheese
| Crust Type | Calories (per slice) | Texture | Best For |
| Hand-Tossed | 250 | Chewy & Soft | Traditional lovers |
| Thin Crust | 180 | Crisp & Light | Health-conscious eaters |
| Deep Dish | 350 | Thick & Dense | Hearty appetite |
Appetizers and Starters
Mary Zifer’s offers an enticing selection of appetizers that set the tone for a satisfying meal. These starters are crafted to complement the main dishes and provide a flavorful introduction to the dining experience.
From classic mozzarella sticks to inventive dips and wings, the appetizers are designed with a balance of taste and shareability in mind. They are perfect for groups or as a light snack before the main course arrives, and they reflect the same commitment to quality as the pizzas.
Several appetizers are house specialties, using signature sauces and fresh ingredients. They pair wonderfully with the variety of craft sodas and local beers available, enhancing the overall enjoyment of the meal.
- Garlic Parmesan Wings: Tossed in a savory garlic butter sauce
- Spinach Artichoke Dip: Creamy and cheesy, served with fresh bread
- Loaded Nachos: Topped with melted cheese, jalapeños, and sour cream
- Stuffed Mushrooms: Filled with herb cream cheese and breadcrumbs
“Our appetizers are crafted to be both comforting and exciting, the perfect way to start any meal at Mary Zifer’s.” – Kitchen Manager
Salads and Healthy Choices
Understanding the diverse dietary preferences of its clientele, Mary Zifer’s offers a variety of fresh salads and healthy choices that complement its pizza offerings. These options provide a lighter alternative without compromising on flavor or satisfaction.
The salads incorporate seasonal produce and house-made dressings, emphasizing freshness and vibrant taste. They are popular among health-conscious diners and anyone looking to balance indulgence with nutrition.
Each salad can be customized with protein add-ons like grilled chicken or shrimp, making them both versatile and filling. Ingredients are carefully selected to maintain a crisp texture and a harmonious flavor profile.
Popular Salad Options
- Caesar Salad: Romaine, parmesan, croutons, and creamy Caesar dressing
- Greek Salad: Mixed greens, olives, feta, cucumbers, and red onions
- House Salad: Seasonal greens, cherry tomatoes, carrots, and balsamic vinaigrette
| Salad | Calories | Protein | Key Ingredients |
| Caesar Salad | 320 | 10g | Romaine, parmesan, croutons |
| Greek Salad | 280 | 8g | Feta, olives, cucumbers |
| House Salad | 200 | 5g | Mixed greens, tomatoes, carrots |
“Freshness and balance are at the core of our salad offerings, ensuring that every bite is both nourishing and delicious.” – Nutrition Consultant
Desserts and Sweet Endings
No meal at Mary Zifer’s Pizza would be complete without indulging in their tempting dessert menu. These sweet treats are crafted to provide a perfect finish, whether you prefer something classic or a bit more adventurous.
The dessert selection features a variety of options, from warm, gooey chocolate chip cookies to rich cheesecakes and fruit-topped tarts. Each dessert is made in-house or locally sourced, emphasizing quality and freshness.
Pairing desserts with coffee or dessert wines is encouraged, enhancing the flavors and providing a well-rounded dining experience. Seasonal specials often appear, giving guests new reasons to return and explore.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet: Served warm with vanilla ice cream
- New York Cheesecake: Classic, creamy, and smooth
- Apple Crisp: Cinnamon-spiced apples with a crunchy oat topping
- Tiramisu: Coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone
Dessert Pairing Suggestions
| Dessert | Suggested Beverage | Flavor Profile |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet | Vanilla Latte | Warm, sweet, creamy |
| New York Cheesecake | Riesling Wine | Rich, tangy, smooth |
| Apple Crisp | Hot Cinnamon Tea | Spiced, fruity, crunchy |
“Desserts at Mary Zifer’s are a celebration of comfort and quality, designed to leave a lasting impression.”
Beverage Selection
Complementing the delicious food, Mary Zifer’s Pizza offers a diverse beverage menu designed to satisfy all tastes. From classic soft drinks to specialty craft beverages, the selections enhance the overall dining experience.
The beverage options include locally brewed beers, a curated wine list, and handcrafted sodas. Freshly brewed coffee and iced teas provide excellent choices for non-alcoholic refreshment.
Seasonal drinks also feature prominently, adding variety throughout the year.
Mary Zifer’s pays special attention to pairing beverages with menu items, offering recommendations to elevate flavor combinations. Whether enjoying a slice or a full meal, the right drink can transform the dining moment.
- Craft Beers: Local and regional selections rotated seasonally
- Wines: Reds, whites, and sparkling options carefully chosen
- Specialty Sodas: House-made, natural flavors like cherry vanilla and root beer
- Coffees and Teas: Freshly brewed, including espresso and herbal varieties
Beverage Pairing Guide
| Food Item | Recommended Beverage | Why It Works |
| Zifer Special Pizza | Amber Ale | Balances bold flavors with malt sweetness |
| Garden Delight Pizza | Sauvignon Blanc | Enhances fresh vegetable notes |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | IPA Beer | Cutting bitterness complements spicy heat |
“Choosing the right drink is key to unlocking the full potential of our menu’s flavors.” – Beverage Director
Family and Group Dining Options
Mary Zifer’s Pizza caters thoughtfully to families and larger groups, providing flexible dining options that accommodate varying preferences and appetites. These offerings make it an ideal spot for celebrations, casual get-togethers, and community events.
Family-sized pizzas and combo platters simplify ordering and ensure that everyone can enjoy a favorite dish. The restaurant also offers kids’ menus with smaller portions and milder flavors tailored for younger palates.
Group reservations and special event catering are available, with staff dedicated to making the experience smooth and enjoyable. This attention to detail reflects Mary Zifer’s commitment to fostering connection through food.
- Family Pizza Pack: Large pizza with two sides and drinks for four
- Party Platter: Assortment of appetizers and pizzas for groups of 8 or more
- Kids’ Menu: Mini pizzas, chicken tenders, and fruit cups
- Catering Services: Customized menus for events and meetings
“Bringing people together is at the heart of everything we do, especially when it comes to families and friends sharing a meal.”
Conclusion
Mary Zifer’s Pizza in New Philadelphia offers a menu that goes beyond ordinary expectations, merging quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and a welcoming atmosphere. From their signature pizzas to customizable options, appetizers, salads, and delightful desserts, the menu caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences.
The restaurant’s attention to detail in every dish, complemented by a carefully curated beverage list, creates a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable. Whether you are stopping by for a quick slice, celebrating with family, or enjoying a night out with friends, Mary Zifer’s ensures that each visit is marked by excellent food and friendly service.
By focusing on fresh ingredients, balanced flavors, and community values, Mary Zifer’s Pizza remains a top choice in New Philadelphia. Its menu reflects a passion for food and hospitality that invites guests to return time and again, discovering new favorites while savoring familiar comforts.
Experience the taste of tradition and innovation combined in every bite at Mary Zifer’s.
