There’s a unique magic that envelops you as you step inside Johnny’s New York Style Pizza. The inviting aroma of freshly baked dough mingles with the gentle hum of conversation, instantly transporting you to a bustling New York pizzeria.
Johnny’s has become a beloved staple for pizza enthusiasts, offering a menu that combines the authenticity of classic New York flavors with an innovative twist. Whether you’re a lifelong devotee of thin, foldable slices or a newcomer eager to savor iconic pies, Johnny’s menu promises a memorable culinary adventure.
With every visit, guests are greeted by a vibrant setting, enthusiastic staff, and, most importantly, a diverse menu that caters to every craving. From hearty, cheese-laden pizzas to crisp salads and mouthwatering desserts, Johnny’s New York Style Pizza menu is a testament to quality, tradition, and an unyielding passion for great food.
Explore the menu’s highlights, discover new favorites, and learn what sets Johnny’s apart as a cornerstone of pizza culture.
The Iconic New York Style Pizza Selection
At the heart of Johnny’s menu lies its legendary New York style pizza. Known for its thin, hand-tossed crust and generous toppings, every pizza is crafted to deliver a true slice of the Big Apple.
The dough is always made fresh, resulting in that signature crispy-yet-chewy bite that distinguishes New York style from other pizza varieties.
Guests can choose from an impressive array of specialty pizzas or customize their own creations. Each pizza is baked to perfection, with bubbling cheese and a robust tomato sauce that elevates every bite.
The menu features both traditional and innovative options, ensuring there’s something for every palate.
What truly sets Johnny’s pizza apart is their commitment to quality ingredients. Only the freshest mozzarella, premium meats, and garden-fresh vegetables are used, and every pie is finished with care.
Whether you’re a fan of classic combinations or adventurous flavors, Johnny’s delivers with consistency and flair.
Popular Signature Pizzas
- Johnny’s Deluxe: A feast of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
- Quattro Formaggi: A cheese lover’s dream with mozzarella, provolone, parmesan, and romano.
- Buffalo Chicken: Spicy buffalo sauce, tender chicken, and a drizzle of ranch dressing.
- Margherita: Fresh basil, sliced tomatoes, and mozzarella on a garlic-infused crust.
“Our pizzas are inspired by the spirit of New York—crafted with tradition, baked with passion, and served with a smile.” – Johnny, Founder
If you’re craving a personalized pie, Johnny’s offers a build-your-own option. Start with the classic thin crust, select your sauce, and choose from a broad array of toppings — from savory Italian sausage to sweet pineapple.
The customizable approach ensures every guest leaves satisfied.
Appetizers and Sides to Start Your Meal
Before diving into a main course, Johnny’s appetizers set the stage for a memorable meal. These starters are thoughtfully curated to complement the pizza experience, offering a balance of comfort and creativity.
Each item is made to order, guaranteeing freshness and flavor in every bite.
From baked classics to shareable plates, the appetizer menu caters to both solo diners and groups. The portions are generous, making them perfect for sharing with friends or family.
Expect a blend of classic Italian favorites and inventive new additions.
Johnny’s places a strong emphasis on using high-quality ingredients, even in its starters. This dedication ensures every appetizer, whether simple or elaborate, exceeds expectations.
The flavors are bold, the textures satisfying, and the choices diverse.
Must-Try Appetizers
- Garlic Knots: Freshly baked dough tied into knots, brushed with garlic butter, and served with marinara.
- Fried Ravioli: Cheese-filled ravioli, lightly breaded and fried, with a side of tangy tomato sauce.
- Cheesy Breadsticks: Soft breadsticks topped with a blend of cheeses and herbs.
- Wings: Available in a selection of house-made sauces, from mild to extra spicy.
Each appetizer is crafted to tease the palate without overwhelming it. For those who love bold flavors, the wings are a standout, with sauces like Buffalo, BBQ, and Garlic Parmesan.
Shareable sides like mozzarella sticks provide a nostalgic touch, while the garlic knots are a perennial favorite.
Pair your starter with a signature dipping sauce. Johnny’s offers both traditional marinara and zesty ranch, allowing you to customize every bite.
Appetizers here aren’t just an afterthought—they’re a key part of the Johnny’s experience.
Classic and Gourmet Pizza Toppings
Johnny’s menu stands out for its extensive collection of pizza toppings. These options let diners customize their pizzas to suit their tastes, whether they prefer traditional flavors or more adventurous combinations.
Each topping is selected for its freshness and flavor, contributing to the overall quality of every pizza.
The toppings menu spans a wide variety of meats, vegetables, cheeses, and specialty ingredients. Every item is prepared daily to ensure the highest standards of taste and presentation.
This attention to detail means that each bite is as satisfying as the last.
Customizing your pizza at Johnny’s is a highly personal experience. Whether you’re a purist who loves pepperoni and mushrooms or someone looking to try artichoke hearts and sun-dried tomatoes, the options are nearly endless.
The staff is always happy to recommend combinations based on your preferences.
Build-Your-Own Pizza Toppings
- Meats: Pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, grilled chicken, ham, anchovies
- Vegetables: Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, spinach, jalapeños, tomatoes
- Cheeses: Mozzarella, feta, ricotta, provolone, parmesan
- Specialty: Pineapple, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers
| Topping | Flavor Profile | Popular Pairings |
| Pepperoni | Spicy, savory | Mushrooms, onions |
| Artichoke Hearts | Earthy, mild | Ricotta, spinach |
| Jalapeños | Spicy, crisp | Chicken, bacon |
| Feta Cheese | Tangy, creamy | Tomatoes, black olives |
Experimentation is encouraged, and many guests discover new favorites by mixing and matching toppings. Signature pies often feature unique combinations, such as grilled chicken with sun-dried tomatoes and feta, or bacon with jalapeños and onions.
The balance of textures and flavors is always a priority at Johnny’s.
Fresh Salads and Lighter Fare
For those seeking a lighter option, Johnny’s salad selection provides a refreshing counterpoint to the heartier pizza offerings. Each salad is made with crisp, locally sourced greens and vibrant vegetables.
Dressings are prepared in-house, ensuring a burst of fresh flavor in every forkful.
The salads at Johnny’s are far from an afterthought. They’re crafted with the same care and attention as the pizzas, often featuring signature touches like homemade croutons or marinated meats.
Portion sizes are generous, making salads a satisfying meal on their own or a perfect side to share.
Guests can choose from classic favorites or more inventive creations. The menu includes both vegetarian-friendly and protein-packed options, making it easy for everyone to find something they love.
Salads are served chilled, ensuring each bite is crisp and refreshing.
Signature Salads
- Greek Salad: Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives, and feta, tossed in Greek dressing.
- Caesar Salad: Crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, homemade croutons, and creamy Caesar dressing.
- Chef Salad: Mixed greens, turkey, ham, mozzarella, egg, and grape tomatoes, served with your choice of dressing.
- House Salad: Fresh greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, and shredded mozzarella.
“Our salads are designed to be as memorable as our pizzas—fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and always made to order.” – Johnny’s Head Chef
For guests with dietary preferences, salads can be customized with add-ons like grilled chicken, anchovies, or extra cheese. The flexibility ensures that everyone can enjoy a meal tailored to their tastes.
Don’t miss the house-made vinaigrette, a favorite among regulars for its tangy, herbaceous flavor.
Pasta Dishes and Italian Classics
Johnny’s menu extends beyond pizza, offering an array of Italian classics that pay homage to traditional recipes. The pasta dishes are rich, comforting, and crafted from timeless ingredients.
Every dish is made fresh, with pasta cooked al dente and sauces simmered to perfection.
Guests can choose from both hearty and lighter pasta options. Each plate is served with a generous portion of garlic bread, making for a satisfying and complete meal.
The Italian classics provide a delicious alternative for those seeking something different from pizza.
The kitchen’s dedication to authenticity shines through in every bite. Sauces are made from scratch, meats are carefully seasoned, and cheeses are melted to golden perfection.
The result is a menu that celebrates the depth and diversity of Italian cuisine.
Popular Pasta Dishes
- Spaghetti Marinara: Classic spaghetti served with Johnny’s signature marinara sauce.
- Chicken Alfredo: Grilled chicken breast over fettuccine noodles with creamy Alfredo sauce.
- Baked Ziti: Ziti pasta baked with ricotta, mozzarella, and marinara, topped with parmesan.
- Lasagna: Layers of pasta, seasoned beef, ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce, baked to perfection.
| Pasta Dish | Sauce | Main Protein |
| Chicken Alfredo | Creamy Alfredo | Grilled Chicken |
| Lasagna | Tomato & Cheese | Ground Beef |
| Baked Ziti | Marinara & Cheese | Ricotta (Vegetarian) |
Guests often praise the baked ziti for its gooey, cheese-laden comfort and the lasagna for its hearty, home-cooked taste. For a lighter alternative, the pasta primavera features sautéed vegetables in a light olive oil sauce, highlighting Johnny’s commitment to fresh, seasonal produce.
Calzones, Strombolis, and Oven-Baked Specialties
For those who crave something beyond traditional pizza, Johnny’s offers a tempting selection of calzones, strombolis, and other oven-baked specialties. These dishes are crafted with the same fresh dough and premium ingredients that define the menu’s quality.
Each bite delivers a satisfying blend of flavors and textures.
Calzones are stuffed with cheeses, meats, and vegetables, then baked to a golden brown. Strombolis, on the other hand, are rolled and filled with a variety of toppings before being sliced and served with dipping sauces.
Both options provide a delightful twist on the classic pizza experience.
The oven-baked specialties are perfect for guests seeking something hearty and portable. Each dish is made to order, ensuring a hot, fresh meal every time.
The options are equally suited to a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner.
Favorite Oven-Baked Specialties
- Classic Calzone: Ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of two toppings, served with marinara.
- Italian Stromboli: Pepperoni, ham, salami, and mozzarella, rolled in dough and baked.
- Veggie Calzone: Spinach, mushrooms, onions, and mozzarella inside a golden crust.
- Meat Lover’s Stromboli: A hearty mix of Italian sausage, bacon, pepperoni, and cheese.
“Our calzones and strombolis capture the spirit of New York street food—warm, flavorful, and made to share.” – Johnny’s Culinary Team
Each specialty comes with a side of Johnny’s signature marinara or garlic butter for dipping. Guests can customize their calzones and strombolis, choosing from a wide array of fillings to suit their preferences.
It’s a hands-on way to enjoy the bold flavors Johnny’s is known for.
Oven-baked specialties are ideal for those seeking a hearty, satisfying meal. The combination of crisp crust, melted cheese, and savory fillings makes these dishes a standout on Johnny’s menu.
Subs, Sandwiches, and Handheld Favorites
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza isn’t just about pizza and Italian fare. The menu boasts a collection of hearty subs and sandwiches, each designed to satisfy even the biggest appetites.
These handheld favorites are made with freshly baked bread, premium meats, and vibrant toppings.
Subs and sandwiches are available hot or cold, with options ranging from classic Italian combos to inventive new creations. Each is generously portioned and served with a side of chips or fries, making for a complete and filling meal.
What makes Johnny’s subs unique is their commitment to bold, authentic flavors. Every sandwich is crafted with attention to texture and taste, ensuring a perfect balance in every bite.
Popular Sub Sandwiches
- Italian Sub: Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, and Italian dressing on a hoagie roll.
- Meatball Parmesan: House-made meatballs, marinara, and melted mozzarella on toasted bread.
- Chicken Parmesan: Breaded chicken breast, marinara, and mozzarella, baked until bubbly.
- Philly Cheesesteak: Sliced steak, sautéed onions, green peppers, and provolone.
| Sandwich | Main Ingredients | Style |
| Italian Sub | Ham, Salami, Pepperoni | Cold |
| Meatball Parmesan | Meatballs, Marinara, Mozzarella | Hot |
| Chicken Parmesan | Breaded Chicken, Marinara, Mozzarella | Hot |
| Philly Cheesesteak | Steak, Onions, Peppers, Provolone | Hot |
Each sub is customizable, with options to add extra cheese, swap out toppings, or request gluten-free bread. The sandwiches are ideal for lunch or dinner and pair perfectly with a side salad or fries.
Guests often rave about the meatball parmesan for its rich sauce and tender meatballs.
Whether you’re craving a classic or something more unique, Johnny’s subs and sandwiches deliver satisfaction with every bite.
Desserts and Sweet Finishes
No meal at Johnny’s is complete without a sweet ending. The dessert menu features a curated selection of Italian-inspired treats, each designed to satisfy your sweet tooth.
From creamy classics to rich, chocolatey delights, there’s something for every dessert lover.
Each dessert is made with high-quality ingredients, ensuring a memorable finish to your meal. The selection includes both individual and shareable options, making it easy to indulge solo or with friends.
Classic Italian recipes are given a Johnny’s twist for a unique touch.
Desserts are prepared fresh daily, and the menu often features seasonal specials. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just capping off a great meal, the dessert offerings provide the perfect final note.
Favorite Desserts
- New York Cheesecake: Creamy, dense cheesecake with a graham cracker crust, served plain or with fruit topping.
- Tiramisu: Layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone, and cocoa powder.
- Chocolate Lava Cake: Warm chocolate cake with a gooey molten center, served with vanilla ice cream.
- Cannoli: Crisp pastry shells filled with sweetened ricotta and chocolate chips.
“Dessert is the final impression—each bite should linger and leave you dreaming of your next visit.” – Johnny’s Pastry Chef
Dessert portions are generous, making them perfect for sharing after a hearty meal. The New York cheesecake is a customer favorite, celebrated for its creamy texture and rich flavor.
For something more decadent, the chocolate lava cake never disappoints.
Pair your dessert with a hot espresso or cappuccino for a truly authentic Italian experience. The sweet finishes at Johnny’s are a celebration of tradition, creativity, and the simple joy of a great meal.
Drinks, Pairings, and the Johnny’s Experience
To round out the meal, Johnny’s offers a thoughtfully curated drink menu. Guests can choose from a selection of sodas, iced teas, and sparkling waters, as well as a range of local and imported beers.
The beverage options are designed to complement the bold flavors of the food menu.
Wine lovers will appreciate Johnny’s list of reds and whites, with pairings suggested for each major dish. Whether you’re enjoying a classic pepperoni pizza or a plate of chicken alfredo, there’s a perfect pour to enhance the experience.
Non-alcoholic options are also abundant, ensuring everyone finds something to enjoy.
The atmosphere at Johnny’s is lively and welcoming, making it an ideal spot for everything from family gatherings to date nights. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, always ready to recommend the perfect drink or dish.
The overall experience is one of warmth, hospitality, and genuine passion for great food.
Recommended Pairings
- Margherita Pizza with Pinot Grigio: The crisp, citrus notes of the wine enhance the fresh basil and tomatoes.
- Meatball Parmesan Sub with Amber Ale: The malty beer complements the rich, savory flavors.
- Baked Ziti with Chianti: The classic Italian red brings out the best in the tomato and cheese sauce.
- Chocolate Lava Cake with Espresso: The bold coffee balances the sweet, molten chocolate.
| Dish | Beverage Pairing | Flavor Benefit |
| Pepperoni Pizza | IPA Beer | Balances spicy and savory notes |
| Greek Salad | Sparkling Water | Refreshes palate between bites |
| Chicken Alfredo | Chardonnay | Enhances creamy sauce |
Every element of the Johnny’s experience is designed to delight, from the first sip to the last bite. The right pairing can elevate a meal, highlighting subtle flavors and adding depth to your dining adventure.
With attentive service and a convivial atmosphere, Johnny’s ensures guests return again and again.
The Johnny’s Difference: Tradition Meets Innovation
What makes Johnny’s New York Style Pizza truly exceptional is its seamless blend of tradition and innovation. While the menu honors classic recipes and time-honored techniques, there’s an ongoing commitment to creativity and improvement.
This approach ensures the offerings remain relevant and exciting, no matter how many times you visit.
Johnny’s invests in ongoing staff training, sourcing the best ingredients, and listening to customer feedback. The result is a menu that evolves while staying true to its roots.
Guests feel valued, knowing their favorite dishes will always deliver the same great taste and quality.
Specials are a regular feature, introducing new flavors and limited-time offerings. Seasonal ingredients are spotlighted, and dietary preferences are accommodated with gluten-free and vegetarian choices.
The menu’s flexibility and variety are hallmarks of Johnny’s commitment to customer satisfaction.
“At Johnny’s, we’re dedicated to serving more than just food—we’re creating experiences, one slice at a time.” – Johnny, Founder
It’s the passion behind every dish, the attention to detail, and the welcoming environment that set Johnny’s apart. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time guest, the Johnny’s difference is evident from the moment you walk through the door.
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza menu is more than just a list of dishes—it’s a celebration of flavor, tradition, and hospitality. Every item is crafted with care, from the iconic pizzas to the decadent desserts.
The extensive menu ensures there’s something for everyone, whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice, a hearty sub, or a fresh salad. The commitment to quality ingredients and authentic techniques shines through in every bite.
Johnny’s welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make every meal memorable, whether you’re dining in, taking out, or ordering for delivery. With a blend of beloved classics and innovative new creations, Johnny’s continues to set the standard for New York style pizza and Italian cuisine.
Discover your new favorite dish, savor the friendly environment, and become part of a tradition that celebrates the simple joy of good food shared with great company.
